The subjectively perceived quality of postgraduate medical training in integrative medicine within the public healthcare systems of Germany and Switzerland: the example of anthroposophic hospitals

BMC Complementary and Alternative Medicine

Pascale Orlow¹  Johannes Weinzirl²  Bettina Berger²  Sabine Eberhard²  Peter Heusser² 

[1] Institute for Environmental Decisions (IED) Consumer Behavior, Swiss Federal Institute of Technology (ETH), Zürich, Switzerland;Gerhard Kienle Chair for Theory of Medicine, Integrative and Anthroposophic Medicine, Institute of Integrative Medicine, Witten/Herdecke University, Gerhard-Kienle-Weg 4, D-58313 Herdecke, Germany

关键词: Integrative medicine;    Anthroposophic medicine;    Problems;    Quality;    Evaluation;    Residency training;    Postgraduate medical training;   

Others  :  830073
DOI  :  10.1186/1472-6882-14-191

 received in 2013-12-11, accepted in 2014-06-04,  发布年份 2014

【 摘 要 】

Background

Integrative medicine (IM) integrates evidence-based Complementary and Alternative Medicine (CAM) with conventional medicine (CON). Medical schools offer basic CAM electives but in postgraduate medical training (PGMT) little has been done for the integration of CAM. An exception to this is anthroposophic medicine (AM), a western form of CAM based on CON, offering an individualized holistic IM approach. AM hospitals are part of the public healthcare systems in Germany and Switzerland and train AM in PGMT. We performed the first quality evaluation of the subjectively perceived quality of this PGMT.

Methods

An anonymous full survey of all 214 trainers (TR) and 240 trainees (TE) in all 15 AM hospitals in Germany and Switzerland, using the ETHZ questionnaire for annual national PGMT assessments in Switzerland (CH) and Germany (D), complemented by a module for AM. Data analysis included Cronbach’s alpha to assess internal consistency questionnaire scales, 2-tailed Pearson correlation of specific quality dimensions of PGMT and department size, 2-tailed Wilcoxon Matched-Pair test for dependent variables and 2-tailed Mann–Whitney U-test for independent variables to calculate group differences. The level of significance was set at p < 0.05.

Results

Return rates were: D: TE 89/215 (41.39%), TR 78/184 (42.39%); CH: TE 19/25 (76%), TR 22/30 (73.33%). Cronbach’s alpha values for TE scales were >0.8 or >0.9, and >0.7 to >0.5 for TR scales. Swiss hospitals surpassed German ones significantly in Global Satisfaction with AM (TR and TE); Clinical Competency training in CON (TE) and AM (TE, TR), Error Management, Culture of Decision Making, Evidence-based Medicine, and Clinical Competency in internal medicine CON and AM (TE). When the comparison was restricted to departments of comparable size, differences remained significant for Clinical Competencies in AM (TE, TR), and Culture of Decision Making (TE). CON received better grades than AM in Global Satisfaction and Clinical Competency. Quality of PGMT depended on department size, working conditions and structural training features.

Conclusion

The lower quality of PGMT in German hospitals can be attributed to larger departments, more difficult working conditions, and less favorable structural features for PGMT in AM, possibly also in relation to increased financial pressure.

【 授权许可】

   
2014 Heusser et al.; licensee BioMed Central Ltd.

【 图 表 】

Figure 1.

【 参考文献 】

• [1]Frass M, Strassl RP, Friehs H, Müllner M, Kundi M, Kaye AD: Use and acceptance of complementary and alternative medicine among the general population and medical personnel: a systematic review. Ochsner J 2012, 12(1):45-56.
• [2]Institut für Demoskopie Allensbach: [Natural Remedies 2010. Results of a Representative Population Survey]. Naturheilmittel 2010. Ergebnisse einer bevölkerungsrepräsentativen Befragung. [Internet]. [accessed July 25, 2013]. http://www.ifd-allensbach.de/uploads/tx_studies/7528_Naturheilmittel_2010.pdf webcite
• [3]Leuenberger P, Longchamp C: [What Does the Population Expect from Medicine? Results of a Survey of the GfS-Research Institute, Politics and State, Bern, Commissioned by the Swiss Academy of Medical Sciences] Was erwartet die Bevölkerung von der Medizin? Ergebnisse einer Umfrage des GfS-Forschungsinstitutes, Politik und Staat, Bern, im Auftrag der SAMW. In Zukunft der Medizin Schweiz. Edited by Stauffacher W, Bircher J. Basel: Schweizerischer Ärzteverlag; 2002.
• [4]Swiss Condeferation: Bundesverfassung der Schweizerischen Eidgenossenschaft [Federal Constitution of Switzerland], Art. 118a, Status of March 3, 2013, Page 3 [Internet]. [accessed June 10, 2014]. http://www.admin.ch/opc/de/classified-compilation/19995395/201303030000/101.pdf webcite
• [5]Dachverband Komplementärmedizin (Dakomed) [Internet]. [accessed July 25, 2013]. http://www.dakomed.ch/schwerpunkte/ webcite
• [6]Schär A, Messerli-Rohrbach V, Schubarth P: [Conventional or complementary medicine: what criteria for choosing do patients use?] Schulmedizin oder Komplementärmedizin. Nach welchen Kriterien entscheiden sich die Patientinnen und Patienten? Schweiz Med Wochenschr Suppl 1994, 62:18-27.
• [7]Bishop FL, Yardley L, Lewith GT: A systematic review of beliefs involved in the use of complementary and alternative medicine. J Health Psychol 2007, 12(6):851-867.
• [8]Micke O, Bruns F, Glatzel M, Schönekaes K, Micke P, Mücke R, Büntzel J: Predictive factors for the use of complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) in radiation oncology. Eur J Integr Med 2009, 1(11):19-25.
• [9]Marian F, Joost K, Saini KD, von Ammon K, Thurneysen A, Busato A: Patient satisfaction and side effects in primary care: an observational study comparing homeopathy and conventional medicine. BMC Complement Altern Med 2008, 8:52. BioMed Central Full Text
• [10]Esch BM, Marian F, Busato A, Heusser P: Patient satisfaction with primary care: an observational study comparing anthroposophic and conventional care. Health Qual Life Outcomes 2008, 6(1):74. BioMed Central Full Text
• [11]Jenny S, Simon M, Meier B: [Attitudes of the Swiss population towards complementary medicine]. Haltung der Schweizer Bevölkerung gegenüber der Komplementärmedizin. Zschr Ganzheitsmed 2002, 14:340-347.
• [12]Kanton Zürich. Gesundheitsdepartement: [Satisfaction of the Population With Healthcare in the Canton of Zurich] Zufriedenheit der Bevölkerung mit der Gesundheitsversorgung im Kanton Zürich. [Internet]. [accessed August 2, 202]. http://www.zh.ch/gd/aktuell/Medienmitteilungen webcite
• [13]Nicolao M, Täuber MG, Marian F, Heusser P: Complementary medicine courses in Swiss medical schools: actual status and students’ experience. Swiss Med Wkly 2010, 140(3–4):44-51.
• [14]Brinkhaus B, Witt CM, Jena S, Bockelbrink A, Ortiz M, Willich SN: Integration of complementary and alternative medicine into medical schools in Austria, Germany and Switzerland – Results of a cross-sectional study. Wien Med Wochenschr 2010, 161(1–2):32-43.
• [15]Lehmann B, Krémer B, Werwick K, Herrmann M: Homeopathy as elective in undergraduate medical education--an opportunity for teaching professional core skills. GMS Z Für Med Ausbild 2014, 31(1):Doc7.
• [16]Scheffer C, Tauschel D, Neumann M, Lutz G, Valk-Draad M, Edelhäuser F: Active student participation may enhance patient centeredness: patients’ assessments of the clinical education ward for integrative medicine. Evid Based Complement Alternat Med 2013, 2013:743-832.
• [17]Tognetti Bordogna M, Gentiluomo A, Roberti Di Sarsina P: Post-graduate education in traditional and Non-conventional medicine: Italy poised between national guidelines and regional variants. Altern Integr Med 2013, 2:143.
• [18]Lebensohn P, Kligler B, Dodds S, Schneider C, Sroka S, Benn R, Cook P, Guerrera M, Low Dog T, Sierpina V, Teets R, Waxman D, Woytowicz J, Weil A, Maizes V: Integrative medicine in residency education: developing competency through online curriculum training. J Grad Med Educ 2012, 4(1):76-82.
• [19]Widmer M, Dönges A, Wapf V, Busato A, Herren S: The supply of complementary and alternative medicine in Swiss hospitals. Forsch Komplementärmedizin 2006, 13(6):356-361.
• [20]Rehakliniken (Naturheilkunde) [Internet]. [accessed Juli, 25, 2013]. http://www.rehakliniken.de/index.php webcite
• [21]Heusser P, Berger Braun S, Ziegler R, Bertschy M, Helwig S, van Wegberg B, Cerny T: Palliative in-patient cancer treatment in an anthroposophic hospital: I. Treatment patterns and compliance with anthroposophic medicine. Forsch Komplementärmedizin 2006, 13(2):94-100.
• [22]Steiner R, Wegman I: Extending Practical Medicine: Fundamental Principles Based on the Science of the Spirit. 2nd edition. London: Rudolf Steiner Press; 1996:148.
• [23]Girke M: [Internal Medicine. Basis and Therapeutic Concepts of Anthroposophic Medicine] Innere Medizin: Grundlagen und therapeutische Konzepte der Anthroposophischen Medizin. 2nd edition. Berlin: Salumed Verlag; 2012.
• [24]Schweizerische Ärztevereinigung FMH: [Postgraduate Medical Training in Complementary Medicine: Physician for Anthroposophically Extended Medicine] Weiterbildungsangebote zur Komplementärmedizin: Arzt für Anthroposophisch Erweiterte Medizin (VAOAS) [Internet]. [accessed Juli 25, 2013]. http://www.fmh.ch/bildung-siwf/weiterbildung_allgemein/komplementaermedizin.html webcite
• [25]Schweizerische Ärztevereinigung FMH: [Departments for Postgraduate Medical Training] Weiterbildungsstätten für Ärzte und Ärztinnen (Arlesheim: Ita Wegman Klinik, Lukas Klinik; Richterswil: Paracelsus-Spital) [Internet]. [accessed Juli 25, 2013]. http://www.fmh.ch/bildung-siwf/weiterbildung_allgemein/weiterbildungsstaetten.html webcite
• [26]Bundesärztekammer. [Postgraduate Medical Training in Germany] http://www.bundesaerztekammer.de/page.asp?his=0.8.5585; webcite [Internet]. [accessed Juli 25, 2013]; see: Landesärztekammern > Adressen > Weiterbildung > Weiterbildungsstätten
• [27]Ethics Commission Federal Institute of Technology. Zürich [Internet] [accessed June 10, 2014] http://www.vpf.ethz.ch/about/commissions/EK
• [28]Siegrist M, Orlow P, Giger M: [Questionnaire: “Evaluation of the Situation of Postgraduat Medical Traninig”] Fragebogeninstrument: “Evaluation der Weiterbildungssituation”. Zürich: Swiss Federal Institute of Technology; 2003–2010.
• [29]Orlow P: [Questionnaire: “ Module for Complementary Medicine”] Fragebogeninstrument: “Modul zur Komplementärmedizin”. Zürich: Swiss Federal Institute of Technology; 2010.
• [30]Eberhard S, Heusser P, Orlow P, Siegrist M: [Questionnaire: “Additional questions part for anthroposophic medicine”] Fragebogeninstrument: “Zusatzfragen anthroposophisch-medizinischer Teil”. Zürich: Witten/Herdecke University, Herdecke, Germany, and Swiss Federal Institute of Technology; 2009.
• [31]Heusser P, Eberhard S, Weinzirl J, Orlow P, Berger B: Problems of Integrative Postgraduate Medical Training of Physicians in Anthroposophic Hospitals of Germany and Switzerland. in review for publication
• [32]Anonymous: [VDAÄ Demands Abolition of DRG-System] VDÄÄ Fordert Abschaffung des DRG-Systems [Internet]. [accessed November 28, 2012]. http://www.aerzteblatt.de/nachrichten/52575/vdaeae-fordert-Abschaffung-des-DRG-Systems webcite
• [33]Simon M: [The German DRG-System. Fundamental Construction Mistakes]. Das deutsche DRG-System: Grundsätzliche Konstruktionsfehler. Dtsch Ärztebl [Internet] 2013., 110(39) [accessed November 11, 2013] http://www.aerzteblatt.de/archiv/146774/Das-deutsche-DRG-System-Grundsaetzliche-Konstruktionsfehler webcite
• [34]Eberhard S, Weinzirl J, Orlow P, Berger B, Heusser P: Recommendations for Problem Solving in Integrative Postgraduate Medical Training in Anthroposophic Hospitals. in review for publication