Lessons from history: morbidity of cold injury in the Royal Marines during the Falklands Conflict of 1982

Extreme Physiology & Medicine

Roger Pethybridge³  Deborah Gallimore³  Thomas James Roose Francis¹  Francis St Clair Golden² 

[1] Diving Diseases Research Centre, Plymouth, UK;Extreme Environments Laboratory, Department of Sport and Exercise Science (DSES), University of Portsmouth, Spinnaker Building, Cambridge Road, Portsmouth PO1 2ER, UK;Institute of Naval Medicine, Gosport Hants PO12 2DL, UK

关键词: Non-battle-related injury;    Trench foot;    Frostbite;    Cold sensitivity;    Non-freezing cold injury;   

Others  :  804766
DOI  :  10.1186/2046-7648-2-23

 received in 2012-09-28, accepted in 2013-07-23,  发布年份 2013

【 摘 要 】

Background

Environmental conditions in the Falklands Conflict of 1982 favoured the genesis of cold injuries. Immediately, post-war, cold injury morbidity and its contributory factors were assessed, in the personnel of UK 3 Commando Brigade (3 Cdo Bde).

Methods

A questionnaire survey of the 3,006 members of 3 Cdo Bde who landed on the islands was conducted within 6–10 weeks of the end of hostilities. Questions included those relating to features of cold injury, body morphology, age, symptoms experienced, past medical history and other possible contributory causes. Additionally, the unit medical team conducted a cursory examination. Data were sent to the Royal Navy Institute of Naval Medicine (INM), where the degree of likely cold injury was broadly classified (‘asymptomatic’ ‘mild’, ‘moderate’ or ‘severe’). A sample (total 109) was then selected at random from each category and subsequently examined and tested at the INM (nerve conduction, photoplethysmography and thermography testing). Forty-seven non-cold exposed sailors acted as a control group. These contemporaneous records have now been identified and interrogated.

Results

Some 2,354 (78%) completed questionnaires were returned, revealing that 1,505 (64%) had experienced symptoms of non-freezing cold injury. The morbidity in the infantry units was significantly greater than that in the support troops (1,051 (76%) vs 454 (46%), p < 0.05). No evidence was found to support an influence of a number of factors, commonly believed to have an aetiological role in the production of cold injury. Whilst there was no significant relationship between past history and cold injury morbidity in the brigade as a whole, or within the infantry units alone, an association was identified in the collective infantry units (73%) and the support/headquarter units (59%) (p < 0.05).

In comparison with uninjured sailors who acted as controls (n = 47), nerve conduction was impaired in 35% of those screened some months after returning to the UK, while the photoplethysmography and thermographic responses to a cold sensitivity test showed that most (including those classed by questionnaire as asymptomatic) had residual ‘cold sensitivity’.

Conclusions

Although the passage of time has made retrospective interrogation of historical documents hard, the available data do appear to offer valuable historical and clinical insights. Cold injury affected the majority of those fighting in the cold temperate climate of the Falklands. The overwhelming environmental conditions meant that, for most, a past history of cold injury did not appear to represent a risk factor for subsequent injury, as is the case for less severe conditions. Importantly, even asymptomatic individuals when tested often showed physiological evidence of cold injury—perhaps predisposing them to subsequent elevation in risk.

【 授权许可】

   
2013 Golden et al.; licensee BioMed Central Ltd.

【 图 表 】

Figure 1.

Figure 2.

【 参考文献 】

• [1]Smith JL, Ritchie J, Dawson J: On the pathology of trench frostbite. Lancet 1915, 186:595-598.
• [2]Hughes B: The causes and prevention of trench foot. Brit Med J 1916, 1:712-714.
• [3]Whayne TF, DeBakey M: Cold Injury, Ground Type. Washington DC: Office of the Surgeon General, Department of the Army; 1958. 48:83–142
• [4]Corbett DO, Benson P: Medical aspects of harsh environments: cold-induced injury. In Textbook of Military Medicine: Medical Aspects of Harsh Environments. Volume 2. 2nd edition. Edited by Pandolf AB, Burr RE. Washington DC: Office of the Surgeon General; 2001.
• [5]Thompson J: 3 Commando Brigade in the Falklands: No Picnic. Yorkshire: Pen and Sword Books; 1985.
• [6]Vaux N: March to the South Atlantic. London: Buchan & Enright; 1986.
• [7]Ungley CC, Blackwood W: Peripheral vasoneuropathy after chilling immersion foot and immersion hand. Lancet 1942, 2:447-451.
• [8]Blackwood W, Russell H: Experiments in the study of immersion foot. Edin Med J 1943, 50:385-398.
• [9]Francis TJR: Non freezing cold injury: a historical review. J Roy Nav Med Serv 1984, 70:134-139.
• [10]Francis TJR, Golden FSC: Non freezing cold injury: the pathogenesis. J Roy Nav Med Serv 1985, 71:3-8.
• [11]Thomas JR, EH Oakley EH: Nonfreezing cold injury. In Textbook of Military Medicine: Medical Aspects of Harsh Environments. Volume 1. Edited by Pandolf AB, Burr RE. Washington DC: Office of the Surgeon General; 2001:467-490.
• [12]Imray C, Grieve A, Dhillon S: Cold damage to the extremities: frostbite and non-freezing cold injuries. Postgrad Med J 2009, 85:481-488.
• [13]Travis S, Muggeridge T, Golden FSC: Toe temperatures during arctic training. Mil Med 1990, 155(4):162-166.
• [14]Schechter DC, Sarot IA: Historical accounts of injuries due to cold. Surgery 1968, 63(3):527-535.
• [15]Ungley CC, Channell GD, Richards RL: The immersion foot syndrome. Br J Surg 1945, 33:17-31.
• [16]Golden FSC, Eglin C, Inns R, Laight D, Martin L, Tipton M: Non-freezing cold injury: its nature and assessment. Report: University of Portsmouth, Institute of Biomedical and Biomolecular Sciences and UK (Gov); 2003.
• [17]Parsons SL, Leach IH, Charnley : A case of bilateral trench foot. Injury 1993, 24(10):680-681.
• [18]Marsh A: A short but distant war—the Falklands campaign. J Roy Soc Med 1983, 76(11):972-982.
• [19]McCraig HR, Gooderson CY: Ergonomic and physiological aspects of military operations in a cold wet climate. Ergonomics 1986, 29(7):849-857.
• [20]Eglin CM, Golden FSC, Tipton MJ: Cold sensitivity test for individuals with non-freezing cold injury: the effect of prior exercise. Extreme Physiol Med 2013, 2:16.
• [21]Riddel DI: Superficial frostbite: a clinical and experimental study. Department of Medicine, University of Dundee; 1983. [MD Thesis]
• [22]Passias TC, Menially GS, Mekjavic IB: Effects of hypoglycaemia on thermoregulatory responses. J Appl Physiol 1996, 80(3):1021-1032.
• [23]Haight JSJ, Keatinge WR: Failure of thermoregulation in cold during hypoglycaemic induced by exercise and ethanol. J Appl Physiol 1973, 229:87-97.