Quality assessment of Japanese clinical practice guidelines including recommendations for acupuncture

Integrative Medicine Research

Yohji Fukazawa¹  Hitoshi Yamashita¹  Shoko Masuyama²  Ikuro Wakayama²  Yuse Okawa² 

[1] Corresponding authors at: Graduate School of Health Sciences, Morinomiya University of Medical Sciences, 1-26-16 Nanko-Kita, Suminoe-Ku, Osaka 559-8611, Japan.;Graduate School of Health Sciences, Morinomiya University of Medical Sciences, Osaka, Japan;

关键词: Acupuncture;    AGREE II;    Clinical practice guidelines;    GRADE system;    Recommendation;   

DOI  :  

来源: DOAJ

【 摘 要 】

Background: The quality of clinical practice guidelines (CPGs) should be extensively evaluated. This study aimed to evaluate Japanese CPGs that include recommendations for acupuncture. Methods: In a literature search, CPGs including recommendations for acupuncture published in Japan until October 2021 were sought. We assessed (1) whether the CPGs were developed in accordance with the Grading Recommendations Assessment, Development and Evaluation (GRADE) system, (2) the quality of the CPGs using the Appraisal of Guidelines for Research and Evaluation (AGREE) II, and (3) whether the strength of the recommendations for acupuncture was consistent with each CPG's predefined procedure. Results: Seventeen CPGs including 23 recommendations in total were identified and assessed. (1) Three CPGs were in accordance with the GRADE system. (2) The mean score of overall assessment using AGREE II was 4.5 on a 7-point Likert scale. The mean domain scores were 77% for domain 1 (scope and purpose), 54% for domain 2 (stakeholder involvement), 48% for domain 3 (rigor of development), 78% for domain 4 (clarity of presentation), 20% for domain 5 (applicability), and 51% for domain 6 (editorial independence). (3) The strength of the recommendations for acupuncture in two CPGs was judged to be underestimated. Some of the CPGs contained elementary problems that were not considered in AGREE II. Conclusion: The methodological quality of Japanese CPGs including recommendations for acupuncture was not necessarily high. Since technical issues exist in each field of therapy, the respective experts should be involved in developing and reviewing CPGs to disseminate accurate health information.

【 授权许可】

Unknown