A narrative review on the effect of economic downturns on the nursing labour market: implications for policy and planning

Human Resources for Health

Raisa Deber²  Audrey Laporte²  Andrea Baumann¹  Mohamad Alameddine³ 

[1] Faculty of Health Sciences International Health, Michael G. DeGroote Centre for Learning, McMaster University, Hamilton, ON, L8S 4K1, Canada;Faculty of Medicine, Institute of Health Policy Management and Evaluation, University of Toronto, Health Sciences Building, 155 College Street, Suite 425, Toronto, ON, M5T 3M6, Canada;Faculty of Health Sciences, Department of Health Management and Policy, American University of Beirut, Riad El-Solh, Beirut, 1107 2020, Lebanon

关键词: Policy;    Demand;    Supply;    Recession;    Nurses;    Economic downturn;   

Others  :  822699
DOI  :  10.1186/1478-4491-10-23

 received in 2011-12-16, accepted in 2012-06-18,  发布年份 2012

【 摘 要 】

Economic downturns and recession lead to budget cuts and service reductions in the healthcare sector which often precipitate layoffs and hiring freezes. Nurses, being the largest professional group in healthcare, are strongly affected by cost reductions. Economic downturns destabilize the nursing labour market with potential negative outcomes, including serious shortages, extending beyond the recessionary period. The objectives of this manuscript are to provide an overview of the potential short- and long-run impact of economic downturns on the supply and demand of nurses, and present healthcare decision makers with a framework to enhance their ability to strategically manage their human resources through economic cycles.

A narrative review of the literature on the effects of economic downturns on the nursing labour market in developed countries was carried out with a special focus on studies offering a longitudinal examination of labour force trends. Analysis indicates that economic downturns limit the ability of public payers and institutions to finance their existing health workforce. As salaried healthcare workers, nurses are especially susceptible to institutional budget cuts. In the short run, economic downturns may temporarily reduce the demand for and increase the supply of nurses, thereby influencing nursing wages and turnover rates. These effects may destabilise the nursing labour market in the long run. After economic downturns, the market would quickly display the pre-recessionary trends and there may be serious demand–supply imbalances resulting in severe shortages. Potential long-term effects of recession on the nursing labour market may include a downsized active workforce, difficulty in retaining younger nurses, a decreased supply of nurses and workforce casualisation.

Lack of understanding of labour market dynamics and trends might mislead policy makers into making misinformed workforce downsizing decisions that are often difficult and expensive to reverse. In the aftermath of an economic downturn, the costs of attracting nurses back often outweigh the short term cost savings. Effective management should support the nursing workforce by creating attractive and stable work environments to retain nurses at a manageable cost.

【 授权许可】

   
2012 Alameddine et al.; licensee BioMed Central Ltd.

【 图 表 】

Figure 1.

【 参考文献 】

• [1]Houston M, Day M, de Lago M, Zarocostas J: Health services across Europe face cuts as debt crisis begins to bite. BMJ 2011, 343:d5266.
• [2]Buerhaus PI, Auerbach DI: The recession's effect on hospital registered nurse employment growth. Nurs Econ 2011, 29:163-167.
• [3]Sussman JB, Halasyamani LK, Davis MM: Hospitals during recession and recovery: vulnerable institutions and quality at risk. J Hosp Med 2010, 5:302-305.
• [4]Leamer E: What's a Recession, Anyway? National Bureau of Economic Research Working Paper Series 2008, 14221:1-36.
• [5]OECD calls for urgent action to boost ailing global economy: OECD calls for urgent action to boost ailing global economy. http://www.oecd.org/document/47/0,3746,en_21571361_44315115_49095919_1_1_1_1,00.html webcite
• [6]Duffield C, Kearin M, Johnston J, Leonard J: The impact of hospital structure and restructuring on the nursing workforce. Aust J Adv Nurs 2007, 24:42-46.
• [7]Lineweaver LA, Battle CE, Schilling RM, Nall CM: Six hospitals describe decentralization, cost containment, and downsizing. J Nurses Staff Dev 1999, 15:198-204.
• [8]Kalimo R, Taris TW, Schaufeli WB: The effects of past and anticipated future downsizing on survivor well-being: an equity perspective. J Occup Health Psychol 2003, 8:91-109.
• [9]Greenglass ER, Burke RJ: Hospital restructuring and burnout. J Health Hum Serv Adm 2002, 25:89-114.
• [10]Hertting A, Theorell T: Physiological changes associated with downsizing of personnel and reorganisation in the health care sector. Psychother Psychosom 2002, 71:117-122.
• [11]Maynard A: Medical workforce planning: some forecasting challenges. Aust Econ Rev 2006, 39:323-329.
• [12]Cooper RA, Getzen TE, Laud P: Economic expansion is a major determinant of physician supply and utilization. Health Serv Res 2003, 38:675-696.
• [13]Baumann AO, Blythe JM, Underwood JM: Surge capacity and casualization: Human resource issues in the post-SARS health system. Can J Public Health 2006, 97:230-232.
• [14]Baumeister R, Leary M: Writing narrative literature reviews. Rev Gen Psych 1997, 1:311-320.
• [15]Riessman C: Narrative analysis. Thousand Oaks, CA, London: Sage Publications; 1993.
• [16]Blythe J, Baumann A, Giovannetti P: Nurses' experiences of restructuring in three Ontario hospitals. J Nurs Scholarsh 2001, 33:61-68.
• [17]Baumann A, Blythe J: Restructuring, reconsidering, reconstructing: implications for health human resources. Int J Public Adm 2003, 26:1561.
• [18]Brewer S: Landing a job in a tough economy. Nursing 2010, 40(Suppl):18-19.
• [19]Hertting A, Nilsson K, Theorell T, Larsson US: Downsizing and reorganization: demands, challenges and ambiguity for registered nurses. J Adv Nurs 2004, 45:145-154.
• [20]Bortoluzzi G, Palese A: The Italian economic crisis and its impact on nursing services and education: hard and challenging times. J Nurs Manag 2010, 18:515-519.
• [21]Benjamin D, Gunderson M, Riddel W: Labour Market Economics. Toronto: McGraw-Hill Ryerson; 2002.
• [22]Zabalegui A, Cabrera E: Economic crisis and nursing in Spain. J Nurs Manag 2010, 18:505-508.
• [23]Notara V, Koupidis SA, Vaga E, Grammatikopoulos IA: Economic crisis and challenges for the Greek healthcare system: the emergent role of nursing management. J Nurs Manag 2010, 18:501-504.
• [24]Gallo WT, Teng HM, Falba TA, Kasl SV, Krumholz HM, Bradley EH: The impact of late career job loss on myocardial infarction and stroke: a 10 year follow up using the health and retirement survey. Occup Environ Med 2006, 63:683-687.
• [25]Strully KW: Job loss and health in the U.S. labor market. Demography 2009, 46:221-246.
• [26]Puig-Barrachina V, Malmusi D, Martenez JM, Benach J: Monitoring social determinants of health inequalities: the impact of unemployment among vulnerable groups. Int J Health Serv 2011, 41:459-482.
• [27]Jin RL, Shah CP, Svoboda TJ: The impact of unemployment on health: a review of the evidence. CMAJ 1995, 153:529-540.
• [28]Alameddine M, Laporte A, Baumann A, O'Brien-Pallas L, Croxford R, Mildon B, Wang S, Milburn B, Deber R: Where are nurses working? employment patterns by sub-sector in Ontario, Canada. Healthc Policy 2006, 1:65-86.
• [29]Heitlinger A: The paradoxical impact of health care restructuring in Canada on nursing as a profession. Int J Health Serv 2003, 33:37-54.
• [30]Aiken LH, Clarke SP, Sloane DM: Hospital restructuring: does it adversely affect care and outcomes? J Health Hum Serv Adm 2001, 23:416-442.
• [31]Aiken LH, Clarke SP, Silber JH, Sloane D: Hospital nurse staffing, education, and patient mortality. LDI Issue Brief 2003, 9:1-4.
• [32]Needleman J, Buerhaus P, Mattke S, Stewart M, Zelevinsky K: Nurse-staffing levels and the quality of care in hospitals. N Engl J Med 2002, 346:1715-1722.
• [33]Link CR, Settle RF: Wage incentives and married professional nurses: a case of backward-bending supply? Econ Inq 1981, 19:144-156.
• [34]Buerhaus P: The recession and the nursing shortage. OR Manager 2009, 25:5-6.
• [35]Hader R: The compensation tumble. Nurs Manage 2010, 41:26-31.
• [36]Yang BM, Prescott N, Bae EY: The impact of economic crisis on health-care consumption in Korea. Health Policy Plan 2001, 16:372-385.
• [37]Staines R: Recession forces nurses to seek financial rescue. Nurs Times 2009, 105:1.
• [38]Auerbach D, Buerhaus P, Staiger D: Registered nurse supply grows faster than projected amid surge in new entrants ages 23–26. Health Aff 2011, 30:2286-2292.
• [39]Buerhaus PI: The shape of the recovery: economic implications for the nursing workforce. Nurs Econ 2009, 27:338-340. 336.
• [40]Broome ME: At what cost? Stewardship of our most important resources. Nurs Outlook 2010, 58:1-2.
• [41]Carney M: Challenges in healthcare delivery in an economic downturn, in the Republic of Ireland. J Nurs Manag 2010, 18:509-514.
• [42]Cohen J, Stuenkel D, Nguyen Q: Providing a healthy work environment for nurses: the influence on retention. J Nurs Care Qual 2009, 24:308-315.
• [43]Christmas K: How work environment impacts retention. Nurs Econ 2008, 26:316-318.
• [44]International Centre for Human Resources in Nursing: An Ageing Nursing Workforce. 2007.
• [45]CanadianNurses Association. http://www.cna-aiic.ca/ webcite
• [46]Alameddine M, Baumann A, Laporte A, O'Brien-Pallas L, Levinton C, Onate K, Deber R: Career trajectories of nurses leaving the hospital sector in Ontario, Canada (1993–2004). J Adv Nurs 2009, 65:1044-1053.
• [47]Jones CB: The costs of nurse turnover, part 2: application of the Nursing Turnover Cost Calculation Methodology. J Nurs Adm 2005, 35:41-49.
• [48]Jones CB: Revisiting nurse turnover costs: adjusting for inflation. J Nurs Adm 2008, 38:11-18.
• [49]Alameddine M, Baumann A, Onate K, Deber R: Career transitions of inactive nurses: a registration database analysis (1993–2006). Int J Nurs Stud 2011, 48:184-192.
• [50]O'Brien-Pallas L, Duffield C, Alksnis C: Who will be there to nurse? Retention of nurses nearing retirement. J Nurs Adm 2004, 34:298-302.
• [51]Nursing Graduate Guarantee for New Ontario Graduate Nurses. http://www.healthforceontario.ca/Work/InsideOntario/OntarioNurses/NursingGradGuarantee.aspx webcite
• [52]Kane D: Job sharing: a retention strategy for nurses. Can J Nurs Leadersh 1999, 12:16-22.
• [53]Cameron S, Armstrong-Stassen M, Bergeron S, Out J: Recruitment and retention of nurses: challenges facing hospital and community employers. Nurs Leadersh (Tor Ont) 2004, 17:79-92.
• [54]Leurer MD, Donnelly G, Domm E: Nurse retention strategies: advice from experienced registered nurses. J Health Organ Manag 2007, 21:307-319.
• [55]Shields MA, Ward M: Improving nurse retention in the National Health Service in England: the impact of job satisfaction on intentions to quit. J Health Econ 2001, 20:677-701.
• [56]Hayes LJ, O'Brien-Pallas L, Duffield C, Shamian J, Buchan J, Hughes F, Laschinger HK, North N: Nurse turnover: A literature review - An update. Int J Nurs Stud 2012, 49:887-905.