AUTONOMÍA PERSONAL Y REFLEXIÓN: UN ANÁLISIS DE LAS IDEAS DE HARRY FRANKFURT Y GERALD DWORKIN

UFSM Curso de Direito. Revista Eletronica

Juan Francisco Iosa¹ 

[1] Universidad Nacional de Córdoba

关键词: Personal Autonomy;    Gerald Dworkin;    Harry Frankfurt;    political liberalism;    liberal perfectionism.;    autonomía personal;    Gerald Dworkin;    Harry Frankfurt;    liberalismo político;    perfeccionismo liberal.;    autonomía personal;    Gerald Dworkin;    Harry Frankfurt;    liberalismo político;    perfeccionismo liberal.;   

DOI  :  10.5902/1981369426370

学科分类：社会科学、人文和艺术（综合）

来源: Universidade Federal de Santa Maria * Departamento de Direito

【 摘 要 】

I argue against a conception of personal autonomy focused on identification between desires of first and second order - here called empirical conception of second order preferences - and for a conception centered on the idea of reflection - the normative conception of second order preferences. Both, I assert, are possible readings of the theses about personal autonomy asserted by Harry Frankfurt and Gerald Dworkin. Because of its link with the empirical conception I reject here a radical liberalism involving the state's obligation to respect any self-regarding life plan preferred by the agent. By virtue of its connection to the normative conception I suggest, on the contrary, the feasibility of a liberal perfectionism such that the value of personal autonomy justifies state intervention in the life plans that jeopardize it.

【 授权许可】

CC BY