Restorative circles and gender expression in three North American middle school environments

Restorative Justice, Masculinity, Educational Reform

Becker, Mark ; Lyubansky, Mikhail, ; ,Dixson, Adrienne ; Pak ; Yoon

关键词: Restorative Justice, Masculinity, Educational Reform;   

Others  :  https://www.ideals.illinois.edu/bitstream/handle/2142/101042/BECKER-THESIS-2018.pdf?sequence=1&isAllowed=y

美国|英语

来源: The Illinois Digital Environment for Access to Learning and Scholarship

【 摘 要 】

This project is a secondary analysis of existing data collected within two Midwestern urban school districts. The objective of this investigation was two-fold. One was to assist two Midwestern school districts in better understanding how their recently implemented restorative programs were affecting quality of life and education for both students and staff/teachers. The goal was to allow them the opportunity to shift attention and resources toward areas that need to be developed further while simultaneously highlighting the aspects of their programs that were functioning well.While the field is certainly expanding, there exists a lack of models for schools in terms of restorative approaches to conflict and school culture. This investigation contributes to a growing body of data & evidence supporting the importance of alternatives to solely punitive measures of handling discipline and conflict in learning communities. A secondary objective was to further an understanding of how gendered power dynamics interact with, and are affected by, restorative approaches. I propose this lens through which to view the development of restorative programs to account for possible intersections of power dynamics with gender (as well as race, class and other identities which impact gender expressions) in order to open up further possibilities for educational reform. This approach seeks to better our understanding of how attempts at ‘reforming’ educational settings often fail, through no lack of effort, as a result of the social reproduction of power and inequality.Additionally, this study points to specific restorative methods which can act as possible interventions. This research seeks to engage with a growing body of research aimed at improving educational experiences for all people while preparing young people to engage with the complexities of the world with tools that affirm a wide variety of democratic approaches to learning.