The need for assessment of risks arising from interactions between NGT organisms from an EU perspective

Environmental Sciences Europe

卷:35

Research

Meike Schulz¹  Franziska Koller¹  Matthias Juhas²  Andreas Bauer-Panskus²  Christoph Then² 

[1] Fachstelle Gentechnik und Umwelt (FGU), Munich, Germany;

[2] Testbiotech, Munich, Germany;

关键词: New genomic techniques;    Genetically engineered organisms;    Genome editing;    GMO regulation;    Risk assessment;    Direct and indirect effects;    Interactions;    Cumulative long-term effects;    Accumulated risks;    Prospective technology assessment;   

DOI  :  10.1186/s12302-023-00734-3

 received in 2022-10-08, accepted in 2023-04-09,  发布年份 2023

来源: Springer

【 摘 要 】

BackgroundNew genomic techniques (NGTs) allow new genotypes and traits to be developed in different ways and with different outcomes compared to previous genetic engineering methods or conventional breeding (including non-targeted mutagenesis). EU GMO regulation requires an assessment of their direct and indirect effects that may be immediate, delayed or cumulative. Such effects may also result from the interactions of NGT organisms simultaneously present in a shared receiving environment or emerge from a combination of their traits. This review elaborates such potential interactions based on a literature review and reasoned scenarios to identify possible pathways to harm.Main findingsNGT organisms might be introduced into the environment and food chains on a large-scale, involving many traits, across a broad range of species and within short periods of time. Unavoidably, this would increase the likelihood that direct or indirect effects will occur through interactions between NGT organisms that are, for example simultaneously present within a shared environment. It has to be assumed that the cumulative effects of these NGT organisms may exceed the sum of risks identified in the distinct ‘events’. Consequently, risk assessors and risk managers not only need to consider the risks associated with individual NGT organisms (‘events’), but should also take account of risks resulting from their potential interactions and combinatorial effects. In addition, a prospective technology assessment could help the risk manager in defining criteria to minimize potential unintended interactions between NGT organisms through limiting the scale of releases.ConclusionsIf genetically engineered (GE) organisms derived from NGTs are released into the environment, their potentially negative impacts need to be minimized. As with all GE organisms, it is, therefore, crucial to not only assess the risks of the individual events, but also their potential interactions which can trigger direct and indirect effects with adverse impacts. It is necessary to develop hypotheses and specific scenarios to explore interactions between NGT organisms and possible pathways to harm from the perspective of the precautionary principle. In addition, the introduction prospective technology assessment could provide an instrument for the risk manager to control the scale of releases of NGT organisms.

【 授权许可】

CC BY   
© The Author(s) 2023