Onset complexo pré e pós-tratamento de desvio fonológico em três modelos de terapia fonológica Complex onset pre and post phonological disorder treatment in three different phonological therapy models

Revista da Sociedade Brasileira de Fonoaudiologia

关键词: Desenvolvimento da linguagem;    Transtornos da articulação;    Fala;    Fonoterapia;    Linguagem infantil;    Language development;    Articulation disorders;    Speech;    Speech therapy;    Child language;   

DOI  :  10.1590/S1516-80342010000300014

来源: DOAJ

【 摘 要 】

OBJETIVO: Analisar a ocorrência de onset complexo pré e pós-tratamento em crianças tratadas com três diferentes modelos de terapia fonológica. MÉTODOS: Participaram 21 sujeitos com desvio fonológico, 16 meninos e cinco meninas, com idades entre quatro e sete anos e 11 meses, divididos em grupos de sete sujeitos de acordo com o modelo utilizado para o tratamento: Ciclos Modificado, Oposições Máximas e ABAB-Retirada e Provas Múltiplas. Verificou-se os dados do sistema fonológico inicial e final, referentes à produção total de onsets complexos e dos onsets complexos com /l/ e com /r/. Estes foram classificados em: não adquiridos, de 0 a 39%; parcialmente adquiridos, de 40 a 69% e adquiridos de 70 a 100%. Os dados foram submetidos à análise estatística. RESULTADOS: Quanto ao total de onsets complexos, nos Modelos de Ciclos e Oposições Máximas, houve diferença nas médias dos onsets complexos não adquiridos e dos onsets complexos adquiridos antes e após a terapia e, no Modelo ABAB apenas nos onsets complexos adquiridos (p<0,05). No onset complexo com /r/ verificou-se o mesmo resultado. No onset complexo com /l/, somente no Modelo de Ciclos houve diferença entre as médias dos onsets complexos não adquiridos e dos onsets complexos adquiridos. Em todos os modelos foi diferente a classificação de onsets complexos não adquiridos para onsets complexos adquiridos, pré e pós-tratamento. CONCLUSÃO: Os três modelos de terapia fonológica se mostraram eficientes para o tratamento da estrutura silábica onset complexo.
PURPOSE: To examine the occurrence of complex onset pre- and post-treatment in children treated with three different models of phonological therapy. METHODS: Twenty-one subjects with phonological disorder participated in the study, 16 boys and five girls, with ages varying between four years and seven years and eleven months. The children were divided into three groups of seven subjects, according to the therapy models used: Modified Cycles Model, Maximum Opposition Model and ABAB-Withdrawal and Multiple Probes Model. Data from initial and final evaluations of the phonological system were analyzed, regarding the total production of complex onsets and of production of complex onsets with /l/ and /r/. These were classified as: not acquired, from 0 to 39%; partially acquired, from 40 to 69%; and acquired, from 70 to 100%. Statistical analyses were carried out. RESULTS: Regarding the total number of occurences of complex onsets, there was a difference between pre- and post-therapy means of not acquired and acquired complex onsets in the Modified Cycles Model and in the Maximum Opposition Model; in the ABAB-Withdrawal and Multiple Probes Model, this difference was found only for acquired complex onsets. The same was veryfied for complex onsets with /r/. With regards to complex onsets with /l/, differences were found only in the Modified Cycles Model, between not acquired and acquired complex onsets. A different classification of not acquired and acquired complex onsets was observed, in all models, between pre- and post-treatment. CONCLUSION: The three models of phonological therapy were effective for the treatment of complex syllabic onset structure.

【 授权许可】

Unknown