A qualitative exploration of young adult smokers’ responses to novel tobacco warnings

BMC Public Health

Philip Gendall¹  Anna Hoek-Sims¹  Janet Hoek¹ 

[1] University of Otago, P O Box 56, Dunedin, New Zealand

关键词: Temporal construal;    Warning messages;    Young adults;    Smoking;   

Others  :  1162073
DOI  :  10.1186/1471-2458-13-609

 received in 2013-02-01, accepted in 2013-06-18,  发布年份 2013

【 摘 要 】

Background

Despite reduced smoking among adolescents, smoking prevalence peaks among young adults aged 18–30, many of whom believe themselves exempt from the health risks of smoking shown in warning labels. We explored how young adult smokers perceived warnings featuring proximal risks, and whether these encouraged cessation more effectively than traditional health messages.

Methods

We conducted in-depth interviews with 17 young adult smokers and explored their perceptions of current warnings as well as novel warnings representing short-term health consequences; immediate social risks, and tobacco’s toxicity (denormalizing tobacco as an everyday product). We used a thematic analysis approach to explore how participants rationalized existing warnings and interpreted the novel messages.

Results

Participants considered the immediate social and physiological benefits they gained from smoking outweighed the distal risks shown in health warnings, which they regarded as improbable and irrelevant. Of the novel warnings, those presenting immediate social risks altered the balance of gains and losses young adults associated with smoking; however, those presenting short-term health risks or depicting tobacco as a toxin were less effective.

Conclusions

Participants regarded warnings featuring proximal social risks as more salient and they were less likely to rationalise these as irrelevant. Social risk messages merit further investigation to examine their potential as a complement to traditional health warnings.

【 授权许可】

   
2013 Hoek et al.; licensee BioMed Central Ltd.

【 图 表 】

Figure 1.

【 参考文献 】

• [1]Hammond D: Smoking behaviour among young adults: beyond youth prevention. Tob Control 2005, 14:181-185.
• [2]Wakefield MA, Loken B, Hornik RC: Use of mass media campaigns to change health behaviour. Lancet 2010, 376(9748):1261-1271.
• [3]Hammond D: Health warning messages on tobacco products: a review. Tob Control 2011, 20(5):327-337.
• [4]Hassan L, Shiu E, Walsh G, Hastings G: HELP – for a life without tobacco: a case study on demarketing across two levels. Mark Int Plan 2009, 27(4):486-502.
• [5]Hoek J, Newcombe R, Walker S: Promoting youth smokefree behaviour: An evaluation of a social norms campaign. AMJ 2011, 19(1):58-64.
• [6]Netemeyer R, Andrews J, Burton S: Effects of antismoking advertising–based beliefs on adult smokers’ consideration of quitting. Am J Public Health 2005, 95:1062-1066.
• [7]Wakefield M, Flay B, Nichter M, Giovino G: Effects of anti-smoking advertising on youth smoking: a review. J Health Comm 2003, 8(3):229-247.
• [8]Chaloupka FJ, Cummings KM, Morley CP, Horan JK: Tax, price and cigarette smoking: evidence from the tobacco documents and implications for tobacco company marketing strategies. Tob Control 2002, 11(suppl 1):62-72.
• [9]Wakefield MA, Spittal MJ, Yong H-H, Durkin SJ, Borland R: Effects of mass media campaign exposure intensity and durability on quit attempts in a population-based cohort study. Health Educ Res 2011, 26(6):988-997.
• [10]Wilson N, Sertsou G, Edwards R, Thomson G, Grigg M, Li J: A new national smokefree law increased calls to a national quitline. BMC Public Health 2007, 7(147):75.
• [11]Freeman B, Chapman S, Rimmer M: The case for the plain packaging of tobacco products. Addiction 2008, 103:580-590.
• [12]Gendall P, Hoek J, Edwards R, Gifford H, Pirikahu G, Pene G, Thomson G, McCool J: Young Adults’ interpretations of tobacco brands: implications for tobacco control. Nicotine Tobacco Res 2011, 13(10):911-918.
• [13]Gendall P, Hoek J, Edwards R, McCool J: A cross-sectional analysis of How young adults perceive tobacco brands: implications for FCTC signatories. BMC Public Health 2012, 12:796. BioMed Central Full Text
• [14]Hoek J, Gendall P, Gifford H, Pirikahu G, McCool J, Pene G, Edwards R, Thomson G: Tobacco branding, plain packaging, pictorial warnings, and symbolic consumption. Qual Health Res 2012, 22(5):630-639.
• [15]Belk R: Posessions and the extended self. J Consumer Res 1988, 15:139-168.
• [16]Cook BL, Wayne GF, Keithly L, Connolly G: One size does not fit all: how the tobacco industry has altered cigarette design to target consumer groups with specific psychological and psychosocial needs. Addiction 2003, 98(11):1547-1561.
• [17]Elliott R: Exploring the symbolic meaning of brands. British J Manage 1994, 5(S1):S13-S19.
• [18]Elliott R: Elusive consumption. Edited by Ekstrom K, Brembeck H. Oxford, England: Berg; 2004:129-143.
• [19]Hogg M, Michell P: Identity, self and consumption: a conceptual framework. J Mark Manage 1996, 12(7):629-644.
• [20]Scheffels J, Lund KE: Occasional smoking in adolescence: constructing an identity of control. J Youth Studies 2005, 8(4):445-460.
• [21]Carter S: The Australian cigarette brand as product, person, and symbol. Tob Control 2003, 12:79-86.
• [22]Hogg M, Terry D, White K: A tale of Two theories: a critical comparison of identity theory with social identity theory. Soc Psychol Quart 1995, 58(4):255-269.
• [23]Lennon A, Gallois C, Owen N, McDermott L: Young women as smokers and nonsmokers: a qualitative social identity approach. Qual Health Res 2005, 15(10):1345-1359.
• [24]Hammond D, Dockrell M, Arnott D, Lee A, McNeill A: Cigarette pack design and perceptions of risk among UK adults and youth. Eu J Pub Health 2009, 19(6):631-637.
• [25]Hammond D, Parkinson C: The impact of cigarette package design on perceptions of risk. J Pub Health 2009, 31(3):345-353.
• [26]Chapman S, Carter S: Avoid health warnings on all tobacco products for just as long as we can”: A history of Australian tobacco industry efforts to avoid, delay and dilute health warnings on cigarettes . Tob Control 2003, 12(Suppl. III):iii3-iii22.
• [27]Borland R, Wilson N, Fong G, Hammond D, Cummings K, Yong H, Hosking W, Hastings G, Thrasher J, NcNeill A: Impact of graphic and text warnings on cigarette packs: findings from four countries over five years. Tob Control 2009, 18(5):358-364.
• [28]Borland R, Yong H, Wilson N, Fong G, Hammond D, Cummings K, Hosking W, McNeill A: How reactions to cigarette packet health warnings influence quitting: findings from the ITC Four-Country survey. Addiction 2009, 104(4):669-675.
• [29]Brown A, Moodie C: Adolescents’ Perceptions of tobacco control measures in the united kingdom. Health Promo Pract 2012, 3(January):41-47.
• [30]O’Hegarty M, Pederson LL, Nelson DE, Mowery P, Gable JM, Wortley P: Reactions of young adult smokers to warning labels on cigarette packages. Am J Prevent Med 2006, 30(6):467-473.
• [31]Siegel M: Antismoking advertising: figuring out what works. J Health Comm 2002, 7(2):157-162.
• [32]Ministry of Health: The Health of New Zealand Adults 2011/12: Key findings of the New Zealand Health Survey. Wellington, New Zealand: Ministry of Health; 2012. Available at: http://www.health.govt.nz/publication/health-new-zealand-adults-2011-12 webcite
• [33]Biener L, Ming J, Gilpin E, Albers A: The impact of emotional tone, message, and broadcast parameters in youth anti-smoking advertisements. J Health Comm 2002, 9(3):259-274.
• [34]Ling PM, Glantz SA: Why and How the tobacco industry sells cigarettes to young adults: evidence from industry documents. Am J Public Health 2002, 92(6):908-916.
• [35]Song AV, Glantz SA: Pushing secondhand smoke and the tobacco industry outside the social norm to reduce adolescent smoking. J Adolescent Health 2008, 43(4):315-317.
• [36]Chapman S, Freeman B: Markers of the denormalisation of smoking and the tobacco industry. Tob Control 2008, 17(1):25-31.
• [37]Dunlop SM: Talking “truth”: predictors and consequences of conversations about a youth antismoking campaign for smokers and nonsmokers. J Health Comm 2011, 16(7):708-725.
• [38]Kahneman D, Tversky A: Prospect theory: an analysis of decision under risk. Econometrica 1979, 47(2):263-291.
• [39]Toll BA, Salovey P, O’Malley SS, Mazure CM, Latimer A, McKee SA: Message framing for smoking cessation: the interaction of risk perceptions and gender. Nicotine Tobacco Res 2008, 10(1):195-200.
• [40]Hall PA, Fong GT: Temporal self-regulation theory: a model for individual health behavior. Health Psychol Rev 2007, 1(1):6-52.
• [41]Trope Y, Liberman N: Temporal construal. Psychol Rev 2003, 110(3):403-421.
• [42]Fujita K, Trope Y, Liberman N, Levin-Sagi M: Construal levels and self-control. J Personal Soc Pyschol 2006, 90(3):351-367.
• [43]Thaler RH: Some empirical evidence on time inconsistency. Rev Econ Studies 1981, 23:165-180.
• [44]Doll R, Peto R, Boreham J, Sutherland I: Mortality in relation to smoking: 50 years’ observations on male British doctors. British Med J 2004, 328:1-9.
• [45]Sutfin EL, Szykman LR, Moore MC: Adolescents’ responses to anti-tobacco advertising: exploring the role of adolescents’ smoking status and advertisement theme. J Health Comm 2008, 13(5):480-500.
• [46]Oakes W, Chapman S, Borland R, Balmford J, Trotter L: “Bulletproof skeptics in life’s jungle”: which self-exempting beliefs about smoking most predict lack of progression towards quitting? Prevent Med 2004, 39(4):776-782.
• [47]Kleinjan M, van den Eijnden RJ, Engels RC: Adolescents’ rationalizations to continue smoking: The role of disengagement beliefs and nicotine dependence in smoking cessation. Addict Behav 2009, 34(5):440-445.
• [48]Pechmann C, Reibling E: Antismoking advertisements for youths: an independent evaluation of health, counter-industry, and industry approaches. Am J Public Health 2006, 96(5):906-913.
• [49]Peracchio LA, Luna D: The development of an advertising campaign to discourage smoking initiation among children and youth. J Advert 1998, XXVII(3):49-56.
• [50]Biener L, Ming J: The impact of emotional tone, message, and broadcast parameters in youth anti-smoking advertisements. J Health Comm 2004, 9(3):259-274.
• [51]Terry-Mcelrath Y, Wakefield M, Ruel E, George IB, Emery S, Szczypka G, Clegg-Smith K, Flay B: The effect of antismoking advertisement executional characteristics on youth comprehension, appraisal, recall, and engagement. J Health Comm 2005, 10(2):127-143.
• [52]Maubach N, Hoek J, Edwards R, Gifford H, Erick S: The times are changing”: New Zealand smokers’ perceptions of the tobacco endgame. Tob Control 2012. Available online 12 June
• [53]Malone RE: Imagining things otherwise: new endgame ideas for tobacco control. Tob Control 2010, 19(5):349-350.
• [54]Kvale S: Interviews: an introduction to qualitative research interviewing. Thousand Oaks: Sage Publications; 1996.
• [55]Hoek J, Maubach N, Gendall P, Edwards R, Stevenson R: Social Smokers’ conflicted identities. Tob Control 2013, 22(4):261-265.
• [56]Braun V, Clarke V: Using thematic analysis in psychology. Qual Res Psychol 2006, 3:77-101.
• [57]Whittemore R, Chase SK, Mandle CL: Validity in qualitative research. Qual Health Res 2001, 11(4):522-537.
• [58]Schane RE, Glantz SA, Ling PM: Social smoking: implications for public health, clinical practice, and intervention research. Am J Prevent Med 2009, 37(2):124-131.
• [59]Goldman LK, Glantz SA: Evaluation of antismoking advertising campaigns. JAMA 1998, 279(10):772-777.
• [60]Hastings G, MacFadyen L: The limitations of fear messages. Tob Control 2002, 11:73-75.
• [61]Thompson LE, Barnett JR, Pearce JR: Scared straight? Fear-appeal anti-smoking campaigns, risk, self-efficacy and addiction. Health Risk Soc 2009, 11(2):181-196.
• [62]Morales A, Wu E, Fitzsimons G: How disgust enhances the effectiveness of fear appeals. J Market Res 2011, 1:35.
• [63]Leshner G, Bolls P, Thomas E: Scare’ Em or disgust ‘Em: the effects of graphic health promotion messages. Health Comm 2009, 24(5):447-458.
• [64]Leshner G, Bolls P, Wise K: Motivated processing of fear appeal and disgust images in televised anti-tobacco ads. J Media Psychol Theories Methods Appl 2011, 23(2):77-89.
• [65]McDermott L, Dobson A, Owen N: Occasional tobacco use among young adult women: a longitudinal analysis of smoking transitions. Tob Control 2007, 16(August):248-254.
• [66]Stewart-Knox B, Sittlington J, Rugka°sa J, Harrisson S, Treacy M, Santos-Abaunza P: Smoking and peer groups: Results from a longitudinal qualitative study of young people in Northern Ireland. British J Soc Psychol 2005, 44:397-414.
• [67]Hammond D, Fong GT, McDonald PW, Brown KS, Cameron R: Graphic Canadian cigarette warning labels and adverse outcomes: evidence from Canadian smokers. Am J Public Health 2004, 94(8):1442-1445.