Choosing healthier foods in recreational sports settings: a mixed methods investigation of the impact of nudging and an economic incentive

International Journal of Behavioral Nutrition and Physical Activity

Kim D Raine³  Linda J McCargar¹  Laksiri A Goonewardene²  Dana Lee Olstad³ 

[1]Department of Agricultural, Food and Nutritional Science, 4–10 Agriculture/Forestry Centre, University of Alberta, Edmonton, AB T6G 2P5, Canada

[2]Alberta Agriculture and Rural Development, Government of Alberta, #307, 7000 113 Street, J.G. O’Donoghue Building, Edmonton, AB T6H 5T6, Canada

[3]Centre for Health Promotion Studies, University of Alberta, 3-300 ECHA, 11405 87 Ave, Edmonton, AB T6G 1C9, Canada

关键词: Mixed methods;    Behavioral economics;    Profit;    Community context;    Dietary behaviors;    Healthy food;    Economic incentive;    Nudge;    Intervention;    Environmental change;   

Others  :  805652
DOI  :  10.1186/1479-5868-11-6

 received in 2013-06-01, accepted in 2014-01-21,  发布年份 2014

【 摘 要 】

Background

Nudging is an approach to environmental change that alters social and physical environments to shift behaviors in positive, self-interested directions. Evidence indicates that eating is largely an automatic behavior governed by environmental cues, suggesting that it might be possible to nudge healthier dietary behaviors. This study assessed the comparative and additive efficacy of two nudges and an economic incentive in supporting healthy food purchases by patrons at a recreational swimming pool.

Methods

An initial pre-intervention period was followed by three successive and additive interventions that promoted sales of healthy items through: signage, taste testing, and 30% price reductions; concluding with a return to baseline conditions. Each period was 8 days in length. The primary outcome was the change in the proportion of healthy items sold in the intervention periods relative to pre- and post-intervention in the full sample, and in a subsample of patrons whose purchases were directly observed. Secondary outcomes included change in the caloric value of purchases, change in revenues and gross profits, and qualitative process observations. Data were analyzed using analysis of covariance, chi-square tests and thematic content analysis.

Results

Healthy items represented 41% of sales and were significantly lower than sales of unhealthy items (p < 0.0001). In the full sample, sales of healthy items did not differ across periods, whereas in the subsample, sales of healthy items increased by 30% when a signage + taste testing intervention was implemented (p < 0.01). This increase was maintained when prices of healthy items were reduced by 30%, and when all interventions were removed. When adults were alone they purchased more healthy items compared to when children were present during food purchases (p < 0.001), however parental choices were not substantially better than choices made by children alone.

Conclusions

This study found mixed evidence for the efficacy of nudging in cueing healthier dietary behaviors. Moreover, price reductions appeared ineffectual in this setting. Our findings point to complex, context-specific patterns of effectiveness and suggest that nudging should not supplant the use of other strategies that have proven to promote healthier dietary behaviors.

【 授权许可】

   
2014 Olstad et al.; licensee BioMed Central Ltd.

【 图 表 】

Figure 1.

Figure 2.

【 参考文献 】

• [1]Cohen D, Farley TA: Eating as an automatic behavior. Prev Chronic Dis 2008, 5(1):A23.
• [2]Cohen DA, Babey SH: Contextual influences on eating behaviours: heuristic processing and dietary choices. Obes Rev 2012, 13(9):766-779.
• [3]Marteau TM, Hollands GJ, Fletcher PC: Changing human behavior to prevent disease: the importance of targeting automatic processes. Science 2012, 337(6101):1492-1495.
• [4]Marteau TM, Ogilvie D, Roland M, Suhrcke M, Kelly MP: Judging nudging: can nudging improve population health? BMJ 2011, 342:d228.
• [5]Downs J, Loewenstein G, Wisdom J: Strategies for promoting healthier choices. Am Econ Rev 2009, 99(2):159-164.
• [6]Thaler R, Sunstein C: Nudge: improving decisions about health, wealth and happiness. New York: Penguin Books; 2008.
• [7]Hanks AS, Just DR, Smith LE, Wansink B: Healthy convenience: nudging students toward healthier choices in the lunchroom. J Public Health (Oxf) 2012, 34(3):370-376.
• [8]Wansink B, Just DR, Hanks AS, Smith LE: Pre-sliced fruit in school cafeterias: children’s selection and intake. Am J Prev Med 2013, 44(5):477-480.
• [9]Just DR, Lund J, Price J: The role of variety in increasing the consumption of fruits and vegetables among children. Agric Resour Econ Rev 2012, 41(1):72-81.
• [10]Just D, Wansink B: Smarter lunchrooms: using behavioral economics to improve meal selection. Choices 2009., 24(3)
• [11]Schwartz MB: The influence of a verbal prompt on school lunch fruit consumption: a pilot study. Int J Behav Nutr Phys Act 2007, 4:6. BioMed Central Full Text
• [12]Perry CL, Bishop DB, Taylor GL, Davis M, Story M, Gray C, Bishop SC, Mays RA, Lytle LA, Harnack L: A randomized school trial of environmental strategies to encourage fruit and vegetable consumption among children. Health Educ Behav 2004, 31(1):65-76.
• [13]de Droog SM, Valkenburg PM, Buijzen M: Using brand characters to promote young children’s liking of and purchase requests for fruit. J Health Commun 2011, 16(1):79-89.
• [14]Wansink B, Painter JE, van Ittersum K: Descriptive menu labels’ effect on sales. Cornell Hosp Q 2001, 42(6):68-72.
• [15]Thorndike A, Sonnenberg L, Riis J, Barraclough S, Levy D: A 2-phase labeling and choice architecture intervention to improve healthy food and beverage choices. Am J Public Health 2012. epub ahead of print
• [16]Wisdom J, Downs J, Loewenstein G: Promoting healthy choices: Information versus convenience. Am Econ J 2010, 2:164-178.
• [17]Rozin P, Scott S, Dingley M, Urbanek J, Jiang H, Kaltenbach M: Nudge to nobesity I: minor changes in accessibility decrease food intake. Judgment Decis Making 2011, 6(4):323-332.
• [18]Skov LR, Lourenco S, Hansen GL, Mikkelsen BE, Schofield C: Choice architecture as a means to change eating behaviour in self-service settings: a systematic review. Obes Rev 2013, 14(3):187-196.
• [19]Naylor PJ, Bridgewater L, Purcell M, Ostry A, Wekken SV: Publically funded recreation facilities: obesogenic environments for children and families? Int J Environ Res Public Health 2010, 7(5):2208-2221.
• [20]Olstad DL, Downs SM, Raine KD, Berry TR, McCargar LJ: Improving children’s nutrition environments: a survey of adoption and implementation of nutrition guidelines in recreational facilities. BMC Public Health 2011, 11:423. BioMed Central Full Text
• [21]Olstad DL, Raine KD, McCargar LJ: Adopting and implementing nutrition guidelines in recreational facilities: public and private sector roles. A multiple case study. BMC Public Health 2012, 12:376. BioMed Central Full Text
• [22]Naylor PJ, Wekken SV, Trill D, Kirbyson A: Facilitating healthier food environments in public recreation facilities: results of a pilot project in British Columbia, Canada. J Park Recreation Adm 2010, 28(4):37-58.
• [23]Thomas H, Irwin J: Food choices in recreation facilities: operators’ and patrons’ perspectives. Can J Diet Pract Res 2010, 71(4):180-185.
• [24]Vander Wekken S, Sorensen S, Meldrum J, Naylor PJ: Exploring industry perspectives on implementation of a provincial policy for food and beverage sales in publicly funded recreation facilities. Health Policy 2012, 104(3):279-287.
• [25]Olstad DL, Raine KD, McCargar LJ: Adopting and implementing nutrition guidelines in recreational facilities: tensions between public health and corporate profitability. Public Health Nutr 2013, 16(5):815-823.
• [26]O’Dea JA: Why do kids eat healthful food? Perceived benefits of and barriers to healthful eating and physical activity among children and adolescents. J Am Diet Assoc 2003, 103(4):497-501.
• [27]Glanz K, Basil M, Maibach E, Goldberg J, Snyder D: Why Americans eat what they do: taste, nutrition, cost, convenience, and weight control concerns as influences on food consumption. J Am Diet Assoc 1998, 98(10):1118-1126.
• [28]Blanchette L, Brug J: Determinants of fruit and vegetable consumption among 6-12-year-old children and effective interventions to increase consumption. J Hum Nutr Diet 2005, 18(6):431-443.
• [29]Larson N, Laska MN, Story M, Neumark-Sztainer D: Predictors of fruit and vegetable intake in young adulthood. J Acad Nutr Diet 2012, 112(8):1216-1222.
• [30]Krolner R, Rasmussen M, Brug J, Klepp KI, Wind M, Due P: Determinants of fruit and vegetable consumption among children and adolescents: a review of the literature. Part II: qualitative studies. Int J Behav Nutr Phys Act 2011, 8:112. BioMed Central Full Text
• [31]Drewnowski A: Taste preferences and food intake. Annu Rev Nutr 1997, 17:237-253.
• [32]Schickenberg B, van Assema P, Brug J, de Vries NK: Product samples stimulate choice of unfamiliar healthful food products. Appetite 2011, 57(1):197-201.
• [33]Birch LL, Marlin DW: I don’t like it; I never tried it: effects of exposure on two-year-old children’s food preferences. Appetite 1982, 3(4):353-360.
• [34]Baranowski T, Davis M, Resnicow K, Baranowski J, Doyle C, Lin LS, Smith M, Wang DT: Gimme 5 fruit, juice, and vegetables for fun and health: outcome evaluation. Health Educ Behav 2000, 27(1):96-111.
• [35]Reynolds KD, Franklin FA, Binkley D, Raczynski JM, Harrington KF, Kirk KA, Person S: Increasing the fruit and vegetable consumption of fourth-graders: results from the high 5 project. Prev Med 2000, 30(4):309-319.
• [36]Perry CL, Bishop DB, Taylor G, Murray DM, Mays RW, Dudovitz BS, Smyth M, Story M: Am J Public Health. 1998, 88(4):603-609.
• [37]Horne PJ, Tapper K, Lowe CF, Hardman CA, Jackson MC, Woolner J: Increasing children’s fruit and vegetable consumption: a peer-modelling and rewards-based intervention. Eur J Clin Nutr 2004, 58(12):1649-1660.
• [38]Gittelsohn J, Suratkar S, Song HJ, Sacher S, Rajan R, Rasooly IR, Bednarek E, Sharma S, Anliker JA: Process evaluation of Baltimore Healthy Stores: a pilot health intervention program with supermarkets and corner stores in Baltimore City. Health Promot Pract 2010, 11(5):723-732.
• [39]Curran S, Gittelsohn J, Anliker J, Ethelbah B, Blake K, Sharma S, Caballero B: Process evaluation of a store-based environmental obesity intervention on two American Indian Reservations. Health Educ Res 2005, 20(6):719-729.
• [40]Gittelsohn J, Dyckman W, Frick KD, Boggs MK, Haberle H, Alfred J, Vastine A, Palafox N: A pilot food store intervention in the Republic of the Marshall Islands. Pac Health Dialog 2007, 14(2):43-53.
• [41]Ho LS, Gittelsohn J, Rimal R, Treuth MS, Sharma S, Rosecrans A, Harris SB: An integrated multi-institutional diabetes prevention program improves knowledge and healthy food acquisition in northwestern Ontario First Nations. Health Educ Behav 2008, 35(4):561-573.
• [42]Wansink B, van Ittersum K, Painter JE: How descriptive food names bias sensory perceptions in restaurants. Food Qual Prefer 2005, 16:393-400.
• [43]Jensen JD, Hartmann H, de Mul A, Schuit A, Brug J: Economic incentives and nutritional behavior of children in the school setting: a systematic review. Nutr Rev 2011, 69(11):660-674.
• [44]An R: Effectiveness of subsidies in promoting healthy food purchases and consumption: a review of field experiments. Public Health Nutr 2012, 16(7):1-14.
• [45]Alberta Health and Wellness: The Alberta nutrition guidelines for children and youth. 2012. Available at: http://www.healthyalberta.com/NutritionGuidelines-Sept2012.pdf webcite
• [46]Stunkard AJ, Sorenson TI, Schulsinger F: Use of the Danish adoption register for the study of obesity and thinness. In The genetics of neurological and psychiatric disorders. Edited by Kety S. New York: Raven; 1983:115-120.
• [47]Warschburger P, Kroller K: Maternal perception of weight status and health risks associated with obesity in children. Pediatrics 2009, 124(1):e60-e68.
• [48]Spradley J: Doing participant observation. In Participant observation. New York: Holt, Rinehart and Winston; 1980.
• [49]Raghunathan R, Walker RE, Hoyer WD: The unhealthy = tasty intuition and its effects on taste inferences, enjoyment and choice of food products. Adv Consum Res 2006, 33:450-451.
• [50]Bublitz MG LAP, Block LG: Why did I eat that? Perspectives on food decision making and dietary restraint. J Consum Psychol 2010, 20:239-258.
• [51]van Kleef E, Otten K, van Trijp HC: Healthy snacks at the checkout counter: a lab and field study on the impact of shelf arrangement and assortment structure on consumer choices. BMC Public Health 2012, 12(1):1072. BioMed Central Full Text
• [52]Epstein LH, Jankowiak N, Nederkoorn C, Raynor HA, French SA, Finkelstein E: Experimental research on the relation between food price changes and food-purchasing patterns: a targeted review. Am J Clin Nutr 2012, 95(4):789-809.
• [53]Faith MS, Fontaine KR, Baskin ML, Allison DB: Toward the reduction of population obesity: macrolevel environmental approaches to the problems of food, eating, and obesity. Psychol Bull 2007, 133(2):205-226.
• [54]French SA, Story M, Jeffery RW, Snyder P, Eisenberg M, Sidebottom A, Murray D: Pricing strategy to promote fruit and vegetable purchase in high school cafeterias. J Am Diet Assoc 1997, 97(9):1008-1010.
• [55]Jue JJ, Press MJ, McDonald D, Volpp KG, Asch DA, Mitra N, Stanowski AC, Loewenstein G: The impact of price discounts and calorie messaging on beverage consumption: a multi-site field study. Prev Med 2012, 55(6):629-633.
• [56]Powell LM, Chriqui JF, Khan T, Wada R, Chaloupka FJ: Assessing the potential effectiveness of food and beverage taxes and subsidies for improving public health: a systematic review of prices, demand and body weight outcomes. Obes Rev 2013, 14(2):110-128.
• [57]Powell LM, Zhao Z, Wang Y: Food prices and fruit and vegetable consumption among young American adults. Health Place 2009, 15(4):1064-1070.
• [58]Powell LM, Chaloupka FJ: Food prices and obesity: evidence and policy implications for taxes and subsidies. Milbank Q 2009, 87(1):229-257.
• [59]Sturm R, Powell LM, Chriqui JF, Chaloupka FJ: Soda taxes, soft drink consumption, and children’s body mass index. Health Aff (Millwood) 2010, 29(5):1052-1058.
• [60]Beydoun MA, Powell LM, Chen X, Wang Y: Food prices are associated with dietary quality, fast food consumption, and body mass index among U.S. children and adolescents. J Nutr 2011, 141(2):304-311.
• [61]Per capital real GDP by state. [http://www.bea.gov/iTable/iTable.cfm?reqid=70&step=1&isuri=1&acrdn=1#reqid=70&step=1&isuri=1 webcite]
• [62]Median total income, by family type, by census metropolitan area. [http://www.statcan.gc.ca/tables-tableaux/sum-som/l01/cst01/famil107a-eng.htm webcite]
• [63]Humbert ML, Chad KE, Spink KS, Muhajarine N, Anderson KD, Bruner MW, Girolami TM, Odnokon P, Gryba CR: Factors that influence physical activity participation among high- and low-SES youth. Qual Health Res 2006, 16(4):467-483.
• [64]Horgen KB, Brownell KD: Comparison of price change and health message interventions in promoting healthy food choices. Health Psychol 2002, 21(5):505-512.
• [65]Eyles H, Ni Mhurchu C, Nghiem N, Blakely T: Food pricing strategies, population diets, and non-communicable disease: a systematic review of simulation studies. PLoS Med 2012, 9(12):e1001353.
• [66]Andreyeva T, Long MW, Brownell KD: The impact of food prices on consumption: a systematic review of research on the price elasticity of demand for food. Am J Public Health 2010, 100(2):216-222.
• [67]Phipps SA, Burton PS, Osberg LS, Lethbridge LN: Poverty and the extent of child obesity in Canada, Norway and the United States. Obes Rev 2006, 7(1):5-12.
• [68]Robert SA, Reither EN: A multilevel analysis of race, community disadvantage, and body mass index among adults in the US. Soc Sci Med 2004, 59(12):2421-2434.
• [69]Epstein LH, Dearing KK, Paluch RA, Roemmich JN, Cho D: Price and maternal obesity influence purchasing of low- and high-energy-dense foods. Am J Clin Nutr 2007, 86(4):914-922.
• [70]Vyth EL, Steenhuis IH, Heymans MW, Roodenburg AJ, Brug J, Seidell JC: Influence of placement of a nutrition logo on cafeteria menu items on lunchtime food Choices at Dutch work sites. J Am Diet Assoc 2011, 111(1):131-136.
• [71]Dubbert PM, Johnson WG, Schlundt DG, Montague NW: The influence of caloric information on cafeteria food choices. J Appl Behav Anal 1984, 17(1):85-92.
• [72]Buscher LA, Martin KA, Crocker S: Point-of-purchase messages framed in terms of cost, convenience, taste, and energy improve healthful snack selection in a college foodservice setting. J Am Diet Assoc 2001, 101(8):909-913.
• [73]Mishra A, Mishra H, Masters TM: The influence of bite size on quantity of food consumed: a field study. J Consum Res 2012, 38:791-795.
• [74]Meyers AW, Stunkard AJ, Coll M: Food accessibility and food choice. A test of Schachter’s externality hypothesis. Arch Gen Psychiatry 1980, 37(10):1133-1135.
• [75]Auchincloss AH, Young C, Davis AL, Wasson S, Chilton M, Karamanian V: Barriers and facilitators of consumer use of nutrition labels at sit-down restaurant chains. Public Health Nutr 2013, 21(3):1-8.
• [76]Block JP, Chandra A, McManus KD, Willett WC: Point-of-purchase price and education intervention to reduce consumption of sugary soft drinks. Am J Public Health 2010, 100(8):1427-1433.
• [77]Giskes K, Van Lenthe FJ, Brug J, Mackenbach JP, Turrell G: Socioeconomic inequalities in food purchasing: the contribution of respondent-perceived and actual (objectively measured) price and availability of foods. Prev Med 2007, 45(1):41-48.
• [78]Holsten JE, Deatrick JA, Kumanyika S, Pinto-Martin J, Compher CW: Children’s food choice process in the home environment. A qualitative descriptive study. Appetite 2012, 58(1):64-73.
• [79]Lytle LA: Measuring the food environment: state of the science. Am J Prev Med 2009, 36(4 Suppl):S134-S144.
• [80]Elbel B, Gyamfi J, Kersh R: Child and adolescent fast-food choice and the influence of calorie labeling: a natural experiment. Int J Obes (Lond) 2011, 35(4):493-500.
• [81]Herman AN, Malhotra K, Wright G, Fisher JO, Whitaker RC: A qualitative study of the aspirations and challenges of low-income mothers in feeding their preschool-aged children. Int J Behav Nutr Phys Act 2012, 9(1):132. BioMed Central Full Text
• [82]Petrunoff NA, Wilkenfeld RL, King LA, Flood VM: Treats’, ‘sometimes foods’, ‘junk’: a qualitative study exploring ‘extra foods’ with parents of young children. Public Health Nutr 2012, 1-8. (epub ahead of print)
• [83]Epstein LH, Dearing KK, Handley EA, Roemmich JN, Paluch RA: Relationship of mother and child food purchases as a function of price: a pilot study. Appetite 2006, 47(1):115-118.
• [84]Klesges RC, Stein RJ, Eck LH, Isbell TR, Klesges LM: Parental influence on food selection in young children and its relationships to childhood obesity. Am J Clin Nutr 1991, 53(4):859-864.
• [85]Disantis KI, Grier SA, Odoms-Young A, Baskin ML, Carter-Edwards L, Young DR, Lassiter V, Kumanyika SK: What “price” means when buying food: insights from a multisite qualitative study with black Americans. Am J Public Health 2013, 103(3):516-522.
• [86]Slater J, Sevenhuysen G, Edginton B, O’Neil J: ‘Trying to make it all come together’: structuration and employed mothers’ experience of family food provisioning in Canada. Health Promot Int 2012, 27(3):405-415.
• [87]Haynes-Maslow L, Parsons SE, Wheeler SB, Leone LA: A qualitative study of perceived barriers to fruit and vegetable consumption among low-income populations, north Carolina, 2011. Prev Chronic Dis 2013, 10:E34.
• [88]Rasmussen M, Krolner R, Klepp KI, Lytle L, Brug J, Bere E, Due P: Determinants of fruit and vegetable consumption among children and adolescents: a review of the literature. Part I: Quantitative studies. Int J Behav Nutr Phys Act 2006, 3:22. BioMed Central Full Text
• [89]Pearson N, Biddle SJ, Gorely T: Family correlates of fruit and vegetable consumption in children and adolescents: a systematic review. Public Health Nutr 2009, 12(2):267-283.
• [90]Hannan P, French SA, Story M, Fulkerson JA: A pricing strategy to promote sales of lower fat foods in high school cafeterias: acceptability and sensitivity analysis. Am J Health Promot 2002, 17(1):1-6. ii
• [91]Wilbur CS, Zifferblatt SM, Pinsky JL, Zifferblatt S: Healthy vending: a cooperative pilot research program to stimulate good health in the marketplace. Prev Med 1981, 10(1):85-93.
• [92]Waterlander WE, Steenhuis IH, de Boer MR, Schuit AJ, Seidell JC: Introducing taxes, subsidies or both: the effects of various food pricing strategies in a web-based supermarket randomized trial. Prev Med 2012, 54(5):323-330.
• [93]Johnson DB, Payne EC, McNeese MA, Allen D: Menu-labeling policy in king county, Washington. Am J Prev Med 2012, 43(3 Suppl 2):S130-S135.
• [94]Rice T: The behavioral economics of health and health care. Annu Rev Public Health 2013, 34:431-447.