Why medical students choose psychiatry - a 20 country cross-sectional survey

BMC Medical Education

Dinesh Bhugra³  David M Ndetei⁴  Amit Malik⁵  Gregory J Lydall¹  Kitty Farooq² 

[1] Castel Hospital, Guernsey GY5 7NJ, UK;Oxleas NHS Foundation Trust, 68 The Heights, Charlton, London SE7 8JH, UK;Mental Health and Cultural Diversity, PO25, Health Service and Population Research Department, Institute of Psychiatry, King’s College London, David Goldberg Centre, De Crespigny Park, London SE5 8AF, UK;Africa Mental Health Foundation, 1st Floor Gakuo Court, Lower Hill Road, Off Haile Sellasie Avenue, P.O Box 48423, 00100 Nairobi, Kenya;Surrey and Borders NHS Trust, 18 Mole Business Park, Leatherhead, Surrey KT22 7AD, UK

关键词: Medical school selection;    Gender;    Recruitment;    Enrichment activity;    Stigma;    Attitude to psychiatry;    Medical student;    Career choice;    Psychiatry;   

Others  :  1135664
DOI  :  10.1186/1472-6920-14-12

 received in 2013-05-29, accepted in 2013-12-18,  发布年份 2014

【 摘 要 】

Background

Recruitment to psychiatry is insufficient to meet projected mental health service needs world-wide. We report on the career plans of final year medical students from 20 countries, investigating factors identified from the literature which influence psychiatric career choice.

Methods

Cross sectional electronic or paper survey. Subjects were final year medical students at 46 medical schools in participating countries. We assessed students’ career intentions, motivations, medical school teaching and exposure to psychiatry. We assessed students’ attitudes and personality factors. The main outcome measure was likelihood of specializing in psychiatry. Multilevel logistic regression was used to examine the joint effect of factors upon the main outcome.

Results

2198 of 9135 (24%) of students responded (range 4 to 91%) across the countries. Internationally 4.5% of students definitely considered psychiatry as a career (range 1 to 12%). 19% of students (range 0 to 33%) were “quite likely”, and 25% were “definitely not” considering psychiatry. Female gender, experience of mental/physical illness, media portrayal of doctors, and positive attitudes to psychiatry, but not personality factors, were associated with choosing psychiatry. Quality of psychiatric placement (correlation coefficient = 0.22, p < 0.001) and number of placements (correlation coefficient =0.21, p < 0.001) were associated with higher ATP scores. During medical school, experience of psychiatric enrichment activities (special studies modules and university psychiatry clubs), experience of acutely unwell patients and perceived clinical responsibility were all associated with choice of psychiatry.

Multilevel logistic regression revealed six factors associated with students choosing psychiatry: importance of own vocation, odds ratio (OR) 3.01, 95% CI 1.61 to 5.91, p < 0.001); interest in psychiatry before medical school, OR 10.8 (5.38 to 21.8, p < 0.001); undertaking a psychiatry special study module, OR 1.45 (1.05 to 2.01, p = 0.03) or elective OR 4.28 (2.87- 6.38, p < 0.001); membership of a university psychiatry club, OR 3.25 (2.87 to 6.38, p < 0.001); and exposure to didactic teaching, OR 0.54 (0.40 to 0.72, p < 0.001).

Conclusions

We report factors relevant to medical student selection and psychiatry teaching which affect career choice. Addressing these factors may improve recruitment to psychiatry internationally.

【 授权许可】

   
2014 Farooq et al.; licensee BioMed Central Ltd.

【 图 表 】

Figure 1.

Figure 2.

【 参考文献 】

• [1]The Lancet Psychiatry’s identity crisis The Lancet 2012, 379(9823):1274.
• [2]Cooper B: British psychiatry and its discontents. JRSM 2010, 103(10):397-402.
• [3]Katschnig H: Are psychiatrists an endangered species? Observations on internal and external challenges to the profession. World Psychiatry 2010, 9(1):21-28.
• [4]Oyebode F, Humphreys M: The future of psychiatry. Br J Psychiatry 2011, 199(6):439-440.
• [5]WHO: mhGAP : Mental Health Gap Action Programme: scaling up care for mental, neurological and substance use disorders [pdf report]. 2008. [cited 2009 6/6/09]; Available from: http://www.who.int/mental_health/mhgap_final_english.pdf webcite
• [6]Maj M: The WPA Action Plan 2008–2011. 2008. [cited 2009 11/06/2009]; Available from: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2559914/ webcite
• [7]Rojnic Kuzman M, Giacco D, Simmons M, Wuyts P, Bausch-Becker N, Favre G, Nawka A: Are there differences between training curricula on paper and in practice? Views of European trainees. World Psychiatry 2012, 11(2):135.
• [8]WHO: Atlas: psychiatric education and training across the world 2005. Geneva: WHO; 2005.
• [9]Rao NR: Recent trends in psychiatry residency workforce with special reference to international medical graduates. Acad Psychiatry 2003, 27(4):269-276.
• [10]RCPsych: Fill rate and competition ratios for CT1 August 2012 intake. 2012. [cited 2013 13.5.13]; Available from: http://www.rcpsych.ac.uk/traininpsychiatry/nationalrecruitment/fillratesandcompetition.aspx webcite
• [11]Eagle PF, Marcos LR: Factors in medical students’ choice of psychiatry. Am J Psychiatry 1980, 137(4):5.
• [12]Sierles FS, Dinwiddle S, Patro D, Atre-Vaidya N, Schrift MJ, Woddard J: Factors affecting medical student choice of psychiatry. Academic Psychiatry 2003, 27:260-26.
• [13]Brockington I, Mumford D: Recruitment into psychiatry. Br J Psychiatry 2002, 180:307-312.
• [14]Thompson DJ, Sims ACP: Malaise in psychiatric recruitment and its remedy. Psychiatric Bulletin 1999, 23:227-229.
• [15]Brown N, Vassilas CA, Oakley C: Recruiting psychiatrists – A Sisyphean task? Psychiatric Bulletin 2009, 31(11):300-392.
• [16]Sierles FS, Yager J, Weissman SH: Recruitment of U.S. medical graduates into psychiatry: reasons for optimism, sources of concern. Acad Psychiatry 2003, 27(4):252-259.
• [17]Tamaskar P, McGinnis RA: Declining interest in psychiatry. Jama 2002, 287:1.
• [18]El-Sayeh H, Budd S, Waller R, Holmes J: How to win the hearts and minds of students in psychiatry. Advances in Psychiatric Treatment 2006, 12:182-192.
• [19]Feldmann TB: Medical students’ attitudes toward psychiatry and mental disorders. Acad Psychiatry 2005, 29(4):354-356.
• [20]Buckley PF, Madaan V: Leadership and professional workforce development. Psychiatr Clin North Am 2008, 31(1):105-122.
• [21]Stoudemire A: Quo vadis, psychiatry? Problems and potential for the future of medical student education in psychiatry. Psychosomatics 2000, 41(3):204-209.
• [22]Newton DA, Grayson MS, Newton DA, Grayson MS: Trends in career choice by US medical school graduates. Jama 2003, 290(9):1179-1182.
• [23]Lunn B: Recruitment into psychiatry: an international challenge. Aust N Z J Psychiatry 2011, 45(805):807.
• [24]Eagles JM, Wilson S, Murdoch JM, Brown T: What impact do undergraduate experiences have upon recruitment into psychiatry? Psychiatric Bulletin 2007, 31(2):70-72.
• [25]Farooq K, Lydall GJ, Bhugra D: Research into recruitment: critical gaps in the literature. Int Rev Psychiatr 2013, 25(4):366-370.
• [26]Lofchy J, Brunet A, Silver I: The psychiatry institute for medical students: a novel recruitment strategy. Acad Psychiatry 1999, 23:6.
• [27]Mihalynuk T, Leung G, Fraser J, Bates J, Snadden D: Free choice and career choice: Clerkship electives in medical education. Med Educ 2006, 40(11):1065-1071.
• [28]Weintraub W, Plaut SM, Weintraub E: Recruitment into psychiatry: increasing the pool of applicants. Can J Psychiatry 1999, 44(5):473-477.
• [29]Wilkinson G: Medical students’ attitudes to psychiatry at the end of the clinical curriculum. Psychol Med 1983, 13(4):665-668.
• [30]Thompson ER: Development and validation of an international English big-five mini-markers. Pers Indiv Differ 2008, 45(6):542-548.
• [31]Feifel D, Moutier CY, Swerdlow NR: Attitudes toward psychiatry as a prospective career among students entering medical school. Am J Psychiatr 1999, 156(9):1397-1402.
• [32]Rao NR, Meinzer AE, Manley M, Chagwedera I: International medical students’ career choice, attitudes toward psychiatry, and emigration to the United States: examples from India and Zimbabwe. Acad Psychiatry 1998, 22:117-126.
• [33]Lambert TW, Goldacre MJ, Turner G: Career choices of United Kingdom medical graduates of 1999 and 2000: questionnaire surveys. Br Med J 2003, 326:194-195.
• [34]Balon R, Franchini GR, Freeman PS, Hassenfeld IN, Keshavan MS, Yoder E: Medical students’ attitudes and views of psychiatry: 15 years later. Acad Psychiatry 1999, 23:30-36.
• [35]Pailhez G, Bulbena A, Coll J, Ros S, Balon R: Attitudes and views on psychiatry: a comparison between Spanish and U.S. medical students. Acad Psychiatry 2005, 29(1):82-91.
• [36]Bulbena A, Pailhez G, Coll J, Balon R: Changes in the attitudes towards psychiatry among Spanish medical students during training in psychiatry. Eur J Psychiatr 2005, 19:79-87.
• [37]Compton MT, Frank E, Elon L, Carrera J: Changes in U.S. medical students’ specialty interests over the course of medical school. J Gen Intern Med 2008, 23(7):1095-1100.
• [38]Mahoney R, Katona C, McParland M, Noble L, Livingston G: Shortage specialties: changes in career intentions from medical student to newly qualified doctor. Med Teach 2004, 26(7):650-654.
• [39]Galeazzi GM, Secchi C, Curci P: Current factors affecting the choice of psychiatry as a speciality: an Italian study. Acad Psychiatry 2003, 27:74-81.
• [40]Lambert TW, Turner G, Fazel S, Goldacre MJ: Reasons why some UK medical graduates who initially choose psychiatry do not pursue it as a long-term career. Psychol Med 2006, 36(5):679-684.
• [41]Goldacre MJ, Lambert TW: Stability and change in career choices of junior doctors. Med Educ 2002, 34:700-707.
• [42]Goldacre MJ, Davidson JM, Lambert TW: Career choices at the end of the pre-registration year for doctors who qualified in the United Kingdom in 1996. Med Educ 1999, 33:882-889.
• [43]Goldacre MJ, Turner G, Fazel S, Lambert T: Career choices for psychiatry: national surveys of graduates of 1974–2000 from UK medical schools.[erratum appears in Br J Psychiatry. 2005 Apr;186:357]. Br J Psychiatry 2005, 186:158-164.
• [44]Lambert TW, Davidson JM, Evans J, Goldacre MJ: Doctors’ reasons for rejecting initial choices of specialties as long-term careers. Med Educ 2003, 37:312-318.
• [45]Syed EU, Siddiqi MN, Dogar I, Hamrani MM, Yousafzai AW, Zuberi S: Attitudes of pakistani medical students towards psychiatry as a prospective career: a survey. Acad Psychiatry 2008, 32(2):160-164.
• [46]Abramowitz MZ, Bentov-Gofrit D, Abramowitz MZ, Bentov-Gofrit D: The attitudes of Israeli medical students toward residency in psychiatry. Acad Psychiatry 2005, 29(1):92-95.
• [47]Sierles FS, Taylor MA: Decline of U.S. medical student career choice of psychiatry and what to do about it. Am J Psychiatry 1995, 152(10):1416-1426.
• [48]Ndetei DM, Ongecha-Owuor F, Mutiso V, Kuria M, Khasakhala L, Kokonya D: The challendes of human resources in mental health in Kenya. South African Psychiatry Review 2007, 10:433-436.
• [49]Gjerberg E: Gender diffferences in doctors’ preference - and gender difference in final specialisation. Soc Sci Med 2002, 54:591-605.
• [50]Gjerberg E: Medical women - towards full integration? An analysis of the speciality choices made by two cohorts of Norwegian doctors. Soc Sci Med 2001, 52:331-343.
• [51]Lambert EM, Holmboe ES: The relationship between speciality choice and gender of U.S. medical students, 1990–2003. Acad Med 2005, 80:797-802.
• [52]Frank E, Boswell L, Dickstein LJ: Characteristics of female psychiatrists. Am J Psychiatry 2001, 158:205-212.
• [53]Rajagopal S, Rehill KS, Godfrey E: Psychiatry as a career choice compared with other specialties: a survey of medical students. Psychiatr Bull 2004, 28:444-446.
• [54]Altindag A, Yanik M, Ucok A, Alptekin K, Ozkan M: Effects of an antistigma program on medical students’ attitudes towards people with schizophrenia. Psychiatry Clin Neurosci 2006, 60(3):283-288.
• [55]Corrigan PW, Morris SB, Michaels PJ, Rafacz JD, Rusch N: Challenging the public stigma of mental illness: a meta-analysis of outcome studies. Psychiatric Services 2012, 63(10):963-973.
• [56]Corrigan PW, Watson AC: Understanding the impact of stigma on people with mental illness. World Psychiatr 2002, 1(1):16-20.
• [57]Schomerus G, Schwahn C, Holzinger A, Corrigan PW, Grabe HJ, Carta MG, Angermeyer MC: Evolution of public attitudes about mental illness: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Acta psychiatrica Scandinavica 2012, 125(6):440-452.
• [58]Maidment R, Livingston G, Katona M, Whitaker E, Katona C: Carry on shrinking: career intentions and attitudes to psychiatry of prospective medical students. Psychiatric Bulletin 2003, 27:30-32.
• [59]Maidment R, Livingston G, Katona C, McParland M, Noble L: Change in attitudes to psychiatry and intention to pursue psychiatry as a career in newly qualified doctors: a follow-up of two cohorts of medical students. Med Teach 2004, 26(6):565-569.
• [60]Ndetei DM, Khasakhala L, Ongecha-Owuor F, Kuria M, Mutiso V, Syanda J, Kokonya D: Attitudes toward psychiatry: a survey of medical students at the University of Nairobi, Kenya. Acad Psychiatry 2008, 32(2):154-159.
• [61]Al-Ansari A, Alsadadi A: Attitude of Arabian Gulf University medical students towards psychiatry. Educ Health 2002, 15:180-188.
• [62]Kuhnigk O, Strebel B, Schilauske J, Jueptner M: Attitudes of medical students towards psychiatry: effects of training, courses in psychiatry, psychiatric experience and gender. Adv Health Sci Educ Theory Pract 2007, 12(1):87-101.
• [63]Strebel B, Obladen M, Lehmann E, Gaebel W: Attitude of medical students to psychiatry. A study with the German translated, expanded version of the ATP-30].[erratum appears in Nervenarzt 2000 Jul;71(7):579. Nervenarzt 2000, 71(3):205-212.
• [64]Tharyan P, John T, Tharyan A, Braganza D: Attitudes of ‘tomorrow’s doctors’ towards psychiatry and mental illness. Natl Med J India 2001, 14:355-359.
• [65]Niedermier JA, Bornstein R, Brandemihl A: The junior medical student psychiatry clerkship: curriculum, attitudes, and test performance. Acad Psychiatry 2006, 30(2):136-143.
• [66]Lampe L, Coulston C, Walter G, Malhi G: Up close and personal: medical students prefer face-to-face teaching in psychiatry. Australas Psychiatry 2010, 18(4):354-360.
• [67]Lampe L, Coulston C, Walter G, Malhi G: Familiarity breeds respect: attitudes of medical students towards psychiatry following a clinical attachment. Australas Psychiatry 2010, 18(4):348-353.
• [68]Bobo WV, Nevin R, Greene E, Lacy TJ: The effect of psychiatric third-year rotation setting on academic performance, student attitudes, and specialty choice. Acad Psychiatry 2009, 33(2):105-111.
• [69]Clardy JA, Thrush CR, Guttenberger VT, Goodrich ML, Burton RPD: The junior psychiatric clerkship and medical students’ interest in psychiatry. Acad Psychiatry 2000, 24:6.
• [70]Kasuboski D, Marshall J: Responsibility and relevance in a psychiatric clerkship. J Med Educ 1973, 48(8):752-757.
• [71]Yakeley J, Shoenberg P, Heady A: Who wants to do psychiatry? The influence of a students psychotherapy scheme - a 10-year retrospective study. The Psychiatrist 2004, 28:208-212.