The interplay between structure and agency in shaping the mental health consequences of job loss

BMC Public Health

Gwyneth Jolley⁵  Anna Ziersch¹  Lareen Newman³  Frances Baum²  Julia Anaf⁴ 

[1] Southgate Institute for Health, Society & Equity, Flinders University, Room 253, Health Sciences Building, GPO Box 2100, Adelaide, SA, 5001, Australia;Southgate Institute for Health, Society & Equity & SACHRU, Flinders University, Health Sciences Building Room 2.05, GPO Box 2100, Adelaide, SA, 5001, Australia;Southgate Institute for Health Society & Equity, Flinders University, Room 2.55, Health Sciences Building, GPO Box 2100, Adelaide, SA, 5001, Australia;Southgate Institute for Health, Society and Equity, Flinders University, Room 248 Health Sciences Building, GPO Box 2100, Adelaide, SA, 5001, Australia;South Australian Community Health Research Unit, Flinders University, GPO Box 2100, Adelaide, SA, 5001, Australia

关键词: Manufacturing;    Automotive;    Redundancy;    Mitsubishi;    Structure;    Agency;    Mental health;    Unemployment;    Job loss;   

Others  :  1162569
DOI  :  10.1186/1471-2458-13-110

 received in 2012-07-26, accepted in 2013-01-23,  发布年份 2013

【 摘 要 】

Background

Job loss is a discrete life event, with multiple adverse consequences for physical and mental health and implications for agency. Our research explores the consequences of job loss for retrenched workers’ mental health by examining the interplay between their agency and the structures shaping their job loss experiences.

Methods

We conducted two waves of in-depth, semi-structured interviews with a sample of 33 of the more than 1000 workers who lost their jobs at Mitsubishi Motors in South Australia during 2004 and 2005 as a result of industry restructuring. Interviews capturing the mental health consequences of job loss were recorded and transcribed verbatim. Thematic analysis was employed to determine the health consequences of the job loss and the impact of structural factors.

Results

Main themes that emerged from the qualitative exploration of the psychological distress of job loss included stress, changes to perceived control, loss of self-esteem, shame and loss of status, experiencing a grieving process, and financial strain. Drawing on two models of agency we identified the different ways workers employed their agency, and how their agency was enabled, but mainly constrained, when dealing with job loss consequences.

Conclusions

Respondents’ accounts support the literature on the moderating effects of economic resources such as redundancy packages. The results suggest the need for policies to put more focus on social, emotional and financial investment to mediate the structural constraints of job loss. Our study also suggests that human agency must be understood within an individual’s whole of life circumstances, including structural and material constraints, and the personal or interior factors that shape these circumstances.

【 授权许可】

   
2013 Anaf et al.; licensee BioMed Central Ltd.

【 参考文献 】

• [1]Price RM, Choi JN, Vinokur AD: Links in the chain of adversity following job loss: how financial strain and loss of personal control lead to depression, impaired functioning and poor health. J Occup Health Psychol 2002, 7(4):302-312.
• [2]Barry M, Friedli L: Mental capital and well-being: making the most of ourselves in the 21st century, State-of-Science Review SR-B3, The influence of social, demographic and physical factors on positive mental health in children, adults and older people. 2008. Government Office for Science UK
• [3]Marmot M: Introduction. In Social determinants of health. Edited by Marmot M, Wilkinson R. Oxford: Oxford University Press; 2006.
• [4]Hanisch KA: Job loss and unemployment research from 1994 to 1998: a review and recommendations for research and intervention. Journal of Vocational Behavior 1999, 55:188-220.
• [5]Parker SR, Thomas CG, Ellis ND, McCarthy WEJ: Effects of the Redundancy Payments Act. London: HM Stationery Office; 1971.
• [6]Weller S: Financial stress and the long-term outcomes of job loss. Work, Employment and Society 2012, 26(1):10-25.
• [7]Bohle P, Quinlan M, Mayhew C: The health and safety effects of job insecurity: An evaluation of the evidence. Economic and Labour Relations Review 2001, 12:32-60.
• [8]Latack JC, Kinicki AJ, Prussia GE: An integrative process model of coping with job loss. Acad Manage Rev 1995, 20(3):311-342.
• [9]Borland J: Recent trends in job stability and job security in Australia. Canberra: Centre for Economic Policy Research; 2000.
• [10]Wilkinson R: Health, hierarchy and social anxiety. Ann N Y Acad Sci 1999, 896:48-63.
• [11]Wilkinson R, Marmot M (Eds): Social determinants of health: the solid facts. Second edition. Geneva: World Health Organisation; 2003.
• [12]Lewchuk W, Clarke M, de Wolff A: Working without commitments: The health effects of precarious employment. McGill-Queen's University Press; 2011.
• [13]Ferrie J, Martin I, Shipley J, Marmot M, Stansfeld S, Davy Smith G: The health effects of major organisational change and job insecurity. Soc Sci Med 1998, 46(2):243-254.
• [14]Beale N, Nethercott S: The health of industrial relations employees four years after compulsory redundancy. J R Coll Gen Pract 1987, 37:390-394.
• [15]Dekker SWA, Schaufeli WB: The effects of job security on psychological health and withdrawal: a longitudinal study. Australian Psychologist 1995, 30(1):57-63.
• [16]Blau G: A process model for understanding victim responses to worksite / function closure. Human Resources Management Review 2006, 16:12-28.
• [17]Kubler-Ross E: On death and dying. New York: Macmillan; 1969.
• [18]Dooley D, Fielding J, Lennart L: Health and Unemployment. Annu Rev Public Health 1996, 17:449-465.
• [19]Brenner H, Mooney A: Unemployment and health in the context of economic change. Soc Sci Med 1983, 17(16):1125-1138.
• [20]Green C, Leeves G: The incidence and consequence of worker displacement in Australia. Australian Economic Papers 2003, 42(3):316-331.
• [21]Marmot M, Siegrist J, Theorell T, Feeney A: Health and the psychosocial environment at work. In Social Determinants of Health. Edited by Marmot M, Wilkinson R. Oxford: Oxford University Press; 2006.
• [22]Abbott K, Kelly P: Conceptualising Industrial Relations in the "Risk Society". Labour and Industry 2005, 16(1):83-102.
• [23]LaMontagne A, Smith P, Louie A, Quinlan M, Ostry A, Shoveller J: Psychosocial and other working conditions: Variation by employment arrangement in a sample of working Australians. Am J Ind Med 2012, 55(2):93-106.
• [24]Bohle P, Pitts C, Quinlan M: Time to call it quits: Older workers, contingent employment, safety and health. Int J Health Serv 2010, 40:123-41.
• [25]Lewchuk W, de Wolff A, King A: From job strain to employment strain: health effects of precarious employment. Just Labour 2003, 3(Fall):23-35.
• [26]Grzywacz J, Dooley D: "Good jobs" to "bad jobs": replicated evidence of an employment continuum from two large surveys. Soc Sci Med 2003, 56:1749-1760.
• [27]Vinokur AD, Price RM, Caplan LJ: Hard times and hurtful partners: how financial strain affects depression and relationship satisfaction of unemployed persons and their spouses. J Pers Soc Psychol 1996, 71:166-179.
• [28]Davis GD, Mantler J: The consequences of financial stress for individuals, families and society, Ottowa: Centre for Research on Stress, Coping and Well-being. Department of Psychology: Carleton University; 2004.
• [29]Holmes TH, Rahe RH: The social readjustment rating scale. J Psychosom Res 1967, 11(2):213-218.
• [30]Kerr L, Carson E, Goddard J: Contractualism, employment services, and mature age job seekers: the tyranny of tangible outcomes. The Drawing Board: An Australian Review of Public Affairs 2002, 3(2):83-104.
• [31]Burgard SA, Brand JE, House JS: Toward a better estimation of the effect of job loss on health. J Health Soc Behav 2007, 48(4):369-384.
• [32]Eliason M, Storrie D: Does job loss shorten life? In Working Papers in Economics. School of Business. Economics and Law Goteborg University; 2004.
• [33]Kessler RC, House JS, Turner JB: Unemployment and health in a community sample. J Health Soc Behav 1987, 28(1):51-59.
• [34]Blakely CA, Collings SCD, Atkinson J: Unemployment and suicide: evidence for a causal association. J Epidemiol Community Health 2003, 57(8):5994-5600.
• [35]Kposowa AJ: Unemployment and suicide: a cohort analysis of social factors predicting suicide in the US National Longitudinal Mortality Study. Psychol Med 2001, 31:127-138.
• [36]Lewis G, Sloggett A: Suicide, deprivation, and unemployment: record linkage study. Br Med J 1998, 317:1283-1286.
• [37]Wallston K, Strudler Walston B, Smith S, Dobbins C: Perceived control and health. Current Psychological Research and Reviews 1987, 6(1):5-25.
• [38]Marmot M: Status syndrome. London: Bloomsbury; 2004.
• [39]Bobak M, Pikhart H, Hertzman C, Marmot M: Socioeconomic factors, material inequalities, and perceived control in self-rated health: cross sectional data from seven post-communist countries. Soc Sci Med 1998, 47:269-279.
• [40]Bobak M, Pikhart H, Rose R, Hertzman C, Marmot M: Socioeconomic factors, material inequalities, and perceived control in self-rated health: cross sectional data from seven post-communist countries. Soc Sci Med 2000, 51:1343-1350.
• [41]Pearlin L: The sociological study of stress. J Health Soc Behav 1989, 30:241-256.
• [42]Bruce C: Helping patients, families, caregivers and physicians in the grieving process. J Am Osteopath Assoc 2007, 107(7):533-540.
• [43]Mills CW: The sociological imagination. New York: Oxford University Press; 1959.
• [44]Raber MJ: Job loss and dislocated workers: A stage theory model for treatment. Employee Assistance Quarterly 1996, 12:19-31.
• [45]Ritchie H, Casebourne J, Rick J: Understanding workless people and communities: a literature review. 2005.
• [46]Brief AP, Konovsky MA, Goodwin R, Link K: Inferring the meaning of work from the effects of unemployment. Journal of applied social psychology 1995, 25:693-711.
• [47]Jones L: Specifying the temporal relationship between job loss and consequences: implications for service delivery. Journal of applied social science 1991, 16:37-62.
• [48]Vinokur AD, Shul Y: Mastery and innoculation against setbacks as active ingredients in the JOBS intervention for the unemployed. J Consult Clin Psychol 1997, 65:867-877.
• [49]Deacon A: Different interpretations of agency within welfare debates. Social Policy and Society 2004, 3(4):447-455.
• [50]Lister R: Poverty. Cambridge: Polity Press; 2004.
• [51]Hoggett P: Agency, rationality and social policy. J Soc Policy 2001, 30(1):37-56.
• [52]Frost L, Hoggett P: Human agency and social suffering. Critical Social Policy 2008, 28(4):438-460.
• [53]Hoggett P: Social policy and the emotions. In Rethinking social policy. Edited by Lewis G, Gewirtz S, Clarke C. London: Sage; 2000.
• [54]Newman L, MacDougall C, Baum F: Australian children's accounts of the closure of a car factory: global restructuring and local impacts. Community, Work and Family 2009, 12(2):143-158.
• [55]Verity F, Jolley G: Closure of an automotive plant: transformation of a work-based 'community'. Policy Studies 2008, 29(3):331-341.
• [56]Anaf J, Newman L, Baum F, Ziersch A, Jolley G: Policy environments and job loss: lived experience of retrenched Australian automotive workers. Critical Social Policy 2012.
• [57]Ritchie J, Spencer L: Qualitative data analysis for applied policy research. In Analysing qualitative data. Edited by Bryman A, Burgess R. London: Routledge; 1994.
• [58]Australian Bureau of Statistics: Labour Force Historical Time Series Australia. Canberra; 2009.
• [59]Latack JC, Dozier JB: After the ax falls: job loss as a career transition. Acad Manage Rev 1986, 11:375-392.
• [60]Hartley JF: The impact of unemployment on self-esteem of managers. Journal of occupational psychology 1980, 53:147-153.
• [61]Bourdieu P: The weight of the world: social suffering in contemporary society. Oxford: Policy Press; 1999.
• [62]Bartley M, Ferrie J, Montgomery S: Health and labour market disadvantage: unemployment, non-employment and job insecurity. In The social determinants of health. Edited by Marmot M, Wilkinson R. Oxford: Oxford University Press; 2006.
• [63]Beale N, Nethercott S: Job-loss and family morbidity: a study of a factory closure. J R Coll Gen Pract 1985, 35:510-514.
• [64]Commission on the Social Determinants of Health: Closing the gap in a generation: health equity through action on the social determinants of health, Final Report. 2008.
• [65]Bandura A: Social foundations of thought and action: a social cognitive theory. New Jersey: Prentice Hall; 1986.
• [66]Beale N, Nethercott S: Job loss and morbidity in a group of employees nearing retirement age. J R Coll Gen Pract 1986, 36:265-266.
• [67]Pond D, Harris E, Magin P: A brief intervention to manage unemployment in general practice. 2002.
• [68]Weller S: The other side of precariousness: the cost of job loss. Centre for Strategic Economic Studies: Victoria University, Melbourne; 2007.
• [69]Isaksson K: Health effects of the new labour market. Kluwer Academic: Plenum Publishers; 2000.
• [70]Henman P: The poverty of welfare reform discourse. In Competing Visions. Volume SPRC Report 1/02. Edited by Eardley T, Bradbury B. Social Policy Research Centre, University of New South Wales; 2002.
• [71]Greener I: Agency, social theory and social policy. Critical Social Policy 2002, 22(4):688-705.
• [72]Pocock B: The work-life collision: What work is doing to Australians and what to do about it. Sydney: Federation Press; 2003.
• [73]Bambra C: Work, Worklessness, and the Political Economy of Health. Oxford: Oxford University Press; 2011.
• [74]Carney T, Hanks P: Social security in Australia. Melbourne: Oxford University Press; 1994.
• [75]Burgess J, Connell J: Reworking work: What are the issues for Australia?. University of Sydney. Association of Industrial Relations Academics of Australia and New Zealand; 2005.
• [76]Isaksson K, Johansson G: Avtalspension med vinst och förlust. Konsekvenser för företag och medarbetare. Stockholm: Folksam förlagservice; 1997.
• [77]Wright S: Welfare-to-work, agency and personal responsibility. J Soc Policy 2012, 41(2):309-328.