期刊论文

【摘要】

This paper reviews the development of early Soviet drug treatment approaches by focusing on the struggle for disciplinary power between leading social and mental hygienists and clinical psychiatrists as a defining moment for Soviet drug treatment speciality that became known as "narcology." From this vantage point, I engage in the examination of the rise and fall of various treatment methods and conceptualizations of addiction in Russian metropolitan centres and look at how they were imported (or not) to other Soviet republics. As clinical psychiatrists appeared as undisputed victors from the battle with social and mental hygienists, the entire narcological arsenal was subdued in order to serve the needs of mainstream psychiatry. However, what that 'mainstream' would be, was not entirely clear. When, in 1934, Aleksandr Rapoport insisted on the need for re-working narcological knowledge in line with the Marxist approach, he could only raise questions and recognise that there were almost no "dialectically illuminated scientific data" to address these questions. The maintenance treatment of opiate users, which emerged as the most effective one based on the results of a six-year study published in 1936, was definitely not attuned to the political and ideological environment of the late 1930s. Maintenance was rather considered as a temporary solution, in the absence of radical therapeutic measures to free Soviet society from "narkomania." As the Great Terror swept across the Soviet Union, Stalin's regime achieved its objective of eliminating drug addiction from the surface of public life by driving opiate users deep underground and incarcerating many of them in prisons and the Gulag camps. In the final section, I briefly discuss the changing perceptions of drug use during the World War II and outline subsequent transformations in Soviet responses to the post-war opiate addiction [Additional file 1].

Additional file 1. Abstract. The Soviet doctor and the treatment of drug addiction: "A difficult andmost ungracious task". A Russian translation of an abstract of this article.

Format: PDFSize: 186KB Download file

This file can be viewed with: Adobe Acrobat Reader

【授权许可】

2011 Latypov; licensee BioMed Central Ltd.

【预览】

附件列表
Files	Size	Format	View
20140709032756754.pdf	610KB	PDF	download
Figure 1.	67KB	Image	download

【图表】

Figure 1.

【参考文献】

[1]Antsyferov LV: Gashishism v Turkestane i psikhozy v sviazi s nim. Turkestanskii Meditsinksii Zhurnal 1923, 2(10-12):305-308. [in Russian]
[2]Korsakov SS: Izbrannye Proizvedeniia. Moscow: Gosudarstvennoe Izdatel'stvo Meditsinskoi Literatury; 1954. [in Russian]
[3]Diukov P: Material dlia uchenia o deistvii opiia s primeneniem ego k psikhiatrii. In Dissertatsia na stepen' doktora meditsiny. St. Petersburg: Tipografiia Departamenta Vneshnei Torgovli; 1863. [in Russian]
[4]Danillo SN: O Vliianii Nekotorykh Iadov (Spirt, Opii, Gashish) na Soznanie u Cheloveka. Publichnaia Lektsiia. St. Petersburg: Izdanie KL Rikkera; 1894. [in Russian]
[5]Bereznitsky MI: Lechenie Gipnozom Morfinistov, Alkogolikov i Kuril'schikov. St. Petersburg: Izdanie K. L. Rikkera; 1906. [in Russian]
[6]Ortenberg P: O kuknaristakh Andizhanskogo uezda. Russkii Vrach 1907, 6(25):864-865. [in Russian]
[7]Dobrokhotov VP: K Kazuistike morfinizma. Russkii Vrach 1913, 12(33):1165-1169. [in Russian]
[8]Sirotkina I: Diagnosing Literary Genius: A Cultural History of Psychiatry in Russia, 1880-1930. Baltimore and London: The Johns Hopkins University Press; 2002.
[9]Weissman NB: Origins of Soviet health administration: Narkomzdrav, 1918-1928. In Health and Society in Revolutionary Russia. Edited by Solomon SG, Hutchinson JF. Bloomington and Indianapolis: Indiana University Press; 1990:97-120.
[10]Solomon SG: David and Goliath in Soviet public health: the rivalry of social hygienists and psychiatrists for authority over the bytovoi alcoholic. Soviet Studies 1989, 41(2):254-275.
[11]Solomon SG: Social hygiene and Soviet public health, 1921-1930. In Health and Society in Revolutionary Russia. Edited by Solomon SG, Hutchinson JF. Bloomington and Indianapolis: Indiana University Press; 1990:175-199.
[12]Sirotkina I: Klassiki i Psikhiatry: Psikhiatriia v Rossiiskoi Kul'ture Kontsa XIX - Nachala XX Veka. Moscow: Novoe Literaturnoe Obozrenie; 2009. [in Russian]
[13]Meyer A: The aims of a psychiatric clinic. In The Commonsense Psychiatry of Dr. Adolf Meyer: Fifty-two Selected Papers. Edited by Lief A. New York, Toronto, and London: McGraw-Hill Book Company, Inc; 1948:359-368.
[14]Rozenshtein LM: Public health service and mental hygiene in the U.S.S.R. Mental Hygiene 1931, 4:739-743. [in Russian]
[15]Iudin T: Ocherki Istorii Otechestvennoi Psikhiatrii. Moscow: Medgiz; 1951. [in Russian]
[16]Kutanin MP: Narkomaniia. Saratovskii Vestnik Zdravookhraneniia 1921, 2(5-8):36-51. [in Russian]
[17]Prozorov LA: Nevro-psikhiatricheskie dispansery i nevro-psikhiatricheskie otdeleniia dispansernykh ob"edinenii v 1929/1930 g. Zhurnal Nevropatologii i Psikhiatrii 1931, 6:73-83. [in Russian]
[18]Sholomovich AS: Otchet o dispansernoi bor'be s narkotizmom v Moskve. In Voprosy Narkologii. Volume 1. Edited by Sholomovich AS. Moscow: Izdanie Moszdravotdela; 1926::71-86. [in Russian]
[19]Zinov'ev PM: K Voprosu ob Organizatsii Nevro-psikhiatricheskikh Dispanserov (Razvitie Myslei Vtoroi Chasti Doklada na Vtorom Vserossiiskom Soveschanii po Voprosam Psikhiatrii i Nevrologii, 12-17 Noiabria 1923 g.) Moscow. 1924. [in Russian]
[20]Sholomovich AS: Osnovnye terminy i poniatiia narkoproblemy. In Voprosy Narkologii. Volume 1. Edited by Sholomovich AS. Moscow: Izdanie Moszdravotdela; 1926::5-7. [in Russian]
[21]Sholomovich AS: Narkotizm, kak sotsial'no-patologicheskoe iavlenie, i mery bor'by s nim sredi rabochikh. In Voprosy Narkologii. Volume 1. Edited by Sholomovich AS. Moscow: Izdanie Moszdravotdela; 1926::45-50. [in Russian]
[22]Barsukov MI, Vladimirtsev IN, Kuz'min MK, Nesterenko AI (Eds): Postanovlenie Soveta narodnykh komissarov RSFSR O blizhaishikh meropriiatiiakh v oblasti lechebno-predupreditel'noi i kul'turno-prosvetitel'noi raboty po bor'be s alkogolizmom, 11 sentiabria 1926 In Zdravookhranenie v Gody Vosstanovleniia i Sotsialisticheskoi Rekonstruktsii Narodnogo Khoziastva SSSR 1925-1940. Moscow: Meditsina; 1973:39. [in Russian]
[23]Prozorov LA: Sovetskoe zakonodatel'stvo po bor'be s alkogolizmom. In Voprosy Narkologii. Volume 2. Moscow: Izdanie Moszdravotdela; 1928::92-97. [in Russian]
[24]Transchel K: Under the Influence: Working-Class Drinking, Temperance, and Cultural Revolution in Russia, 1895-1932. Pittsburg: University of Pittsburgh Press; 2006.
[25]Sholomovich AS: Bor'ba s narkotizmom. Moskovskii Meditsinskii Zhurnal 1927, 5:123-128. [in Russian]
[26]Curry TB, Bacon DR, Rho RH: The history of subcutaneous oxygen therapy. Journal of Clinical Anesthesia 2006, 18(5):388-395.
[27]Golant RIa: Problemy morfinizma (klinicheskie i dispansernye nabliudenia, eksperimental'nye issledovaniia). In Trudy Gosudarstvennogo Instituta Meditsinskikh Znanii. Volume 5. Edited by Rozenberg NK. Leningrad: Izdanie Gosudarstvennogo Instituta Meditsinskikh Znanii; 1929::17-32. [in Russian]
[28]Kondratchenko AN: Obsledovanie gruppy opiomanov. Vrachebnaia Gazeta 1930, 17-18:1339-1346. [in Russian]
[29]Lebina N: Povsednevnaia Zhizn' Sovetskogo Goroda: Normy i Anomalii. 1920 - 1930 gody. St. Petersburg: Zhurnal "Neva" - Izdatel'sko-Torgovyi Dom "Letnii Sad"; 1999. [in Russian]
[30]White S: Russia Goes Dry: Alcohol, State and Society. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press; 1996.
[31]Phillips L: Bolsheviks and the Bottle: Drink and Worker Culture in St. Petersburg, 1900-1929. DeKalb: Northern Illinois University Press; 2000.
[32]Strelchuk IV: Klinika i Lechenie Narkomanii. Moscow: Gosudarstvennoe Izdatel'stvo Meditsinskoi Literatury MEDGIZ; 1956. [in Russian]
[33]Barsukov MI, Vladimirtsev IN, Kuz'min MK, Nesterenko AI (Eds): Postanovlenie kollegii NK RKI RSFSR O sostoianii psikhiatricheskikh bol'nits i postanovke psikhiatricheskogo dela v respublike In Zdravookhranenie v Gody Vosstanovleniia i Sotsialisticheskoi Rekonstruktsii Narodnogo Khoziastva SSSR 1925-1940. Moscow: Meditsina; 1973:174-176. [in Russian]
[34]Sirotkina I: Mental hygiene for Geniuses: psychiatry in the early Soviet years. Journal of the History of the Neurosciences 2007, 16(1):150-159.
[35]Zajicek B: Scientific psychiatry in Stalin's Soviet Union: the politics of modern medicine and the struggle to define 'Pavlovian' psychiatry, 1939-1953. PhD thesis. The University of Chicago; 2009.
[36]Ioffe Kh: Nervno-psikhicheskoe zdorov'e rabotnikov psikhiatricheskoi bol'nitsy. Meditsinskaia Mysl' Uzbekistana i Turkmenistana 1930, 7-8:84-88. [in Russian]
[37]Prozorov LA: Narkotizm i bor'ba s nim. Izvestiia Narodnogo Komissariata Zdravookhraneniia 1924, 2-3:21-28. [in Russian]
[38]Sereisky MIa: Konstitutsiia narkomanov. In Trudy Psikhiatricheskoi Kliniki (Devich'e Pole). Volume 1. Moscow: Izdanie M. i S. Sabashnikovykh; 1925::22-53. [in Russian]
[39]Gorovoi-Shaltan VA: Morfinizm, ego rasprostranenie i profilaktika. In Voprosy Narkologii. Volume 2. Moscow: Izdanie Moszdravotdela; 1928::46-53. [in Russian]
[40]Bluemenau EB: Okhmeliaiuschie Durmany. Tabak, Opii i Morfii, Kokain, Efir i Gashish, Ikh Vred i Posledstviia. Leningrad: Knigoizdatel'stvo "Seiatel'" E. V. Vysotskogo; 1925. [in Russian]
[41]Rapoport AM: Ob osnovnykh zadachakh sovetskoi narkologii. In Problemy Narkologii. Edited by Rapoport AM. Moscow and Leningrad: Gosudarstvennoe Meditsinskoe Izdatel'stvo; 1934:3-6. [in Russian]
[42]Strelchuk IV: Klinika i Terapiia Narkomanii. Moscow: Moskovskii Oblastnoi Klinicheskii Institut i Moskovskaia Oblastnaia Nevro-Psikhiatricheskaia Klinika; 1940. [in Russian]
[43]Bakhtiiarov VA: K voprosu o narkomanii. In Trudy Nauchno-Issledovatel'skikh Institutov Sverdlovskogo Oblzdravotdela. Volume 7. Edited by Konovalov KA. Sverdlovsk: Sverdlovskoe Oblastnoe Gosudarstvennoe Izdatel'stvo; 1936::199-204. [in Russian]
[44]Kondratchenko AN, Ioffe Kh: Opyt 1 1/2 - godichnoi raboty narkostatsionara Tashkentskogo nevro-psikhiatricheskogo dispansera. Zhurnal Nevropatologii i Psikhiatrii 1931, 6:83-89. [in Russian]
[45]Kamaev AL: Na putiakh bor'by s narkomaniiami. In Puti Sovetskoi Psikho-Nevrologii (Materialy 1-go Kraevogo S'ezda Psikhiatrov i Nevropatologov Srednevolzhskogo Kraia 5-11 Noiabria 1930 g.). Edited by Kamaev AL. Samara: Srednevolzhskii Kraizdrav; 1931:72-85. [in Russian]
[46]Kantorovich NV: Dispansernye nabliudeniia nad morfinistami. Sovetskaia Psikhonevrologiia 1936, 12(3):69-75. [in Russian]
[47]Khudiakov PP: Iz istorii bor'by s narkomaniei na Dal'nem Vostoke v nachale 20-kh gg. In Rossiia i Kitai na Dal'nevostochnykh Rubezhakh. Volume 2. Edited by Bolotin DP, Gerasimenko AP, Derevianko AlP, Derevianko AnP, Zabiako AP, Kosikhina SS, Lamin VA, Oglezneva EA, Plutenko AD, Ponkratova LA, Simutina NL, Filonov SV. Blagoveschensk: Izdatel'stvo Amurskogo Gosudarstvennogo Universiteta; 2001::424-430. [in Russian]
[48]Maslov EV: Problema narkomanii v Turkmenskoi SSR. Sovetskoe Zdravookhranenie Turkmenii 1939, 2-3:121-127. [in Russian]
[49]Smirnov BL: K probleme terapii reaktsii abstinentsii u opiomanov. In Trudy Turkmenskogo Gosudarstvennogo Nauchno-Issledovatel'skogo Instituta Nevrologii i Fiziatrii. Volume 1. Edited by Malykin RIa. Ashkhabad and Baku: Turkmengosizdat; 1936::143-154. [in Russian]
[50]Guliamov MG: Dostizheniia i perspektivy razvitiia psikhiatrii v Tadzhikistane. K 70-letiiu Velikogo Oktiabria. Zdravookhranenie Tadzhikistana 1987, 4:6-14. [in Russian]
[51]Guliamov MG, Subbotin AI: Psikhiatricheskaia pomosch i perspectivy ee razvitiia v Tadzhikistane. Zdravookhranenie Tadzhikistana 1972, 6:54-61. [in Russian]
[52]Guliamov MG, Subbotin AI: Razvitie psikhiatricheskoi nauki i praktiki. Zdravookhranenie Tadzhikistana 1984, 4:17-23. [in Russian]
[53]The Central State Archive of the Republic of Tajikistan (TsGA RT)f. 172, op. 1, d. 25, ll. 7, 8
[54]The Central State Archive of the Republic of Tajikistan (TsGA RT)f. 20, op. 3, d. 20, l. 93
[55]The Central State Archive of the Republic of Tajikistan (TsGA RT)f. 279, op. 7, d. 271
[56]The Central State Archive of the Republic of Tajikistan (TsGA RT)f. 279, op. 7, d. 272
[57]The Central State Archive of the Republic of Tajikistan (TsGA RT)f. 172, op. 1, d. 44
[58]Abdullaev SA, Alimova T, Bobodzhanov Iu, Rakhimov T: K istorii zdravookhraneniia v severnom Tadzhikistane. Zdravookhranenie Tadzhikistana 1986, 2:88-91. [in Russian]
[59]Ismailov II: Polveka fizlechebnitse. Zdravookhranenie Tadzhikistana 1980, 4:72-74. [in Russian]
[60]Tadzhiev IaT: Materialy k istorii zdravookhraneniia Tadzhikistana (Leninabadskaia oblast'). Zdravookhranenie Tadzhikistana 1984, 2:76-80. [in Russian]
[61]Antsyferov LV: Gashishizm v Srednei Azii. Tahskent: Prilozhenie k Zhurnalu Za Sotsialisticheskoe Zdravookhranenie Uzbekistana 8-9; 1934. [in Russian]
[62]Maev P: Aziatskii Tashkent. In Materialy dlia Statistiki Turkestanskogo Kraia. Ezhegodnik. Volume IV. Edited by Maev NA. St. Petersburg: Tipografiia i Khromolitografiia A. Transhelia; 1876::271-282. [in Russian]
[63]Ostroumov NP: Sarty. Etnograficheskie Materialy. Tashkent: Izdanie Knizhnogo Magazina "Bukinist"; 1896. [in Russian]
[64]Vereschagin VV: Dukhobortsy i Molokane v Zakavkaz'e. Shiity v Karabakhe. Batchi i Opiumoedy v Srednei Azii. Ober-Amergau v Gorakh Bavarii. Moscow: Tipo-litografiia Tovarischestva I. N. Kushnerev i Ko; 1900. [in Russian]
[65]Mustafetova PK, Pogosov AV: Klinicheskie osobennosti koknarovoi narkomanii. [http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed?term=mustafetova%20pogosov] webciteZhurnal Nevrologii i Psikhiatrii Imeni S. S. Korsakova 1999, 99(4):25-28. [in Russian]
[66]Kerimi NB: Opium use in Turkmenistan: a historical perspective. Addiction 2000, 95(9):1319-1333.
[67]Boyish: Shira khāna. Er Uzi 1925, 1:4-5. [in Uzbek]
[68]Blankfel'd AE: K voprosu o lekarstvennoi narkomanii. Za Sotsialisticheskoe Zdravookhranenie Uzbekistana 1933, 4-5:137-139. [in Russian]
[69]Strelchuk IV: K voprosu o lechenii morfiinoi abstinentsii. In Problemy Narkologii. Edited by Rapoport AM. Moscow and Leningrad: Gosudarstvennoe Meditsinskoe Izdatel'stvo; 1934:55-60. [in Russian]
[70]Blankfel'd A: Perezhivaniia opiofaga vo vremia iavlenii vozderzhaniia. In Trudy Respublikanskoi Psikhiatricheskoi Bol'nitsy. Volume 1. Edited by Antsyferov LV, Kevorkov N. Tashkent: Izdanie Respublikanskoi Psikhiatricheskoi Bol'nitsy Narkomzdrava UzSSR; 1934::151-153. [in Russian]
[71]Streliukhin AK: Osobennosti techeniia opiomanii u beremennykh. Sovetskoe Zdravookhranenie Turkmenii 1939, 1:145-155. [in Russian]
[72]Kalachev B: Narkomafia s "borodoi": kogda poiavilas' u nas "chuma XX veka"? Rodina 1990, 8:28-29. [in Russian]
[73]Kurmanov KSh: Narkomaniia: Ugolovno-Pravovye i Kriminologicheskie Problemy. Frunze: Ilim; 1989. [in Russian]
[74]Levin MB: The pattern of drug use diffusion in the USSR. In MSc thesis. University of Wisconsin; 1991.
[75]Blinovsky IuA: K voprosy o lechenii narkomanov nikotinovoi kislotoi i oblegchenii abstinentsii. In Trudy Respublikanskoi Psikhiatricheskoi Klinicheskoi Bol'nitsy. Volume 2. Edited by Detengof FF, Guliamov MG. Tashkent: Izdatel'stvo Akademii Nauk UzSSR; 1949::228-232. [in Russian]
[76]Guliamov MG: Mezhrespublikanskaia konferentsiia psikhiatrov. Za Sotsialisticheskoe Zdravookhranenie Uzbekistana 1953, 1:45-48. [in Russian]
[77]Epifanova NM: Giperbaricheskaia oksigenatsiia v lechenii bol'nykh narkomaniei, toksikomaniei i alkogolizmom v postintoksikatsionnom i abstinentnom periodakh. Anesteziologiia i Reanimatologiia 1995, 3:34-39. [in Russian]
[78]Ostroglazov V: Mif o gravidane. K 70-letiiu Moskovskoi oblastnoi psikhiatricheskoi bol'nitsy № 5. Predistoriia. Nezavisimyi Psikhiatricheskii Zhurnal 2008, 3:73-89. [in Russian]
[79]Zhirnov E: Arkhiv. Mocha i kamen. Kommersant Vlast' 2001, 49:56-58. [in Russian]
[80]Zhirnov E: Progressiruiuschee istoschenie nervnoi sistemy. Kommersant Vlast' 2009., 19(823) [in Russian]
[81]Arkhiv. Pamiatnye resheniia Kommersant Vlast' 2003, 32:47. [in Russian]

Harm Reduction Journal
The Soviet doctor and the treatment of drug addiction:

Alisher B Latypov¹
[1] Eurasian Harm Reduction Network (EHRN), 11B Svitrigailos Street, Vilnius 03228, Lithuania
关键词: repression of drug users; opiate maintenance therapy; addiction treatment; psychiatry; social and mental hygiene; history; Soviet narcology;
Others : 810085 DOI : 10.1186/1477-7517-8-32

received in 2011-09-09, accepted in 2011-12-30, 发布年份 2011
PDF


	文献评价指标
	下载次数：17次	浏览次数：17次

【 摘 要 】

【 授权许可】

【 预 览 】

【 图 表 】

【 参考文献 】

【摘要】

【授权许可】

【预览】

【图表】

【参考文献】