OS (DES)ACERTOS DO LEGISLADOR NA “POSITIVAÇÃO” DAS TEORIAS DE ROBERT ALEXY NO DIREITO PROCESSUAL CIVIL BRASILEIRO

UFSM Curso de Direito. Revista Eletronica

André Karam Trindade¹  João Carneiro Duarte Neto¹ 

[1] Programa de Pós-Graduação Stricto Sensu em Direito da Faculdade Guanambi (FG/BA)

关键词: Balancing of Rights;    Deliberation;    Legal Reasoning;    Robert Alexy;    New Brazilian Code of Civil Procedure.;    Justificación;    Nuevo Código de Procedimiento Civil;    Ponderación;    Robert Alexy;    Teoría de la argumentación jurídica;    fundamentação, novo código de processo civil, ponderação, Robert Alexy;    teoria da argumentação jurídica;   

DOI  :  10.5902/1981369429603

学科分类：社会科学、人文和艺术（综合）

来源: Universidade Federal de Santa Maria * Departamento de Direito

【 摘 要 】

This article deals with the application of Robert Alexy’s legal theories in Paragraphs 1 and 2 of article 489 of the Brazilian Civil Procedure Code. Therefore, the study is structured in two parts. In the first, it introduces the theory of juridical argumentation, briefly, and analyzes the provisions contained in Paragraph 1 of article 489 of the Civil Procedure Code based on the mentioned theory, observing the harmony between the legal text and Alexy’s doctrinal formulations. In the second part, the study presents his theory of fundamental rights, with emphasis on the distinction between rules and principles, maximum proportionality and deliberation technique, and examines Paragraph 2 of Article 489 of the Civil Procedure Code, verifying the total dissonance between the legal text and Alexy’s theoretical basis. In conclusion, at the end, the paper indicates the right and wrong decisions of the Brazilian legislators, pointing out their consequences for the Brazilian Law.

【 授权许可】

CC BY