Is planned adaptation to heat reducing heat-related mortality and illness? A systematic review

BMC Public Health

Ines Rohn¹  Melanie Boeckmann² 

[1] Medical University Hannover, Carl-Neuberg-Str 1, 30625 Hannover, Germany;Center for Social Policy Research, University of Bremen, Mary-Somerville-Str. 5, 28359 Bremen, Germany

关键词: Respiratory disease;    Cardiovascular disease;    Systematic review;    Effectiveness;    Climate change;    Heat;   

Others  :  1125952
DOI  :  10.1186/1471-2458-14-1112

 received in 2014-05-02, accepted in 2014-09-25,  发布年份 2014

【 摘 要 】

Background

Extreme heat is an important public health risk. Climate change will likely increase the temperatures humans are exposed to through exacerbated heat wave intensity and frequency, possibly increasing health risks from heat. To prevent adverse effects on human health, heat prevention plans and climate change adaptation strategies are being implemented. But are these measures effectively reducing heat-related mortality and morbidity? This study assesses the evidence base in 2014.

Methods

We conducted a systematic review of peer-reviewed published literature. We applied a combined search strategy of automated search and journal content search using the electronic databases PubMed, Web of Knowledge, Biological Abstracts, CAB Abstracts and ProQuest Dissertation & Theses A&I. Quality appraisal was conducted using CASP checklists, and we identified recurrent themes in studies with content analysis methodology. We conducted sub-group analyses for two types of studies: survey and interview research on behavioral change and perception, and observational studies with regression.

Results

30 articles were included in the review. The majority of studies (n = 17) assessed mortality or morbidity reductions with regression analysis. Overall, the assessments report a reduction of adverse effects during extreme heat in places where preventive measures have been implemented. Population perception and behavior change were assessed in five studies, none of which had carried out a pre-test. Two themes emerged from the review: methodological challenges are a major hindrance to rigorous evaluation, and what counts as proof of an effective reduction in adverse health outcomes is disputed.

Conclusions

Attributing health outcomes to heat adaptation remains a challenge. Recent study designs are less rigorous due to difficulties assigning the counterfactual. While sensitivity to heat is decreasing, the examined studies provide inconclusive evidence on individual planned adaptation measures.

【 授权许可】

   
2014 Boeckmann and Rohn; licensee BioMed Central Ltd.

【 图 表 】

Figure 1.

Figure 2.

Figure 3.

Figure 4.

【 参考文献 】

• [1]Baccini M, Kosatsky T, Analitis A, Anderson HR, D’Ovidio M, Menne B, Michelozzi P, Biggeri A, the PHEWE Collaborative Group: Impact of heat on mortality in 15 European cities: attributable deaths under different weather scenarios. J Epidemiol Community Health 2011, 65:64-70.
• [2]Ng CFS, Ueda K, Ono M, Nitta H, Takami A: Characterizing the effect of summer temperature on heatstroke-related emergency ambulance dispatches in the Kanto area of Japan. Int J Biometeorol 2014, 58:941-948.
• [3]McMichael AJ, Wilkinson P, Kovats RS, Pattenden S, Hajat S, Armstrong B, Vajanapoom N, Niciu EM, Mahomed H, Kingkeow C, Kosnik M, O’Neill MS, Romieu I, Ramirez-Aguilar M, Barreto ML, Gouveia N, Nikiforov B: International study of temperature, heat and urban mortality: the “ISOTHURM” project. Int J Epidemiol 2008, 37:1121-1131.
• [4]Heatstroke information http://www.fdma.go.jp/neuter/topics/houdou/h25/2510/251015_1houdou/01_houdoushiryou.pdf webcite
• [5]Fowler DR, Mitchell CS, Brown A, Pollock T, Bratka LA, Paulson J, Noller AC, Mauskapf R, Oscanyan K, Vaidyanathan A, Wolkin A, Taylor EV, Radcliffe R: Heat-related deaths after an extreme heat event — Four States, 2012, and United States, 1999–2009. Morb Mortal Wkly Rep 2013, 62:433-436.
• [6]Yeo TP: Heat stroke: a comprehensive review. AACN Clin Issues Adv Pract Acute Crit Care 2004, 15:280-293.
• [7]Bouchama A, Knochel JP: Heat stroke. N Engl J Med 2002, 346:1978-1988.
• [8]Atha WF: Heat-related illness. Emerg Med Clin North Am 2013, 31:1097-1108.
• [9]Martinez M, Devenport L, Saussy J, Martinez J: Drug-associated heat stroke. South Med J 2002, 95:799-802.
• [10]Green H, Gilbert J, James R, Byard RW: An analysis of factors contributing to a series of deaths caused by exposure to high environmental temperatures. Am J Forensic Med Pathol 2001, 22:196-199.
• [11]Wolf J, Adger WN, Lorenzoni I, Abrahamson V, Raine R: Social capital, individual responses to heat waves and climate change adaptation: an empirical study of two UK cities. Glob Environ Chang 2010, 20:44-52.
• [12]Kenny GP, Yardley J, Brown C, Sigal RJ, Jay O: Heat stress in older individuals and patients with common chronic diseases. CMAJ 2010, 182:1053-1060.
• [13]Rosenthal JK: Evaluating the Impact of the Urban Heat Island on Public Health: Spatial and Social Determinants of Heat-Related Mortality in New York City. New York City: Columbia University; 2010.
• [14]Laaidi K, Zeghnoun A, Dousset B, Bretin P, Vandentorren S, Giraudet E, Beaudeau P: The impact of heat islands on mortality in Paris during the August 2003 heat wave. Environ Health Perspect 2012, 120:254-259.
• [15]Tan J, Zheng Y, Tang X, Guo C, Li L, Song G, Zhen X, Yuan D, Kalkstein AJ, Li F: The urban heat island and its impact on heat waves and human health in Shanghai. Int J Biometeorol 2010, 54:75-84.
• [16]Stone B, Hess JJ, Frumkin H: Urban form and extreme heat events: are sprawling cities more vulnerable to climate change than compact cities? Environ Health Perspect 2010, 118:1425-1428.
• [17]Oikonomou E, Davies M, Mavrogianni A, Biddulph P, Wilkinson P, Kolokotroni M: Modelling the relative importance of the urban heat island and the thermal quality of dwellings for overheating in London. Build Environ 2012, 57:223-238.
• [18]IPCC: Summary for Policymakers. In Clim Chang 2007 Impacts, Adapt Vulnerability Contrib Work Gr II to Fourth Assess Rep Intergov Panel Clim Chang. Edited by Parry ML, Canziani OF, Palutikof JP, van der Linden PJ, Hanson CE. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press; 2007:7-22.
• [19]IPCC: Summary for policymakers. In Clim Chang 2007 Phys Sci Basis Contrib Work Gr I to Fourth Assess Rep Intergov Panel Clim Chang. Edited by Solomon S, Qin D, Manning M, Chen Z, Marquis M, Averyt KB, Tignor M, Miller HL. Cambridge [u.a.]: Cambridge University Press; 2007:1-18.
• [20]Greene S, Kalkstein LS, Mills DM, Samenow J: An examination of climate change on extreme heat events and climate–mortality relationships in large U.S. cities. Weather Clim Soc 2011, 3:281-292.
• [21]Huang C, Barnett AG, Wang X, Vaneckova P, FitzGerald G, Tong S: Projecting future heat-related mortality under climate change scenarios: a systematic review. Environ Health Perspect 2011, 119:1681-1690.
• [22]Hajat S, Vardoulakis S, Heaviside C, Eggen B: Climate change effects on human health: projections of temperature-related mortality for the UK during the 2020s, 2050s and 2080s. J Epidemiol Community Heal 2014, 68(7):641-648.
• [23]Knowlton K, Lynn B, Goldberg RA, Rosenzweig C, Hogrefe C, Rosenthal JK, Kinney PL: Projecting heat-related mortality impacts under a changing climate in the New York City region. Am J Public Health 2007, 97:2028-2034.
• [24]Morabito M, Crisci A, Moriondo M, Profili F, Francesconi P, Trombi G, Bindi M, Gensini GF, Orlandini S: Air temperature-related human health outcomes: current impact and estimations of future risks in Central Italy. Sci Total Environ 2012, 441:28-40.
• [25]Guha-Sapir D, Hoyois P, Below R: Annual Disaster Statistical Review 2012: The Numbers and Trends. Brussels: Centre for Research on the Epidemiology of Disasters (CRED) and Institute of Health and Society (IRSS) Université catholique de Louvain; 2012.
• [26]Coumou D, Robinson A, Rahmstorf S: Global increase in record-breaking monthly-mean temperatures. Clim Change 2013, 118:771-782.
• [27]Coumou D, Robinson A: Historic and future increase in the global land area affected by monthly heat extremes. Environ Res Lett 2013, 8:034018.
• [28]Black H: When to warn? comparing heat indices to evaluate public health risks. Environ Health Perspect 2010, 118:A35.
• [29]Anderson GB, Bell ML, Peng RD: Methods to calculate the heat index as an exposure metric in environmental health research. Environ Health Perspect 2013, 121:1111-1119.
• [30]Morabito M, Crisci A, Messeri A, Capecchi V, Modesti PA, Gensini GF, Orlandini S: Environmental temperature and thermal indices: what is the most effective predictor of heat-related mortality in different geographical contexts? Sci World J 2014, 2014:961750.
• [31]Handmer J, Honda Y, Kundzewicz ZW, Arnell N, Benito G, Hatfield J, Mohamed IF, Peduzzi P, Wu S, Sherstyukov B, Takahashi K, Yan Z: Changes in impacts of climate extremes: human systems and ecosystems. In Manag Risks Extrem Events Disasters to Adv Clim Chang Adapt A Spec Rep Work Groups I II Intergov Panel Clim Chang (IPCC). Edited by Field CB, Barros V, Stocker TF, Qin D, Dokken DJ, Ebi KL, Mastrandrea MD, Mach KJ, Plattner G-K, Allen SK, Tignor M, Midgley PM. Cambridge, New York: Cambridge University Press; 2012:231-290.
• [32]Patz JA, Campbell-Lendrum D, Holloway T, Foley JA: Impact of regional climate change on human health. Nature 2005, 438:310-317.
• [33]IPCC: Managing the Risks of Extreme Events and Disasters to Advance Climate Change Adaptation. A Special Report of Working Groups I and II of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. Cambridge and New York: Cambridge University Press; 2012:582.
• [34]Kalkstein A, Sheridan S: The social impacts of the heat–health watch/warning system in Phoenix, Arizona: assessing the perceived risk and response of the public. Int J Biometeorol 2007, 52:43-55.
• [35]Abrahamson V, Wolf J, Lorenzoni I, Fenn B, Kovats S, Wilkinson P, Adger WN, Raine R: Perceptions of heatwave risks to health: interview-based study of older people in London and Norwich, UK. J Public Health (Oxf) 2009, 31:119-126.
• [36]Gronlund CJ, Zanobetti A, Schwartz JD, Wellenius GA, O’Neill MS: Heat, heat waves, and hospital admissions among the elderly in the United States, 1992–2006. Env Heal Perspect 2014. http://ehp.niehs.nih.gov/1206132/ webcite
• [37]Schifano P, Cappai G, De SM, Bargagli AM, Michelozzi P: Who should heat prevention plans target? A heat susceptibility indicator in the elderly developed based on administrative data from a cohort study. Heal Aging Res 2013., 2http://dx.doi.org/10.12715/har.2013.2.2 webcite
• [38]Sampson NR, Gronlund CJ, Buxton MA, Catalano L, White-Newsome JL, Conlon KC, O’Neill MS, McCormick S, Parker EA: Staying cool in a changing climate: reaching vulnerable populations during heat events. Glob Environ Chang 2013, 23:475-484.
• [39]Bittner M-I, Matthies EF, Dalbokova D, Menne B: Are European countries prepared for the next big heat-wave? Eur J Public Health 2013, 24(4):615-619.
• [40]Kovats RS, Kristie LE: Heatwaves and public health in Europe. Eur J Public Health 2006, 16:592-599.
• [41]Ebi KL, Burton I: Identifying practical adaptation options: an approach to address climate change-related health risks. Environ Sci Policy 2008, 11:359-369.
• [42]Lowe D, Ebi KL, Forsberg B: Heatwave early warning systems and adaptation advice to reduce human health consequences of heatwaves. Int J Environ Res Public Health 2011, 8:4623-4648.
• [43]Martinez GS, Imai C, Masumo K: Local heat stroke prevention plans in Japan: characteristics and elements for public health adaptation to climate change. Int J Environ Res Public Heal 2011, 8:4563-4581.
• [44]Toloo G, Fitzgerald G, Aitken P, Verrall K, Tong S: Evaluating the effectiveness of heat warning systems: systematic review of epidemiological evidence. Int J Public Health 2013, 58:667-681.
• [45]Critical appraisal skills programme: making sense of evidence http://www.casp-uk.net webcite
• [46]Katrak P, Bialocerkowski AE, Massy-Westropp N, Kumar S, Grimmer KA: A systematic review of the content of critical appraisal tools. BMC Med Res Methodol 2004, 4:22. BioMed Central Full Text
• [47]Booth A, Papaioannou D, Sutton A: Systematic Approaches to a Successful Literature Review. Los Angeles [u.a.]: Sage; 2012.
• [48]Carroll C, Booth A, Lloyd-Jones M: Should we exclude inadequately reported studies from qualitative systematic reviews? An evaluation of sensitivity analyses in two case study reviews. Qual Health Res 2012, 22:1425-1434.
• [49]Bargagli AM, Michelozzi P, Marino C, De Sario M, Schifano P, Cappai G, Perucci CA: Heat health effect prevention: evaluation of the active surveillance program of high risk elderly in Rome, summer 2008. Epidemiology 2009, 20:S75-S75.
• [50]Bittner MI, Stößel U: Perceptions of heatwave risks to health: results of an qualitative interview study with older people and their carers in Freiburg, Germany. Psychosoc Med 2012, 9:Doc05.
• [51]de’Donato FK, Michelozzi P, Bargagli A, Di Gennaro M, D’Ippoliti D, Leonardi MJ, Marino C, Schifimo P, Perucci C: The Italian heat/health warning system for prevention of heat health effects; evaluation of summer 2008. Epidemiology 2008, 19:S287-S288.
• [52]Delaroziere JC, Sanmarco JL: Excess mortality in people over 65 years old during summer heat waves in Marseille. comparison before and after a preventive campaign. Presse Med 2004, 33:13-16.
• [53]Fouillet A, Rey G, Wagner V, Laaidi K, Empereur-Bissonnet P, Le Tertre A, Frayssinet P, Bessemoulin P, Laurent F, De Crouy-Chanel P, Jougla E, Hémon D: Has the impact of heat waves on mortality changed in France since the European heat wave of summer 2003? a study of the 2006 heat wave. Int J Epidemiol 2008, 37:309-317.
• [54]Kishonti K, Paldy A, Bobvos J: Evaluation of the communication of the heat-health-watch-warning system in Hungary. Epidemiology 2006, 17:S427-S428.
• [55]Kysely J, Kriz B: Decreased impacts of the 2003 heat waves on mortality in the Czech Republic: an improved response? Int J Biometeorol 2008, 52:733-745.
• [56]Kyselý J, Plavcová E: Declining impacts of hot spells on mortality in the Czech Republic, 1986–2009: adaptation to climate change? Clim Change 2011, 113:437-453.
• [57]Marinacci C, Marino M, Ferracin E, Fubini L, Gilardi L, Visentin P, Cadum E, Costa G: Testing of interventions for prevention of heat wave related deaths: results among frail elderly and methodological problems. Epidemiol Prev 2009, 33:96-103.
• [58]Morabito M, Profili F, Crisci A, Francesconi P, Gensini GF, Orlandini S: Heat-related mortality in the Florentine area (Italy) before and after the exceptional 2003 heat wave in Europe: an improved public health response? Int J Biometeorol 2012, 56:801-810.
• [59]Schifano P, Leone M, De Sario M, De’donato F, Bargagli AM, D’Ippoliti D, Marino C, Michelozzi P: Changes in the effects of heat on mortality among the elderly from 1998–2010: results from a multicenter time series study in Italy. Environ Health 2012, 11:58. BioMed Central Full Text
• [60]Davis RE, Knappenberger PC, Michaels PJ, Novicoff WM: Changing heat-related mortality in the United States. Environ Health Perspect 2003, 111:1712-1718.
• [61]Ebi KL, Teisberg TJ, Kalkstein LS, Robinson L, Weiher RF: Heat watch/warning systems save lives - estimated costs and benefits for Philadelphia 1995–98. Bull Am Meteorol Soc 2004, 85:1067-1073.
• [62]Mattern J, Garrigan S, Kennedy SB: A community-based assessment of heat-related morbidity in North Philadelphia. Environ Res 2000, 83:338-342.
• [63]Ostro B, Rauch S, Green R, Malig B, Basu R: The effects of temperature and use of air conditioning on hospitalizations. Am J Epidemiol 2010, 172:1053-1061.
• [64]Palecki MA, Changnon SA, Kunkel KE: The nature and impacts of the July 1999 heat wave in the Midwestern United States: Learning from the lessons of 1995. Bull Am Meteorol Soc 2001, 82:1353-1367.
• [65]Rogot E, Sorlie PD, Backlund E: Air-conditioning and mortality in hot weather. Am J Epidemiol 1992, 136:106-116.
• [66]Sheridan S: A survey of public perception and response to heat warnings across four North American cities: an evaluation of municipal effectiveness. Int J Biometeorol 2007, 52:3-15.
• [67]Smoyer KE: A comparative analysis of heat waves and associated mortality in St. Louis, Missouri–1980 and 1995. Int J Biometeorol 1998, 42:44-50.
• [68]Weisskopf MG, Anderson HA, Foldy S, Hanrahan LP, Blair K, Torok TJ, Rumm PD: Heat wave morbidity and mortality, Milwaukee, Wis, 1999 vs 1995: an improved response? Am J Public Health 2002, 92:830-833.
• [69]Chau P, Chan K, Woo J: Hot weather warning might help to reduce elderly mortality in Hong Kong. Int J Biometeorol 2009, 53:461-468.
• [70]Tan J, Zheng Y, Song G, Kalkstein L, Kalkstein A, Tang X: Heat wave impacts on mortality in Shanghai, 1998 and 2003. Int J Biometeorol 2007, 51:193-200.
• [71]Kosatsky T, Dufresne J, Richard L, Renouf A, Giannetti N, Bourbeau J, Julien M, Braidy J, Sauve C: Heat awareness and response among Montreal residents with chronic cardiac and pulmonary disease. Can J Public Heal Can sante publique 2009, 100:237-240.
• [72]Oakman T, Byles-Drage H, Pope R, Pritchard J: Beat the Heat: don’t forget your drink - a brief public education program. Aust N Z J Public Health 2010, 34:346-350.
• [73]Bassil KL, Cole DC: Effectiveness of public health interventions in reducing morbidity and mortality during heat episodes: a structured review. Int J Environ Res Public Health 2010, 7:991-1001.
• [74]Bouchama A, Dehbi M, Mohamed G, Matthies F, Shoukri M, Menne B: Prognostic factors in heat wave related deaths: a meta-analysis. Arch Intern Med 2007, 167:2170-2176.
• [75]Gupta S, Carmichael C, Simpson C, Clarke MJ, Allen C, Gao Y, Chan EYY, Murray V: Electric fans for reducing adverse health impacts in heatwaves. Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2012, 7:1-24.
• [76]Toloo GS, Fitzgerald G, Aitken P, Verrall K, Tong S: Are heat warning systems effective? Environ Heal 2013, 12:27. BioMed Central Full Text
• [77]Andrieu D, Kaiser C, Ourednik A: ScapeToad. 2008.
• [78]Kyselý J, Plavcová E: Declining impacts of hot spells on mortality in the Czech Republic, 1986–2009: adaptation to climate change? Clim Change 2012, 113:437-453.
• [79]Davis RE, Knappenberger PC, Novicoff WM, Michaels PJ: Decadal changes in summer mortality in U.S. cities. Int J Biometeorol 2003, 47:166-175.
• [80]Frumkin H, Hess J, Luber G, Malilay J, McGeehin M: Climate change: the public health response. Am J Public Health 2008, 98:435-445.
• [81]Ballester J, Robine J-M, Herrmann FR, Rodó X: Long-term projections and acclimatization scenarios of temperature-related mortality in Europe. Nat Commun 2011, 2:358.
• [82]McMichael AJ, Woodruff RE, Hales S: Climate change and human health: present and future risks. Lancet 2006, 367:859-869.
• [83]Adger WN, Agrawala S, Mirza MMQ, Conde C, O’Brien K, Pulhin J, Pulwarty R, Smit B, Takahashi K: Assessment of adaptation practices, options, constraints and capacity. In Clim Chang 2007 Impacts, Adapt Vulnerability Contrib Work Gr II to Fourth Assess Rep Intergov Panel Clim Chang. Edited by Parry ML, Canziani OF, Palutikof JP, van der Linden PJ, Hanson CE. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press; 2007:717-743.
• [84]McMichael AJ: Globalization, climate change, and human health. N Engl J Med 2013, 368:1335-1343.
• [85]Programme of Research on Climate Change Vulnerability Impacts and Adaptation (PROVIA): Research Priorities on Vulnerability, Impacts and Adaptation: Responding to the Climate Change Challenge. Nairobi: PROVIA; 2013.
• [86]Cheng JJ, Berry P: Health co-benefits and risks of public health adaptation strategies to climate change: a review of current literature. Int J Public Health 2013, 58:305-311.
• [87]Hallegatte S: Strategies to adapt to an uncertain climate change. Glob Environ Chang 2009, 19(2):240-247.
• [88]Hall JW, Brown S, Nicholls RJ, Pidgeon NF, Watson RT: Proportionate adaptation. Nat Clim Chang 2012, 2:833-834.
• [89]Füssel H-M: Adaptation planning for climate change: concepts, assessment approaches, and key lessons. Sustain Sci 2007, 2:265-275.
• [90]Wilby RL, Dessai S: Robust adaptation to climate change. Weather 2010, 65:180-185.
• [91]Wilby RL, Vaughan K: Hallmarks of organisations that are adapting to climate change. Water Environ J 2011, 25:271-281.
• [92]McMichael AJ: Impediments to comprehensive research on climate change and health. Int J Environ Res Public Health 2013, 10:6096-6105.
• [93]Bassil KL, Cole DC, Smoyer-Tomic K, Callaghan M, Team HEPHIR: What Is the Evidence on Applicability and Effectiveness of Public Health Interventions in Reducing Morbidity and Mortality during Heat Episodes?. Toronto: National Collaborating Centre for Environmental Health; 2007.
• [94]Biesbroek GR, Swart RJ, Carter TR, Cowan C, Henrichs T, Mela H, Morecroft MD, Rey D: Europe adapts to climate change: comparing national adaptation strategies. Glob Environ Chang 2010, 20:440-450.
• [95]Berrang-Ford L, Ford JD, Paterson J: Are we adapting to climate change? Glob Environ Chang 2011, 21:25-33.
• [96]Bobb JF, Peng RD, Bell ML, Dominici F: Heat-related mortality and adaptation to heat in the United States. Env Heal Perspect 2014, 122:811-816.
• [97]Coates L, Haynes K, O’Brien J, McAneney J, de Oliveira FD: Exploring 167 years of vulnerability: an examination of extreme heat events in Australia 1844–2010. Environ Sci Policy 2014, 42:33-44.
• [98]Petkova EP, Gasparrini A, Kinney PL: Heat and mortality in New York City since the beginning of the 20th century. Epidemiology 2014, 25:554-560.
• [99]Smith KR, Woodward A, Campbell-Lendrum D, Chadee D, Honda Y, Liu Q, Olwoch J, Revich B, Sauerborn R, Aranda C, Berry H, Butler C, Chafe Z, Cushing L, Ebi K, Kjellstrom T, Kovats S, Lindsay G, Lipp E, McMichael T, Murray V, Sankoh O, O’Neill M, Shonkoff SB, Sutherland J, Yamamoto S: Human health: impacts, adaptation and co-benefits. In Intergov Panel Clim Chang 5th Assess Rep. Stanford: IPCC; 2014.