The effect of compliance to a Rigo System Cheneau brace and a specific exercise programme on idiopathic scoliosis curvature: a comparative study: SOSORT 2014 award winner

Scoliosis

Joanne Potterton¹  Aimee Stewart¹  LouAnn Rivett¹ 

[1] Physiotherapy Department, School of Therapeutic Sciences, Faculty of Health Sciences, University of the Witwatersrand, Johannesburg, South Africa

关键词: Scoliosis exercise;    RSC brace;    Personality traits;    Quality of life;    Compliance;    Spinal curvature;    Spinal deformity;    Adolescent Idiopathic scoliosis;   

Others  :  791076
DOI  :  10.1186/1748-7161-9-5

 received in 2014-05-22, accepted in 2014-05-26,  发布年份 2014

【 摘 要 】

Background

There is controversy as to whether conservative management that includes wearing a brace and exercises is effective in stabilising idiopathic scoliosis curves. A brace only prevents progression of the curve and has been shown to have favourable outcomes when patients are compliant. So the aim of this study was to: determine the effect of compliance to the Rigo System Cheneau (RSC) brace and a specific exercise programme on Idiopathic Scoliosis curvature; and to compare the Quality of Life (QoL) and psychological traits of compliant and non compliant subjects.

Methods

A pre/post test study design was used with a post study comparison between subjects who complied with the management and those who did not. Fifty one subjects, girls aged 12-16 years, Cobb angles 20-50 degrees participated in the study. Subjects were divided into two groups, according to their compliance, at the end of the study. The compliant group wore the brace 20 or more hours a day and exercised three or more times per week. The non-compliant group wore the brace less than 20 hours a day and exercised less than three times per week. Cobb angles, vertebral rotation, scoliometer readings, peak flow, quality of life and personality traits were compared between groups, using the student’s two sample t-test and an analysis of covariance.

Results

The compliant group, wore the brace 21.5 hours per day and exercised four times a week, and significantly improved in all measures compared to non compliant subjects, who wore the brace 12 hours per day, exercised 1.7 times a week and significantly deteriorated (p < 0.0001). The major Cobb angles in the compliant group improved 10.19°(±5.5) and deteriorated 5.52°(±4.3) in the non compliant group (p < 0.0001). Compliant subjects had a significantly better QoL than the non compliant subjects (p = 0.001). The compliant group were significantly more emotionally mature, stable and realistic than the non compliant group (p = 0.03).

Conclusions

Good compliance of the RSC brace and a specific exercise regime resulted in a significant improvement in curvatures, poor compliance resulted in progression/deterioration. A poorer QoL in the non compliant group possibly was caused by personality traits of the group, being more emotionally immature and unstable.

【 授权许可】

   
2014 Rivett et al.; licensee BioMed Central Ltd.

【 参考文献 】

• [1]Harrington PM: Is scoliosis reversible? In vivo observations of reversible morphological changes in the production of scoliosis in mice. Clin Orthop Relat Res 1976, 116:103-111.
• [2]Mehta MH: Pain provoked scoliosis. Clin Orthop Relat Res 1978, 135:58-65.
• [3]Asher M: Harrington’s: The Human Spine. In Pathogenesis of Idiopathic Scoliosis. Edited by Joabobs RR. Chicago, IL: Scoliosis Research Society; 1984:1-10.
• [4]Hawes MC: Scoliosis and the Human Spine. A Critical Review of Clinical Approaches to Treatment of Spinal Deformity. Tucsan, Az, USA: West Press; 2002:12-51.
• [5]Weiss HR: Rehabilitation of adolescent patients with scoliosis- what do we know? A review of the literature. Pediatr Rehabil 2003, 6(3–4):183-194.
• [6]Weiss HR, Weiss G, Schaar H: Incidence of surgery in conservatively treated patients with scoliosis. Pediatr Rehabil 2003, 6(2):1-8.
• [7]Asher MA, Burton DC: Adolescent idiopathic scoliosis: natural history and long term side effects. Scoliosis 2006, 1:2. BioMed Central Full Text
• [8]Lou E, Hill D, Raso J: Brace treatment for adolescent idiopathic scoliosis. Stud Health Technol Inform 2008, 135:265-273.
• [9]Dickson RA, Weinstein SL: Bracing and screening- yes or no? J Bone Joint Surg 1999, 81:193-198.
• [10]Rowe DE, Bernstein SM, Riddick MF, Adler F, Emans JB, Gardener-Bonneau D: A meta-analysis of the efficacy of non-operative treatments for idiopathic scoliosis. J Bone Joint Surg 1997, 79(5):664-674.
• [11]Negrini S, Grivas TB: Introduction to the “Scoliosis” journal brace technology thematic series: increasing existing knowledge and promoting future developements. Scoliosis 2010, 5:2. BioMed Central Full Text
• [12]Zaina F, Negrini S, Atanasio S, Fusco C, Romano M: Specific exercises performed in the period of brace weaning can avoid loss of correction in adolescent idiopathic scoliosis. Scoliosis 2009, 4:8. BioMed Central Full Text
• [13]Rigo M: Radiological and cosmetic improvement 2 years after brace weaning- a case report. Pediatr Rehabil 2003, 6(3–4):195-199.
• [14]Weiss HR, Weiss G, Petermann F: Incidence of curvature progression in idiopathic scoliosis patients treated with scoliosis inpatient rehabilitation (SIR): an age and sex- matched controlled study. Pediatr Rehabil 2003, 6:23-30.
• [15]Weiss HR, Negrini S, Rigo M, Kotwicki T, Hawes MC, Grivas TB, Maruyama T, Landauer F: Indications for conservative management of scoliosis (guidelines). Scoliosis 2006, 1:5. BioMed Central Full Text
• [16]Negrini A, Atanasio S, Fusco C, Zaina F: Effectiveness of conservative treatment for adolecent scoliosis (bracing and exercises) based on SOSORT management criteria; results according to the SRS criteria for bracing studies. Scoliosis 2009, 4:19. BioMed Central Full Text
• [17]Rigo M: 3D correction of trunk deformity in patients with idiopathic scoliosis using cheneau brace. In Research into spinal deformities 2. I. A. F. Stokes. Amsterdam: IOS Press; 1999:362-365.
• [18]Negrini A, Grivas TB, Kotwicki T, Maruyama T, Rigo M, Weiss HR: Why do we treat adolescent idiopathic scoliosis? What we want to obtain and to avoid for our patients. SOSORT 2005 Consensus Paper. Scoliosis 2006, 1:4. BioMed Central Full Text
• [19]Emans JB, Kablin A, Bancel P: Boston bracing system for idiopathic scoliosis: Follow-up results in 295 patients. Spine 1986, 11:792-801.
• [20]Fernandez-Feliberti R, Flynn J, Ramirez N: Effectiveness of TSLO bracing in the conservative treatment of idiopathic scoliosis. J Paediatr Orthop 1995, 15:176-178.
• [21]Goldberg CJ, Moore DP, Fogarty EE, Dowling FE: The effect of brace treatment on the incidence of surgery. Spine 2001, 26:42-47.
• [22]Rahman T, Bowen JR, Takemitsu M, Scott C: The association between brace compliance and outcome for patients with idiopathic scoliosis. J Pediatr Orthop 2005, 25(4):420-422.
• [23]Weinstein SL, Dolan LA, Wright JG, Dobbs MB: Effects of bracing in adolescents with idiopathic scoliosis. N Engl J Med 2013, 369:1512-1521.
• [24]Landauer F, Wimmer C, Behensky H: Estimating the final outcome of brace treatment for idiopathic scoliosis at 6-month follow-up. Pediatr Rehabil 2003, 6(3–4):201-207.
• [25]Weiss HR, Rigo M: The cheneau concept of bracing- actual standards. Stud Health Technol Inform 2008, 135:291-302.
• [26]Maruyama T, Kitagawa T, Takeshita K, Nakamura K: Side shift exercise for the treatment of IS after skeletal maturity. Stud Health Technol Inform 2002, 91:361-364.
• [27]Hawes MC: The use of exercises in the treatment of scoliosis: an evidence - based critical review of the literature. Pediatr Rehabil 2003, 6(3–4):171-182.
• [28]Negrini S, Zaina F, Romano M, Negrini A, Parzini S: Specific exercises reduce brace prescription in adolescent scoliosis: a prospective controlled cohort study with worst - case analysis. J Rehabil Med 2008, 40(6):451-455.
• [29]Mehta MH: Infantile Idiopathic Scoliosis. In Management of Spinal Deformities. Edited by Bradford DS, Dickson R. Boston, MA: Butterworths; 1984:101-120.
• [30]Stokes IAF: Hueter-Volkmann effect: state of the art reviews. Spine 2000, 14:349-357.
• [31]Negrini A, Fusco C, Minozzi S, Atanasio S, Zaina F, Romano M: Exercises reduce the progression rate of adolescent scoliosis: results of a comprehensive systematic review of the literature. Disabil Rehabil 2008, 30(10):772-785.
• [32]Fusco C, Zaina F, Atanasio S, Romano M, Negrini A, Negrini S: Physical exercises in the treatment of adolescent idiopathic scoliosis: an updated systematic review. Physiother Theory Pract 2011, 27(1):80-114.
• [33]Wan L, Wang G-X, Bian R: Exercise therapy in treatment of essential s-shaped scoliosis: Evaluation of cobb angle in breast and lumbar segment through a follow-up of half a year. Chin J Clin Rehabil 2005, 9:82-84.
• [34]Reichel D, Schanz J: Developemental psychological aspects of scoliosis treatment. Pediatr Rehabil 2003, 6(3–4):221-225.
• [35]Weiss HR, Werkmann M, Stephan C: Brace related stress in scoliosis patients- comparison of different concepts of bracing. Scoliosis 2007, 2:10. BioMed Central Full Text
• [36]Korovessis P, Stamatakis M, Baikousis A, Kirkos C, Kavouris A: Vertical transmission of the hip rolls due to wearing of TLSO for scoliosis. J Spinal Disord 1996, 9:326-333.
• [37]Freidel K, Reichel D, Steiner A, Warschburger P, Petermann F, Weiss HR: Idiopathic scoliosis and quality of life. Stud Health Technol Inform 2002, 88:24-29.
• [38]Vasiliadis E, Grivas TB, Gkoltsiou K: Developement and preliminary validation of the brace questionnaire: a new instrument for measuring quality of life of brace treated scoliotics. Scoliosis 2006, 1:7. BioMed Central Full Text
• [39]Maruyama T: Bracing adolescent idiopathic scoliosis: a systematic review of the literature of effective conservative treatment looking for end results 5 years after weaning. Disabil Rehabil 2008, 30(10):786-791.
• [40]Tones M, Moss N, Polly DWJ: A review of quality of life and psychological issues in scoliosis. Spine 2006, 31(26):3027-3038.
• [41]Vasililiadis E, Grivas TB: Quality of life after conservative treatment of adolescent idiopathic scoliosis. Stud Health Technol Inform 2008, 135:409-413.
• [42]Kotwicki T, Kinel E, Stryla W, Szulc A: Estimation of the stress related to conservative scoliosis therapy: an analysis based on BSSQ questionnaires. Scoliosis 2007, 2:1. BioMed Central Full Text
• [43]Rivett LA, Rothberg A, Stewart A, Berkowitz R: The relationship between quality of life and compliance to a brace protocol in adolescents with idiopathic scoliosis: a comparative study. BMC Muculoskelet Disord 2009, 10:5. BioMed Central Full Text
• [44]Cattell RB: The Scientific Analysis of Personality. Chicago: Aldine Publishing Company; 1965.
• [45]Cattell RB, Cattell DL: Manual for the High School Personality Questionnaire. 3rd edition. Edited by Visser MJ, Garbers Strauss J, Prinsloo CH. Craighall, South Africa: Jopie Van Rooyen and Partners; 2003:1-53.
• [46]Grant WH: “How we develop our personality types”. 2010. [http://personalitycafe.com/myers-briggs-forum/1037-how-personality-types-develop.html webcite]
• [47]Cattell RB, Cattell DL: Handbook for the Jr-Sr. High School Personality Questionnaire. Illinois: Institute for Personality and Ability Testing. Charnpaign; 1975:6-8.
• [48]Cattel HE, Schuerger JM: Essentials of the 16PF. New York: John Wiley and Sons; 2003.
• [49]Izumi Y: The accuracy of Risser staging. Spine 1995, 20(17):1868-1871.
• [50]Bunnell WP: Nonoperative treatment of spinal deformity: the case for observation. Instr Course Lect 1985, 34:106-109.
• [51]Gaskell DV, Webber BA: Medical Conditions. In The Brompton Hospital Guide to Chest Physiotherapy. 5th edition. London: Blackwell Scientific Publications; 1988:34-36.
• [52]Vasililiadis E, Grivas TB, Savvidou G, Triantafyllopoulos G: The influence of the brace on quality of life of adolescents with idiopathic scoliosis. Stud Health Technol Inform 2006, 123:352-356.
• [53]Hopf C: Criteria for treatment of idiopathic scoliosis between 40 degrees and 50 degrees: surgical vs conservative therapy. Orthopade 2000, 29(6):500-506.
• [54]Hawes MC: Impact of spine surgery on signs and symptoms of spinal deformity. Pediatr Rehabil 2006, 9(4):318-391.
• [55]Durmala J, Detko E, Krawczyk K: Values of thoracic kyphosis and lumbar lordosis in adolescents from Czestochowa. Scoliosis 2009, 4:053.
• [56]Rigo M: A series of patients with adolescent idiopathic scoliosis treated with the Rigo System Cheneau (RSC) brace. Primary correction in brace improved by technical evolution. Scoliosis 2007, 2:S11. BioMed Central Full Text
• [57]Rigo M, Gallo D: A new RSC brace design to treat single long thoracic scoliosis. Comparison of the in-brace correction in two groups treated with the new and the classical models. Scoliosis 2009, 4:046.
• [58]Weiss H, Rigo M: Expert- driven Cheneau applications: Description and in-brace corrections. Physiother Theory Pract 2011, 27(1):61-67.
• [59]Wood GI: Comparison of Surface Topography and X-ray Values during Idiopathic Scoliosis Treatment using the Cheneau Brace. In Degree of Master of Science Research. Salford, UK: Institute for Health, School of Health Care Professions. University of Salford; 2003.
• [60]Kotwicki T, Pietrzak S, Sculc A: Three-dimensional action of Cheneau brace on thoracolumbar scoliosis. Research in Spinal Deformities 3. In Stud Health Technol Inform, Volume 88. Edited by Tanguy A, Peuchot B. Amsterdam: IOS Press; 2002:226-229.
• [61]Gallo D, Wood G, Dallmayer R: Quality control of idiopathic scoliosis treatment in 147 patients while using the RSC brace. (Am) J Prosthet Orthot 2011, 23(2):69-77.
• [62]Edgar MA: Brace Wear Compliance. In Scoliosis Research Society Bracing Manual. London, UK: Scoliosis Research Society; 1998:1-9.
• [63]Kinel E, Kotwicki T, Stryla W, Szulc A: Adolescent girls with idiopathic scoliosis< 40 degrees, treated with the TLSO brace, reveal less clinical deformity than non-treated girls having sililar scoliosis angle. Scoliosis 2007, 2(Suppl 1):S16. BioMed Central Full Text
• [64]Durmala J, Kotwicki T, Piotrowski J: Cheneau bracing with dobomed physiotherapy for thoracic scoliosis: prospective evaluation of 25 patients followed to skeletal maturity. Scoliosis 2010, 5(Suppl 1):075. BioMed Central Full Text
• [65]Zaborowska-Sapeta K, Kowalski IM, Kotwicki T, Protasiewicz-Faldowska H, Kiebzakw W: Effectiveness of cheneau brace treatment for idiopathic scoliosis: prospective study in 79 patients followed to skeletal maturity. Scoliosis 2011, 6:2. BioMed Central Full Text
• [66]Takemitsu M, Bowen JR, Rahman T, Glutting JJ, Scott CB: Compliance monitoring of brace treatment for patients with idiopathic scoliosis. Spine 2004, 29(18):2070-2074.
• [67]Donzelli S, Zaina F, Negrini S: Is it possible to make patients use braces the hours prescribed: first results from the thermobrace clinical everyday usage. Scoliosis 2012, 7(Suppl 1):029. BioMed Central Full Text
• [68]Weiss HR: “Best Practice” in conservative scoliosis care. Munich: Pflaum Verlag; 2006:3-47.
• [69]Dobosiewicz K, Durmala J, Kotwicki T: Dobosiewicz method physiotherapy for idiopathic scoliosis. Stud Health Technol Inform 2008, 135:228-236.
• [70]Rigo M: Influence of physiotherapy and bracing on the deformity of the trunk in patients with idiopathic scoliosis. Proceeding of the 2nd S.I.R.E.R. meeting, Barcelona 1996.
• [71]Cinnella P, Muratore M, Testa E, Bondente PG: The treatment of adolescent idiopathic scoliosis with Cheneau brace: long term outcome. Scoliosis 2009, 4:044.
• [72]Rigo M, Quera-Salva G, Puigdevall N, Martinez M: Retrospective results in immature idiopathic scoliotic patients treated with a Cheneau brace. Stud Health Technol Inform 2002, 88:241-245.
• [73]Maruyama T, Miura M, Sasaki G, Kitagawa T: Outcomes of brace treatment for adolescent idiopathic scoliosis. Scoliosis 2007, 2(Suppl 1):S17. BioMed Central Full Text
• [74]Pham VM, Herbaux B, Schill A, Thevenon A: Evaluation of the Cheneau brace in adolescent idiopathic scoliosis. Ann Phys Rehabil Med 2007, 50(3):125-133.
• [75]Rigo M, Weiss H: The cheneau concept of bracing- Biomechanical Aspects. Stud Health Technol Inform 2008, 135:303-319.
• [76]Perdriolle R, Vidal J: Morphology of scoliosis: three-dimensional evolution. Orthopedics 1987, 10(6):909-915.
• [77]Cheneau J, Chekrizhev D, Mezentsev A, Petrenko D: Treatment of the congenital scoliosis by Cheneau brace: 2 year follow-up. Scoliosis 2009, 4:045.
• [78]Rigo M, Villagrasa M, Quera-Salva G: Vertebral deformity corrected by bracing: retrospective selected case series of 10 scoliosis patients treated with a RSC brace. Scoliosis 2009, 4:045.
• [79]Kinel E, Kotwicki T, Stryla W, Szulc A: Adolescent girls with idiopathic scoliosis > 45 degrees, treated with TLSO brace, reveal clinical less deformity than non-treated girls having a similar scoliosis angle. Scoliosis 2007, 2(Suppl 1):S15. BioMed Central Full Text
• [80]Rigo M, Quera-Salva G, Villagrasa M, Ferrer M, Casas A: Effect of specific exercises on the sagittal profile of scoliotic spines. Scoliosis 2007, 2:S7. BioMed Central Full Text
• [81]Durmala J, Dobosiewicz K, Jendrzejek H, Puis W: Exercise efficiency of girls with idiopathic scoliosis based on ventilatory anaerobic threshold. Stud Health Technol Inform 2002, 91:357-360.
• [82]Weiss HR: The effect of an exercise program on VC and rib mobility in patients with IS. Spine 1991, 16(1):88-93.
• [83]Weiss HR, Bickert W: Improvement of the parameters of right-heart stress evidenced by electrocardiographic examinations by the in-patient rehabilitation program according to Schroth in adult patients with scoliosis. Orthop Praxis 1996, 32:450-453.
• [84]Otman S, Kose N, Yakut Y: The efficiency of Schroth 3-dimensional exercise therapy in the treatment of adolescent idiopathic scoliosis in Turkey. Saudi Med J 2005, 26:1429-1435.
• [85]Freidel K, Petermann F, Reichel D, Warschburger P, Weiss HR: Medical and psychosocial outcome of scoliosis in-patient rehabilitation. Scoliosis 2009, 4:061.
• [86]Dos Santos Alves VL, Stirbulov R, Avanzi O: Impact of a physical rehabilitation program on the respiratory function of adolescents with idiopathic scoliosis. Chest 2006, 130:500-505.
• [87]Dos Santos Alves VL, Avanzi O: Objective assessment of the cardiorespiratory function of adolescents with idiopathic scoliosis through the six-minute walk test. Spine 2009, 34(25):E926-E929.
• [88]Durmala J, Tomalak W, Kotwicki T: Function of the respiratory system in patients with idiopathic scoliosis: reasons for impairment and methods of evaluation. In The Conservative Scoliosis Treatment. 1st SOSORT Instructional Course Lecteurs Book. Edited by Grivas TB. Greece: IOS Press; 2008:237-245.
• [89]Wright BM, McKerrow CB: Maximum forced expiratory flow rate as a measure of ventilatory capacity. BMJ 1959, 2:1041-1047.
• [90]Wright BM: A miniature Wright peak flow meter. BMJ 1978, 2:1627-1628.
• [91]Eisinger DB, Kumar R, Woodrow R: Effect of lumbar orthotics on trunk muscle strength. Am J Phys Med Rehabil 1996, 75(3):194-197.
• [92]Shephard RJ: Aging and Exercise. In Encyclopedia of Sports Medicine and Science Edited by Fahey TD. 1998. Internet Society for Sport Science: http://sportsci.org webcite. 7 March 1998
• [93]Rivett LA, Rothberg A, Stewart A, Berkowitz R: Application of different measures of skeletal maturity in initiating weaning from a brace for scoliosis: two case reports. J Med Case Rep 2009, 3:6444. BioMed Central Full Text
• [94]Escalada F, Marco E, Belmonte R, Duarte E, Muniesa JM, Boza R, Tejero M, Caceres E: Assessment of angle velocity in girls with adolescent idiopathic scoliosis. Scoliosis 2009, 4:23. BioMed Central Full Text
• [95]Kolebacz M, Durmala J, Czernicki K: Quality of life of patients with juvenile scoliosis undergoing conservative treatment. In Sixth International Conference of Conservative Management of Spinal Deformities. Lyon, France: SOSORT 2009; 2009.
• [96]Levitskiy FA, Yaroslavska NS, Litvinova NL, Ryhlevskiy EK, Bebeshko VA, Plyatsek AV, Veilikiy NA: Psychological problems of patients with scoliosis who utilize the Cheneau's brace. Scoliosis 2009, 4:064.
• [97]Pham VM, Houliez A, Carpentier A, Herbaux B, Schill A, Thevenon A: Determination of the influence of the Cheneau brace on the quality of life for adolescent with idiopathic scoliosis. Ann Phys Rehabil Med 2008, 51(1):3-8.
• [98]Lindeman M, Behm K: Cognitive strategies and self-esteem as predistors of brace-wear non compliance in patients with idiopathic scoliosis and kyphosis. J Pediatr Orthop 1999, 19(4):493-499.
• [99]Schuerger JM: 16 PF Adolescent Personality Questionnaire: Manual. Champaign, IL: Institute for Personality and Ability testing, Incorporated; 2001.