Benefit Protection : Priority Creditor Rights for Pension Funds

Fiona Stewart

Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development

关键词: contribution;    bankruptcy;    underfunded;    pension creditor;    creditors;    restructuring;    priority right;    pension fund;    insolvent;    funding rule;   

DOI  :  https://doi.org/10.1787/267415864801

学科分类：社会科学、人文和艺术（综合）

来源: OECD iLibrary

【 摘 要 】

Underfunded pension funds are in the same position as other creditors when their sponsoring firm becomes insolvent, having to join the queue claiming the remaining assets of the firm. Arguments for granting pension fund priority rights over other creditors are the same as for introducing pension benefit guarantee schemes – i.e. market failure and diversification. Arguments against such a priority position focus around the impact on other creditors and potential disruptions to capital markets.The OECD’s report on priority pension claims within bankruptcy found that pension claims (unlike wages) rarely receive priority over other creditors. More concerning, it can be difficult for pension fund creditors (being a diverse group without strong financing) to get their voice heard properly within insolvency procedures. Difficulties with providing such priority status to pension creditors stem from problems with changing bankruptcy laws and the strength of other financial creditors. The OECD’s report concludes that priority rights should be given to unpaid and due contributions from the plan sponsor and that care should be taken that pension beneficiaries be treated at least as well as other creditors in any bankruptcy or restructuring process (e.g. ensuring their representation on creditor committees).