CALiPER Exploratory Study: Recessed Troffer Lighting

Miller, Naomi J. ; Royer, Michael P. ; Poplawski, Michael E.

关键词: CALiPER Program;    Solid State Lighting;    Energy Efficiency;    LED;    Photometric Testing;    T8 Replacement Lamps;    Troffer Kits;    Exploratory Study;    LM-79-08 Testing;   

DOI  :  10.2172/1162371
RP-ID  :  PNNL-22348
PID  :  OSTI ID: 1162371
Others  :  Other: BT0301000

美国|英语

来源: SciTech Connect

【 摘 要 】

This report describes an exploration of troffer lighting as used in office and classroom spaces, which was conducted by the CALiPER program. Twenty-four pairs of 2??2 and 2??4 troffers were procured anonymously, documented, tested for photometric and electrical performance, and installed in a mockup office space in Portland, Oregon. Three of the pairs were T8 fluorescent benchmark products, 12 were dedicated LED troffers, five were fluorescent troffers modified for LED lamps (sometimes referred to as "tubes"), and another four troffers were modified with LED retrofit kits. The modifications were performed by a commercial electrical contractor, following the instructions provided by the retrofit lamp or kit manufacturer. Once installed in the mockup facility, the converted luminaires were examined by a NRTL (Nationally Recognized Testing Laboratory) safety expert, who provided feedback on safety issues. In September 2012, a group of lighting designers, engineers, and facility managers were brought in to observe the LED luminaires in comparison to fluorescent benchmarks. This report documents performance in measures that go beyond illuminance values or luminaire efficacy. Dedicated LED troffers are ready to compete with fluorescent troffers in terms of efficacy (lumens per watt), and in many lighting quality issues such as glare, light distribution, visual appearance, and color quality. That is not to say that each one is stellar, but each one tested in this CALiPER study bested the fluorescent benchmarks in terms of efficacy, and almost all were rated highly in several categories -- only one luminaire of twelve performed consistently poorly.