Rationing is a reality in rural physiotherapy: a qualitative exploration of service level decision-making

BMC Health Services Research

Lorraine Sheppard¹  Sophie Lefmann¹  Anne Jones²  Robyn Adams² 

[1] Discipline of Physiotherapy, University of South Australia, Adelaide, Australia;Discipline of Physiotherapy, College of Healthcare Sciences, James Cook University, 1 James Cook Dr, Douglas QLD 4811, Townsville, Australia

关键词: Decision-making;    Rationing;    Prioritization;    Health Services;    Regional;    Rural;    Physiotherapy;   

Others  :  1147664
DOI  :  10.1186/s12913-015-0786-3

 received in 2014-04-21, accepted in 2015-03-11,  发布年份 2015

【 摘 要 】

Background

Deciding what health services are provided is a key consideration in delivering appropriate and accessible health care for rural and remote populations. Despite residents of rural communities experiencing poorer health outcomes and exhibiting higher health need, workforce shortages and maldistribution mean that rural communities do not have access to the range of services available in metropolitan centres. Where demand exceeds available resources, decisions about resource allocation are required.

Methods

A qualitative approach enabled the researchers to explore participant perspectives about decisions informing rural physiotherapy service provision. Stakeholder perspectives were obtained through surveys and in-depth interviews. A system theory-case study heuristic provided a framework for exploration across sites within the investigation area: a large area of one Australian state with a mix of rural, regional and remote communities.

Results

Thirty-nine surveys were received from participants in eleven communities. Nineteen in-depth interviews were conducted with physiotherapist and key decision-makers. Increasing demand, organisational priorities, fiscal austerity measures and workforce challenges were identified as factors influencing both decision-making and service provision. Rationing of physiotherapy services was common to all sites of this study. Rationing of services, more commonly expressed as service prioritisation, was more evident in responses of public sector physiotherapy participants compared to private physiotherapists. However, private physiotherapists in rural areas reported capacity limits, including expertise, space and affordability that constrained service provision.

Conclusions

The imbalance between increasing service demands and limited physiotherapy capacity meant making choices was inevitable. Decreased community access to local physiotherapy services and increased workforce stress, a key determinant of retention, are two results of such choices or decisions. Decreased access was particularly evident for adults and children requiring neurological rehabilitation and for people requiring post-acute physiotherapy. It should not be presumed that rural private physiotherapy providers will cover service gaps that may emerge from changes to public sector service provision. Clinician preference combines with capacity limits and the imperative of financial viability to negate such assumptions. This study provides insight into rural physiotherapy service provision not usually evident and can be used to inform health service planning and decision-making and education of current and future rural physiotherapists.

【 授权许可】

   
2015 Adams et al.; licensee BioMed Central.

【 图 表 】

Figure 1.

Figure 2.

Figure 3.

【 参考文献 】

• [1]Wilson NW, Couper ID, De Vries E, Reid S, Fish T, Marais BJ: A critical review of interventions to redress the inequitable distribution of healthcare professionals to rural and remote areas. Rural Remote Health 2009, 9(2):1060. PubMed English
• [2]Schindeler S, Moore M, Eckstein G, Turner R, Kaldor J, Cerny M, et al.: Rural health information project: Rural health classifications systems. SHP (EPI) 060127 NSW Rural Institute for Clinical Services and Teaching, Centre for Epidemiology and Research, Population Health Division. Department of Health, Sydney, NSW; 2006.
• [3]Australian Institute of Health and Welfare (AIHW). Remoteness classifications. Canberra. 2015 (cited 30 March 2015). Available from http://www.aihw.gov.au/rural-health-remoteness-classifications/.
• [4]Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS). Where do they live? Australian Social Trends April 2013 Canberra. 2013 [cited 2014 20 April]. http://www.abs.gov.au/AUSSTATS/abs@.nsf/Lookup/4102.0Main+Features30April+2013.
• [5]Australian Institute of Health and Welfare (AIHW): Allied health workforce 2012. National health workforce series no. 5. HWL 51. Australian Institute of Health and Welfare, Canberra; 2013.
• [6]Australian Institute of Health and Welfare (AIHW): Australia's Health. AIHW, Canberra; 2008.
• [7]Carey TA, Wakerman J, Humphreys JS, Buykx P, Lindeman M: What primary health care services should residents of rural and remote Australia be able to access? Systematic Rev BMC Health Serv Res 2013, 13(1):178.
• [8]Humphreys JS: Key considerations in delivering appropriate and accessible health care for rural and remote populations: discussant overview. Aust J Rural Health 2009, 17(1):34-8.
• [9]Wakerman J, Humphreys JS, Wells R, Kuipers P, Entwistle P, Jones J: Primary health care delivery models in rural and remote Australia–a systematic review. BMC Health Serv Res 2008, 8(1):276.
• [10]Martin D, Singer P: A strategy to improve priority setting in health care institutions. Health Care Anal 2003, 11(1):59-68.
• [11]Sibbald SL, Singer PA, Upshur R, Martin DK: Priority setting: what constitutes success? A conceptual framework for successful priority setting. BMC Health Services Research 2009, 9(43):1. Epub 2009 March 5
• [12]Arvidsson E, André M, Borgquist L, Carlsson P: Priority setting in primary health care-dilemmas and opportunities: a focus group study. BMC Fam Pract 2010, 11(1):71.
• [13]Barasa EW, Molyneux S, English M, Cleary S. Setting healthcare priorities in hospitals: a review of empirical studies. Health policy and planning. 2014;(3):1-11.
• [14]Putoto G, Pegoraro R: Resource allocation in health care. In Bioethics in the 21st century. Edited by Rudnick A. In Tech, Rijeka, Croatia; 2011.
• [15]Australian Physiotherapy Association (APA): The Factors affecting the supply of health services and medical professionals in rural areas: Submission to Senate Community Affairs Committee. APA, Melbourne; 2011.
• [16]Sheppard L: Work practices of rural and remote physiotherapists. Aust J Rural Health 2001, 9(2):84-90. PubMed English
• [17]Higgs J, Refshauge K, Ellis E: Portrait of the physiotherapy profession. J Interprof Care 2001, 15(1):79-89. PubMed English
• [18]Williams E, D'Amore W, McMeeken J: Physiotherapy in rural and regional Australia. Aust J Rural Health 2007, 15(6):380-6.
• [19]Struber J: Physiotherapy in Australia–where to now? The Internet Journal of Allied Health Sciences and Practice 2003, 1(2):2.
• [20]Lindsay R, Hanson L, Taylor M, McBurney H: Workplace stressors experienced by physiotherapists working in regional public hospitals. Aust J Rural Health 2008, 16(4):194-200. PubMed English
• [21]Edwards I, Jones M, Carr J, Braunack-Mayer A, Jensen GM: Clinical reasoning strategies in physical therapy. Phys Ther 2004, 84(4):312-30. discussion 31–5. PubMed English
• [22]Edwards I, Braunack-Mayer A, Jones M: Ethical reasoning as a clinical-reasoning strategy in physiotherapy. Physiotherapy 2005, 91(4):229-36.
• [23]Edwards I, Richardson B: Clinical reasoning and population health: decision making for an emerging paradigm of health care. Physiother 2008, 24(3):183-93. PubMed
• [24]Finch E, Geddes EL, Larin H: Ethically-based clinical decision-making in physical therapy: process and issues. Physiother 2005, 21(3):147-62. PubMed English
• [25]Grimmer-Somers K: Incorporating research evidence into clinical practice decisions. Physiother Res Int 2007, 12(2):55-8. PubMed English
• [26]Smith M, Higgs J, Ellis E: Physiotherapy decision making in acute cardiorespiratory care is influenced by factors related to the physiotherapist and the nature and context of the decision: a qualitative study. Australian J Physiotherapy 2007, 53(4):261.
• [27]Smith M, Higgs J, Ellis E: Characteristics and processes of physiotherapy clinical decision making: a study of acute care cardiorespiratory physiotherapy. Physiother Res Int 2008, 13(4):209-22. PubMed English
• [28]Smart K, Doody C, Smart K, Doody C: The clinical reasoning of pain by experienced musculoskeletal physiotherapists. Man Ther 2007, 12(1):40-9. PubMed English
• [29]Brown AM, Pirotta M: Determining priority of access to physiotherapy at Victorian community health services. Aust Health Rev 2011, 35(2):178-84. PubMed Language: English. Entry Date: 20110812. Revision Date: 20120127. Publication Type: journal article
• [30]Miller-Mifflin TM, Bzdell M: Development of a physiotherapy prioritization tool in the Baffin region of Nunavut: a remote, under-serviced area in the Canadian arctic. Rural Remote Health 2010, 10(2):1466. PubMed Language: English. Entry Date: 20100910. Revision Date: 20100910. Publication Type: journal article
• [31]Christie HJ: Feature articles-physiotherapy caseload guidelines. Physiother Can 1999, 51(3):186-90.
• [32]Simmons NC, Kuys SS: Trial of an allied health workload allocation model. Aust Health Rev 2011, 35(2):168-75.
• [33]Schoo AM, Boyce RA, Ridoutt L, Santos T: Workload capacity measures for estimating allied health staffing requirements. Aust Health Rev 2008, 32(3):548-58.
• [34]Scott A, Cheng MT: Workload Measures for Allied Health Professionals. Final Report. National Health Workforce Planning and Research Collaboration, Adelaide; 2010.
• [35]Kapiriri L, Norheim OF, Martin DK: Fairness and accountability for reasonableness. Do the views of priority setting decision makers differ across health systems and levels of decision making? Soc Sci Med 2009, 68(4):766-73.
• [36]Kapiriri L, Norheim OF, Martin DK: Priority setting at the micro-, meso-and macro-levels in Canada. Norway and Uganda. Health Policy 2007, 82(1):78-94.
• [37]Mechanic D: Muddling through elegantly: finding the proper balance in rationing. Health Aff 1997, 16(5):83-92.
• [38]Ham C, Coulter A: Explicit and implicit rationing: taking responsibility and avoiding blame for health care choices. J Health Serv Res Policy 2001, 6:164.
• [39]Smith M, Higgs J, Ellis E: Factors influencing clinical decision making. In Clinical reasoning in the health professions. Edited by Higgs J. Elsevier Health Sciences, Amsterdam; 2008:89-100.
• [40]National Health and Hospitals Reform Commission,(NHHRC): Beyond the blame game. Accountability and performance benchmarks for the next Australian health care agreements. National Health and Hospitals Reform Commission, Canberra; 2008.
• [41]Liamputtong P, Ezzy D: Qualitative research methods. Second edition ed. Oxford University Press, Melbourne; 2005.
• [42]Patton MQ: Qualitative research and evaluation methods. 3rd edition. Sage Publications, Thousand Oaks; 2002.
• [43]National Rural Health Alliance (NRHA): Under pressure and undervalued: allied health professionals in rural and remote Australia. National Rural Health Alliance, Canberra; 2004.
• [44]Anaf S, Drummond C, Sheppard L: Combining case study and systems theory as a heuristic model. Qual Health Res 2007, 17(10):1309-15.
• [45]Grbich C: Qualitative research in health: an introduction. Allen & Unwin, St Leonards, N.S.W; 1999.
• [46]Bailey DM: Research for the health professional: a practical guide. Second edition ed. F.A. Davis Company, Philadelphia; 1997.
• [47]Baxter P, Jack S: Qualitative case study methodology: study design and implementation for novice researchers. Qual Rep 2008, 13(4):544-59.
• [48]Higgs J, Refshauge K, Ellis E: Profiles of the professions. Portrait Physiotherapy Profession J Interprof Care 2001, 15(1):79-89.
• [49]Fitzgerald K, Hornsby D, Hudson L: A study of allied health professionals in rural and remote Australia. Services for Australian Rural and Remote Allied Health SARRAH, Canberra; 2001.
• [50]Campbell N, McAllister L, Eley D: The influence of motivation in recruitment and retention of rural and remote allied health professionals: a literature review. Rural Remote Health 2012, 12:1900. Epub 2012
• [51]Miles E, Adams R, Anaf S, Sheppard L: Factors identified by physiotherapists that influence retention of regional clinicians: A qualitative investigation. 2010 Jan. Internet J Allied Health Sci Practice 2010, 8(1):1.
• [52]Roots RK, Li LC: Recruitment and retention of occupational therapists and physiotherapists in rural regions: a meta-synthesis. BMC Health Serv Res 2013, 13(1):59.