Why should i comply? Sellers' accounts for (non-)compliance with legal age limits for alcohol sales

Substance Abuse Treatment, Prevention, and Policy

Menno DT De Jong¹  Joris J Van Hoof¹  Jordy F Gosselt¹ 

[1] Department of Communication Sciences, University of Twente, Enschede, the Netherlands

关键词: vendors;    adolescents;    availability;    alcohol sales;    age limits;    compliance;   

Others  :  834537
DOI  :  10.1186/1747-597X-7-5

 received in 2011-09-19, accepted in 2012-01-23,  发布年份 2012

【 摘 要 】

Background

Availability is an important predictor of early and excessive alcohol consumption by adolescents. Many countries have implemented age limits to prevent underage purchases of alcohol. However, shop-floor compliance with these age limits appears to be problematic. This study addresses the issue of non-compliance with age limits. Which measures do vendors take to avoid underage alcohol sales, and what do they report as important reasons to comply or not with age limits for alcohol sales?

Methods

Open-ended telephone interviews were conducted with store managers selling alcohol (N = 106). Prior to the interviews, all outlets were visited by an underage mystery shopper in order to measure compliance with the legal age limits on alcohol sales. The interview results are compared against actual compliance rates.

Results

Several measures have been taken to prevent underage sales, but the compliance level is low. Furthermore, open coding resulted in 19 themes, representing both valid and invalid arguments, that vendors mentioned as relevant to their decisions of whether to comply with the law. Compliance with age limits is dependent on the knowledge of the rules and the ability and motivation to follow the rules. The ability aspect in particular seems to be problematic, but in many cases, the motivation to actively comply with the age limits is lacking.

Conclusions

To enhance compliance, it is important to raise the awareness of the importance of age limits and to connect possible violations of the regulations to negative consequences.

【 授权许可】

   
2012 Gosselt et al; licensee BioMed Central Ltd.

【 参考文献 】

• [1]Hingson RW, Edwards EM, Heeren T, Rosenbloom D: Age of Drinking Onset and Injuries, Motor Vehicle Crashes, and Physical Fights after Drinking and When Not Drinking. Alcohol Clin Exp Res 2009, 33:783-790.
• [2]Derzon JH: A synthesis of research on predictors of youth alcohol, tobacco, and marijuana use. In Improving Prevention Effectiveness. Edited by Hansen WB, Giles SM, Fearnow-Kenney MD. Greensboro, NC: Tanglewood Research; 2000:105-114.
• [3]Hawkins JD, Catalano RF, Miller JY: Risk and protective factors for alcohol and other drug problems in adolescence and early adulthood: Implications for substance abuse prevention. Psychol Bull 1992, 112:64-105.
• [4]National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism: Youth drinking: Risk factors and consequences. Washington, DC: National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism; 1997. Alcohol Alert, No. 37
• [5]Paschall MJ, Grube JW, Kypri K: Alcohol control policies and alcohol consumption by youth: A multi-national study. Addiction 2009, 104:1849-1855.
• [6]Popova S, Giesbrecht N, Bekmuradov D, Patra J: Hours and days of sale and density of alcohol outlets: Impacts on alcohol consumption and damage: A systematic review. Alcohol Alcoholism 2009, 44:500-516.
• [7]Pokorny SB, Jason LA, Schoeny ME: The relation of retail tobacco availability to initiation and continued smoking. J Clin Child Adolsc 2003, 32:193-204.
• [8]Novak SP, Reardon SF, Raudenbush SW, Buka SL: Retail tobacco outlet density and youth cigarette smoking: a propensity-modeling approach. Am J Public Health 2006, 96:670-676.
• [9]Henriksen L, Feighery EC, Schleicher NC, Cowling DW, Kline RS, Fortmann SP: Is adolescent smoking related to the density and proximity of tobacco outlets and retail cigarette advertising near schools? Prev Med 2008, 47:210-214.
• [10]Vaucher S, Rehm J, Benvenuti J, Müller R: Young teenagers and access to alcohol in a Swiss canton. Evidence from observational testing and from a telephone survey. Addiction 1995, 90:1619-1625.
• [11]Britt H, Toomey TL, Dunsmuir W, Wagenaar AC: Propensity for and Correlates of Alcohol Sales to Underage Youth. J Alcohol Drug Educ 2006, 50:25-42.
• [12]Grube JW: Preventing sales of alcohol to minors: results from a community trial. Addiction 1997, 92:251-260.
• [13]Perry CL, Williams CL, Komro KA, Veblen-Mortenson S, Stigler MH, Munson KA, Farbakhsh K, Jones RM, Foster JL: Project Northland: Long-term outcomes of community action to reduce adolescent alcohol use. Health Educ Res 2002, 17:117-132.
• [14]Romano M, Duailibi SM, Pinsky I, Laranjeira R: Alcohol purchase survey by adolescents in two cities of State of São Paulo, Southeastern Brazil. Rev Saude Publ 2007, 41:495-501.
• [15]Van Hoof JJ, Moll M, Constantinescu M: Selling alcohol to underage adolescents in Romania: Compliance with age restrictions in Pitesti. Rev Cercet Interv So 2009, 27:82-91.
• [16]Willner P, Hart K, Binmore J, Cavendish M, Dunphy E: Alcohol sales to underage adolescents: an unobtrusive observational field study and evaluation of a police intervention. Addiction 2000, 95:1373-1388.
• [17]Gosselt JF, Van Hoof JJ, De Jong MDT, Prinsen S: Mystery shopping and alcohol sales: do supermarkets and liquor stores sell alcohol to underage customers? J Adolescent Health 2007, 41:302-308.
• [18]Forster JL, Murray DM, Wolfson M, Wagenaar AC: Commercial availability of alcohol to young people: Results of alcohol purchase attempts. Prev Med 1995, 24:342-347.
• [19]Dieth D: Testkaufe von Alcoholpraventive Repression oder repressive Pravention? Lausanne: Schweizerische Fachstelle fur Alcohol- und andere Drogenprobleme (SFA); 2005. In Abhangkeiten 3, 11
• [20]Babor T, Caetano R, Casswell S, Edwards G, Giesbrecht N, Graham K, Grube J, Gruenewald P, Hill L, Holder H, Homel R, Osterberg E, Rehm J, Room R, Rossow I: Alcohol: No Ordinary Commodity Research and Public Policy (second edition). Oxford University Press, Oxford, UK; 2010.
• [21]Room R, Babor T, Rehm J: Alcohol and public health. Lancet 2005, 365:519-530.
• [22]Wagenaar AC, Toomey TL, Erickson DJ: Complying with the minimum drinking age: Effects of enforcement and training interventions. Alcohol Clin Exp Res 2005, 29:255-262.
• [23]Dumouchel W, Williams AF, Zador PL: Raising the alcohol purchase age. Journal of Legal Studies 1987, 16:249-266.
• [24]Cummings KM, Hyland A, Saunders-Martin T, Perla J, Coppola PR, Pechacek TF: Evaluation of an enforcement program to reduce tobacco sales to minors. Am J Public Health 1998, 88:932-936.
• [25]Van Hoof JJ, Gosselt JF, Baas N, De Jong MDT: Improving shop floor compliance with age restrictions for alcohol sales: effectiveness of a feedback letter intervention. Eur J Public Health 2012, in press.
• [26]Gosselt JF, Van Hoof JJ, Baas N, De Jong MDT: Under 20? Show your ID! Effects of a national information campaign on compliance with age restrictions for alcohol sales. J Adolescent Health 2011, 49:97-98.
• [27]Krevor B, Capitman JA, Oblak L, Cannon JB, Ruwe M: Preventing Illegal Tobacco and Alcohol Sales to Minors through Electronic Age-Verification Devices: A Field Effectiveness Study. J Public Health Pol 2003, 24:251-268.
• [28]Van Hoof JJ, Gosselt JF, De Jong MDT: Shop Floor Compliance with Age Restrictions for Tobacco Sales: Remote Versus In-Store Age Verification. J Adolescent Health 2010, 46:197-199.
• [29]Black J, Baldwin R: Really Responsive Risk-Based Regulation. Law Policy 2010, 32:181-213.
• [30]Mellett M, Curtin C, Hennessey T, O'Hogan AM: Attainment of ecosystem based governance in European waters--A State property rights regime approach for Ireland. Mar Policy 2011, 35:739-747.
• [31]Nodora JN, Martz WD, Ashbeck EL, Jacobs ET, Thompson PA, Martínez ME: Primary care physician compliance with colorectal cancer screening guidelines. Cancer Cause Control 2011, 22:1277-1287.
• [32]Ribner BS, Hall C, Steinberg JP, Bornstein WA, Beasley K, Duffell JM, De Gennaro M, Garner D: A Web-based program to ensure compliance of medical staff providers with mandated health care facility requirements. Am J Infect Control 2011, 39:511-514.
• [33]Dorbeck-Jung BR, Oude Vrielink MJ, Gosselt JF, Van Hoof JJ, De Jong MDT: Contested hybridization of regulation: Failure of the Dutch regulatory system to protect minors from harmful media. Regul Gov 2010, 4:154-174.
• [34]Gunningham N: Environment, Self-Regulation, and the Chemical Industry: Assessing Responsible Care. Law Policy 1995, 17:57-109.
• [35]Halpern S: Hybrid Design, Systemic Rigidity: Institutional Dynamics in Human Research Oversight. Regul Gov 2008, 2:85-102.
• [36]Howard-Pitney B, Johnson MD, Altman DG, Hopkins R, Hammond N: Responsible alcohol service: a study of server, manager, and environmental impact. Am J Public Health 1991, 81:197-199.
• [37]Griffiths J: Legal Knowledge and the Social Working of Law: the Case of Euthanasia. In Semiotics and Legislation. Edited by Schooten H van. Liverpool: Deborah Charles; 1999:81-108.
• [38]Griffiths J: The Social working of Legal Rules. Journal of Legal Pluralism and Unofficial Law 2003, 48:1-84.
• [39]Havinga T: Private Regulation of Food Safety by Supermarkets. Law Policy 2006, 28:515-533.
• [40]Karlsson-Vinkhuyzen SI, Vihma A: Comparing the Legitimacy and Effectiveness of Global Hard and Soft Law: An Analytical Framework. Regul Gov 2009, 3:400-420.
• [41]Kagan RA, Scholz JT: The 'Criminology of the Corporation' and Regulatory Enforcement Strategies. In Enforcing Regulation. Edited by Hawkins K, Thomas JM. Boston: Kluwer/Nijhoff Publishing; 1984:132-1552.
• [42]Braithwaite V: Games and Engagement: Postures within the Regulatory Community. Law Policy 1995, 17:225-255.
• [43]Gunningham N, Kagan R, Thornton D: Social License and Environment Protection: Why Business Go Beyond Compliance. Berkeley: University of California; 2002.
• [44]Baldwin R, Black J: Really Responsive Regulation. The Modern Law Review 2008, 71:59-94.
• [45]Vogel D: The Private Regulation of Global Corporate Conduct. In The Politics of Global Regulation. Edited by Mattli W, Woods N. Princeton: UP; 2009:151-188.
• [46]Gosselt JF, Van Hoof JJ, De Jong MDT: Media Rating Systems: Do They Work? Compliance with Age Restrictions on the Shop Floor in the Netherlands. Mass Comm Society 2012, in press.
• [47]Bieleman B, Kruize A, Zimmerman C: [Monitor Alcohol Supply Adolescents. Compliance with age restrictions 16 and 18 Years: two-year measurements 1999-2009.]. In Monitor Alcoholverstrekking Jongeren 2009 Naleving leeftijdsgrenzen 16 en 18 jaar Drank- en Horecawet: tweejaarlijkse metingen 1999-2009. Groningen: Intraval; 2010.
• [48]Preusser DF, Williams AF: Sales of alcohol to underage purchasers in three New York counties and Washington, DC. J Public Health Policy 1992, 13:306-17.
• [49]Preusser DF, Williams AF, Weinstein HB: Policing underage alcohol sales. J Safety Res 1994, 25:127-33.
• [50]Wolfson M, Toomey TL, Murray DM, Forster JL, Short BJ, Wagenaar AC: Alcohol outlet policies and practices concerning sales to underage people. Addiction 1996, 9:598-602.
• [51]Freisthler B, Greunewald PJ, Treno AJ, et al.: Evaluating alcohol access and the alcohol environment in neighborhood areas. Alcohol Clin Exp Res 2003, 27:477-484.
• [52]Willner P, Hart K, Binmore J, Cavendish M, Dunphy E: Alcohol sales to underage adolescents: An unobtrusive observational field study and evaluation of a police intervention. Addiction 2000, 95:1373-88.
• [53]Mason J: Qualitative Researching, London: Sage. 2nd edition. 2002.
• [54]Law Enforcement Expertise Centre of the Dutch Ministry of Justice: The 'Table of Eleven'. A versatile tool. The Hague: Dutch Ministry of Justice; 2004.