African community-based conservation: a systematic review of social and ecological outcomes

Ecology and Society: a journal of integrative science for resilience and sustainability

Matthew W Luizza,¹  Kathleen A Galvin,²  Tyler A Beeton,⁴ 

[1] Natural Resource Ecology Laboratory, Colorado State University;Department of Anthropology, Colorado State University;Natural Resource Ecology Laboratory, Colorado State University;North Central Climate Adaptation Science Center

关键词: Africa;    community-based conservation;    conditions;    evaluation;    social;    ecological outcomes;    systematic review;   

DOI  :  10.5751/ES-10217-230339

学科分类：生物科学（综合）

来源: Resilience Alliance Publications

【 摘 要 】

Community-based conservation (CBC) institutions are widely regarded as transformative bodies that benefit social and ecological processes in coupled social-ecological systems. Yet, limited empirical evidence for this claim exists, especially on the African continent where community-based conservancies (CBCs) are being rapidly adopted in diverse institutional forms across multiple countries. We provide the first large-scale systematic review of CBC outcomes in sub-Saharan Africa. We review the literature on CBCs and develop a conceptual model that illustrates the nested scales of interaction in which CBCs are embedded, the institutional processes (“conditions”) reported as important for success, and the outcomes of CBCs on social and ecological systems. The mixed-method approach consists of inductive/deductive textual analysis of cases, geospatial visualization, descriptive statistics, and correlational analysis. Results indicate that more often than not, establishment of CBCs in Africa has led to negative or a mixture of positive and negative social outcomes, whereas ecological outcomes have been largely positive. The research conducted on CBC institutions has overwhelmingly focused on social outcomes, using qualitative methods. Monetary and nonmonetary incentives seem to be important but not sufficient on their own for positive outcomes. Devolution of rights to the local community is significantly associated with CBC outcomes but was not present in many cases, despite this feature being a hallmark of CBCs. A number of conditions were not reported in the cases reviewed, including leadership, social learning, consideration of cultural worldviews, and diverse partnerships. We provide indepth examples of the types and diversity of outcomes and contexts underpinning the presence or absence of societal processes, highlight important gaps in the existing research, and offer guidelines for research and evaluation moving forward.

【 授权许可】

Others