Understanding the role of welfare state characteristics for health and inequalities – an analytical review

BMC Public Health

Olle Lundberg¹  Monica Åberg Yngwe²  Kersti Bergqvist² 

[1] Department of Health Sciences, Mid Sweden University, Östersund, Sweden;Centre for Health Equity Studies, Stockholm University/Karolinska Institutet, Stockholm, Sweden

关键词: Welfare institutions;    Social expenditure;    Welfare regime;    Health;    Health inequalities;   

Others  :  1161390
DOI  :  10.1186/1471-2458-13-1234

 received in 2013-06-25, accepted in 2013-12-02,  发布年份 2013

【 摘 要 】

Background

The past decade has witnessed a growing body of research on welfare state characteristics and health inequalities but the picture is, despite this, inconsistent. We aim to review this research by focusing on theoretical and methodological differences between studies that at least in part may lead to these mixed findings.

Methods

Three reviews and relevant bibliographies were manually explored in order to find studies for the review. Related articles were searched for in PubMed, Web of Science and Google Scholar. Database searches were done in PubMed and Web of Science. The search period was restricted to 2005-01-01 to 2013-02-28. Fifty-four studies met the inclusion criteria.

Results

Three main approaches to comparative welfare state research are identified; the Regime approach, the Institutional approach, and the Expenditure approach. The Regime approach is the most common and regardless of the empirical regime theory employed and the amendments made to these, results are diverse and contradictory. When stratifying studies according to other features, not much added clarity is achieved. The Institutional approach shows more consistent results; generous policies and benefits seem to be associated with health in a positive way for all people in a population, not only those who are directly affected or targeted. The Expenditure approach finds that social and health spending is associated with increased levels of health and smaller health inequalities in one way or another but the studies are few in numbers making it somewhat difficult to get coherent results.

Conclusions

Based on earlier reviews and our results we suggest that future research should focus less on welfare regimes and health inequalities and more on a multitude of different types of studies, including larger analyses of social spending and social rights in various policy areas and how these are linked to health in different social strata. But, we also need more detailed evaluation of specific programmes or interventions, as well as more qualitative analyses of the experiences of different types of policies among the people and families that need to draw on the collective resources.

【 授权许可】

   
2013 Bergqvist et al.; licensee BioMed Central Ltd.

【 图 表 】

Figure 1.

Figure 2.

【 参考文献 】

• [1]Vagero D, Lundberg O: Health inequalities in Britain and Sweden. Lancet 1989, 2(8653):35-36.
• [2]Mackenbach JP, Kunst AE, Cavelaars AEJM, Groenhof F, Geurts JJM, Andersen O, Bonte JTP, Borgan JK, Crialesi R, Desplanques G, et al.: Socioeconomic inequalities in morbidity and mortality in Western Europe. Lancet 1997, 349(9066):1655-1659.
• [3]Brennenstuhl S, Quesnel-Vallee A, McDonough P: Welfare regimes, population health and health inequalities: a research synthesis. J Epidemiol Community Health 2012, 66(5):397-409.
• [4]Muntaner C, Borrell C, Ng E, Chung H, Espelt A, Rodriguez-Sanz M, Benach J, O’Campo P: Review article: politics, welfare regimes, and population health: controversies and evidence. Sociol Health Illn 2011, 33(6):946-964.
• [5]Dahl E, van der Wel KA: Educational inequalities in health in European welfare states: a social expenditure approach. Soc Sci Med 2012, 81:60-69.
• [6]Korpi W, Palme J: The social citizenship indicator program (SCIP). General coding comments. 2007, 1-27.
• [7]Gilbert N: The least generous welfare state? A case of blind empiricism. J Comp Policy Anal 2009, 11(3):355-367.
• [8]Kangas O, Palme J: Social rights, structural needs and social expenditure: a comparative study of 18 OECD countries 1960–2000. In Investigating Welfare State Change: The Dependent Variable Problem in Comparative Analysis. Edited by Clasen J, Siegel NA. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Publishing Limited; 2007:106-129.
• [9]Beckfield J, Krieger N: Epi + demos + cracy: linking political systems and priorities to the magnitude of health inequities–evidence, gaps, and a research agenda. Epidemiol Rev 2009, 31:152-177.
• [10]Lundberg O, Åberg Yngwe M, Kölegård Stjärne M, Björk L, Fritzell J: The Nordic Experience: Welfare States and Public Health (NEWS). Stockholm: US-AB; 2008.
• [11]Popham F, Dibben C, Bambra C: Are health inequalities really not the smallest in the Nordic welfare states? A comparison of mortality inequality in 37 countries. J Epidemiol Community Health 2013, 67:412-418.
• [12]Richter M, Rathman K, Nic Gabhainn S, Zambon A, Boyce W, Hurrelmann K: Welfare state regimes, health and health inequalities in adolescence: a multilevel study in 32 countries. Sociol Health Illn 2012, 34(6):858-879.
• [13]Ploubidis GB, Dale C, Grundy E: Later life health in Europe: how important are country level influences? Eur J Ageing 2012, 9(1):5-13.
• [14]Huijts T, Perkins JM, Subramanian SV: Political regimes, political ideology, and self-rated health in Europe: a multilevel analysis. PLoS One 2010, 5(7):1-5.
• [15]Burstrom B, Whitehead M, Clayton S, Fritzell S, Vannoni F, Costa G: Health inequalities between lone and couple mothers and policy under different welfare regimes - The example of Italy, Sweden and Britain. Soc Sci Med 2010, 70(6):912-920.
• [16]Tanaka S: Parental leave and child health across OECD countries. Econ J 2005, 115(501):F7-F28.
• [17]Kangas O: One hundred years of money, welfare and death: mortality, economic growth and the development of the welfare state in 17 OECD countries 1900–2000. Int J Soc Welf 2010, 19:S42-S59.
• [18]Ferrera M: The ‘southern Model’ of welfare in social Europe. J Eur Social Policy 1996, 6(1):17-37.
• [19]Esping-Andersen G: The three worlds of welfare capitalism. London: Polity; 1990.
• [20]Huber E, Stephens J: Welfare state and production regimes in the era of retrenchment. In The New Politics of the welfare state. Edited by Piersin P . Oxford: Oxford University Press; 2001.
• [21]Huber E, Ragin C, Stephens J: Comparative Welfare States Dataset. Chapel Hill: NC: Northwestern University, University of North Carolina; 1997.
• [22]Eikemo TA, Bambra C, Joyce K, Dahl E: Welfare state regimes and income-related health inequalities: a comparison of 23 European countries. Eur J Public Health 2008, 18(6):593-599.
• [23]Karim SA, Eikemo TA, Bambra C: Welfare state regimes and population health: integrating the East Asian welfare states. Health Policy 2010, 94(1):45-53.
• [24]Espelt A, Borrell C, Rodriguez-Sanz M, Muntaner C, Pasarin MI, Benach J, Schaap M, Kunst AE, Navarro V: Inequalities in health by social class dimensions in European countries of different political traditions. Int J Epidemiol 2008, 37(5):1095-1105.
• [25]Borrell C, Espelt A, Rodriguez-Sanz M, Burstrom B, Muntaner C, Pasarin MI, Benach J, Marinacci C, Roskam AJ, Schaap M, et al.: Analyzing differences in the magnitude of socioeconomic inequalities in self-perceived health by countries of different political tradition in Europe. Int J Health Serv 2009, 39(2):321-341.
• [26]Navarro V, Muntaner C, Borrell C, Benach J, Quiroga A, Rodriguez-Sanz M, Verges N, Pasarin MI: Politics and health outcomes. Lancet 2006, 368(9540):1033-1037.
• [27]Bambra C: Health status and the worlds of welfare. Soc Policy Soc 2006, 5(1):53-62.
• [28]Harding S, Lenguerrand E, Costa G, d’Errico A, Martikainen P, Tarkiainen L, Blane D, Akinwale B, Bartley M: Trends in mortality by labour market position around retirement ages in three European countries with different welfare regimes. Int J Public Health 2012, 58(1):99-108.
• [29]Sekine M, Chandola T, Martikainen P, Marmot M, Kagamimori S: Socioeconomic inequalities in physical and mental functioning of British, Finnish, and Japanese civil servants: role of job demand, control, and work hours. Soc Sci Med 2009, 69(10):1417-1425.
• [30]Deeming C, Hayes D: Worlds of welfare capitalism and wellbeing: a multilevel analysis. J Soc Policy 2012, 41:811-829.
• [31]Sacker A, Worts D, McDonough P: Social influences on trajectories of self-rated health: evidence from Britain, Germany, Denmark and the USA. J Epidemiol Community Health 2011, 65(2):130-136.
• [32]Raphael D: The political economy of health promotion: part 2, national provision of the prerequisites of health. Health Promot Int 2013, 28:112-132.
• [33]Zambon A, Boyce W, Cois E, Currie C, Lemma P, Dalmasso P, Borraccino A, Cavallo F: Do welfare regimes mediate the effect of socioeconomic position on health in adolescence? A Cross-national comparison in Europe, North America, and Israel. Int J Health Serv 2006, 36(2):309-329.
• [34]Rostila M: Social capital and health in European welfare regimes: a multilevel approach. J Eur Soc Policy 2007, 17(3):223-239.
• [35]Castles FG, Mitchell D: Worlds of welfare and families of nations. In Families of nations: Patterns of public policy in western democracies. Edited by Castles FG. Dartmouth: Aldershot; 1993:93-128.
• [36]Bambra C, Netuveli G, Eikemo TA: Welfare state regime life courses: the development of western European welfare state regimes and age-related patterns of educational inequalities in self-reported health. Int J Health Serv 2010, 40(3):399-420.
• [37]Korpi W, Palme J: The paradox of redistribution and strategies of equality: welfare state institutions, inequality, and poverty in the western countries. American Sociological Review 1998, 63(5):661-87.
• [38]Dragano N, Siegrist J, Wahrendorf M: Welfare regimes, labour policies and unhealthy psychosocial working conditions: a comparative study with 9917 older employees from 12 European countries. J Epidemiol Community Health 2010, 65(9):793-799.
• [39]Bambra C, Pope D, Swami V, Stanistreet D, Roskam A, Kunst A, Scott-Samuel A: Gender, health inequalities and welfare state regimes: a cross-national study of 13 European countries. J Epidemiol Community Health 2009, 63(1):38-44.
• [40]van der Wel KA, Dahl E, Thielen K: Social inequalities in “sickness”: does welfare state regime type make a difference? A multilevel analysis of men and women in 26 European countries. Int J Health Serv 2012, 42(2):235-255.
• [41]Chuang YC, Chuang KY, Chen YR, Shi BW, Yang TH: Welfare state regimes, infant mortality and life expectancy: integrating evidence from East Asia. J Epidemiol Community Health 2012, 66(7):e23.
• [42]Eikemo TA, Bambra C, Judge K, Ringdal K: Welfare state regimes and differences in self-perceived health in Europe: a multilevel analysis. Soc Sci Med 2008, 66(11):2281-2295.
• [43]Eikemo TA, Huisman M, Bambra C, Kunst AE: Health inequalities according to educational level in different welfare regimes: a comparison of 23 European countries. Sociol Health Illn 2008, 30(4):565-582.
• [44]Bambra C, Eikemo TA: Welfare state regimes, unemployment and health: a comparative study of the relationship between unemployment and self-reported health in 23 European countries. J Epidemiol Community Health 2009, 63(2):92-98.
• [45]Bambra C: Sifting the wheat from the chaff': a two-dimensional discriminant analysis of welfare state regime theory. Social Policy & Administration 2007, 41(1):1-28.
• [46]Eikemo TA, Bambra C: The welfare state: a glossary for public health. J Epidemiol Community Health 2008, 62(1):3-6.
• [47]Kovacs JM: Approaching the EU and reaching the US? Rival narratives on transforming welfare regimes in East-Central Europe. West European Politics 2002, 25(2):175-204.
• [48]Olsen KM, Dahl SA: Health differences between European countries. Soc Sci Med 2007, 64(8):1665-1678.
• [49]Chung H, Muntaner C: Welfare state matters: a typological multilevel analysis of wealthy countries. Health Policy 2007, 80(2):328-339.
• [50]Sanders AE, Slade GD, John MT, Steele JG, Suominen-Taipale AL, Lahti S, Nuttall NM, Allen PF: A cross-national comparison of income gradients in oral health quality of life in four welfare states: application of the Korpi and Palme typology. J Epidemiol Community Health 2009, 63(7):569-574.
• [51]Hoffmann R: Socioeconomic inequalities in old-age mortality: a comparison of Denmark and the USA. Soc Sci Med 2011, 72(12):1986-1992.
• [52]Olafsdottir S: Fundamental causes of health disparities: stratification, the welfare state, and health in the United States and Iceland. J Health Soc Behav 2007, 48(3):239-253.
• [53]Kunst AE, Bos V, Lahelma E, Bartley M, Lissau I, Regidor E, Mielck A, Cardano M, Dalstra JA, Geurts JJ, et al.: Trends in socioeconomic inequalities in self-assessed health in 10 European countries. Int J Epidemiol 2005, 34(2):295-305.
• [54]Avendano M, Jurges H, Mackenbach JP: Educational level and changes in health across Europe: longitudinal results from SHARE. J Eur Soc Policy 2009, 19(4):301-316.
• [55]Granados JA: Politics and health in eight European countries: a comparative study of mortality decline under social democracies and right-wing governments. Soc Sci Med 2010, 71(5):841-850.
• [56]Engster D, Stensota HO: Do family policy regimes matter for children’s well-being? Soc Polit 2011, 18(1):82-124.
• [57]Ferrarini T, Norstrom T: Family policy, economic development and infant mortality: a longitudinal comparative analysis. Int J Soc Welf 2010, 19:S89-S102.
• [58]Ferrarini T, Sjoberg O: Social policy and health: transition countries in a comparative perspective. Int J Soc Welf 2010, 19:S60-S88.
• [59]Lundberg O, Yngwe MA, Stjarne MK, Elstad JI, Ferrarini T, Kangas O, Norstrom T, Palme J, Fritzell J: The role of welfare state principles and generosity in social policy programmes for public health: an international comparative study. Lancet 2008, 372(9650):1633-1640.
• [60]Esser I, Palme J: Do public pensions matter for health and wellbeing among retired persons? Basic and income security pensions across 13 Western European countries. Int J Soc Welf 2010, 19:S103-S120.
• [61]Norstrom T, Palme J: Public pension institutions and old-age mortality in a comparative perspective. Int J Soc Welf 2010, 19:S121-S130.
• [62]Fritzell S, Ringback Weitoft G, Fritzell J, Burstrom B: From macro to micro: the health of Swedish lone mothers during changing economic and social circumstances. Soc Sci Med 2007, 65(12):2474-2488.
• [63]Nordenmark M, Strandh M, Layte R: The impact of unemployment benefit system on the mental well-being of the unemployed in Sweden, Ireland and Great Britain. Eur Soc 2006, 8(1):83-110.
• [64]Borrell C, Rodriguez-Sanz M, Pasarin MI, Brugal MT, Garcia-de-Olalla P, Mari-Dell’Olmo M, Cayla J: AIDS mortality before and after the introduction of highly active antiretroviral therapy: does it vary with socioeconomic group in a country with a National Health System? Eur J Public Health 2006, 16(6):601-608.
• [65]James PD, Wilkins R, Detsky AS, Tugwell P, Manuel DG: Avoidable mortality by neighbourhood income in Canada: 25 years after the establishment of universal health insurance. J Epidemiol Community Health 2007, 61(4):287-296.
• [66]Korda RJ, Butler JR, Clements MS, Kunitz SJ: Differential impacts of health care in Australia: trend analysis of socioeconomic inequalities in avoidable mortality. Int J Epidemiol 2007, 36(1):157-165.
• [67]Bradley EH, Elkins BR, Herrin J, Elbel B: Health and social services expenditures: associations with health outcomes. BMJ Qual saf 2011, 20(10):826-831.
• [68]Vavken P, Pagenstert G, Grimm C, Dorotka R: Does increased health care spending afford better health care outcomes? Evidence from Austrian health care expenditure since the implementation of DRGs. Swiss Med Weekly 2012, 142:w13589.
• [69]Wu JCL, Chiang TL: Comparing child mortality in Taiwan and selected industrialized countries. J Formos Med Assoc 2007, 106(2):177-180.
• [70]Gesthuizen M, Huijts T, Kraaykamp G: Explaining health marginalisation of the lower educated: the role of cross-national variations in health expenditure and labour market conditions. Sociol Health Illn 2012, 34(4):591-607.
• [71]Stuckler D, Basu S, McKee M: Budget crises, health, and social welfare programmes. BMJ (Clinical research ed) 2010, 340:c3311.
• [72]Baldwin P: Can we define a European welfare state model? In Comparative Welfare Systems: the Scandinavian Model in a Period of Change. Edited by Greve B. London: Macmillan Press Ltd; 1996:29-44.
• [73]Kasza GJ: The illusion of welfare ‘regimes’. J Soc Policy 2002, 31:271-287.
• [74]Mackenbach JP: Public health and welfare. Eur J Public Health 2012, 22(1):1-1.
• [75]Kvist J, Greve B: Has the Nordic welfare model been transformed? Soc Policy Admin 2011, 45(2):146-160.
• [76]Kuivalainen S, Nelson K: Eroding minimum income protection in the Nordic countries? Reassessing the Noridc model of social assistance. In Changing social equality The Nordic welfare model in the 21st century. Great Britain: The Policy Press; 2012:69-87.
• [77]OECD: Crisis squeezes income and puts pressure on inequality and poverty. 2013.
• [78]Hudson J, Kühner S: Towards productive welfare? A comparative analysis of 23 OECD countries. J Eur Social Policy 2009, 19(1):34-46.
• [79]Hudson J, Kühner S: Beyond the dependent variable problem: the methodological challenges of capturing productive and protective dimensions of social policy. Social Policy and Society 2010, 9(02):167-179.
• [80]Hudson J, Kühner S: Analyzing the productive and protective dimensions of welfare: looking beyond the OECD. Soc Policy Admin 2012, 46(1):35-60.
• [81]Hall PA, Soskice D: An introduction to varieties of capitalism. In Varieties of Capitalism: The Institutional Foundations of Comparative Advantage. Edited by Hall PA, Soskice D. Oxford: Oxford University Press; 2001:1-68.
• [82]Castles FG: What welfare states do: a disaggregated expenditure approach. J Soc Policy 2008, 38(1):45-62.