Controversies and considerations regarding the termination of pregnancy for Foetal Anomalies in Islam

BMC Medical Ethics

Jaffar Ali¹  Abdulrahman Al-Matary² 

[1] Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, Faculty of Medicine, University of Malaya, 59100 Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia;Department of Neonatology, King Fahad Medical City Riyadh, P.O. Box 59046, 11525 Riyadh, Kingdom of Saudi Arabia

关键词: TOP;    Termination of pregnancy;    Glorious Qur’an;    Islam;    Ensoulment;    Abortion;   

Others  :  799588
DOI  :  10.1186/1472-6939-15-10

 received in 2013-04-23, accepted in 2014-01-31,  发布年份 2014

【 摘 要 】

Background

Approximately one-fourth of all the inhabitants on earth are Muslims. Due to unprecedented migration, physicians are often confronted with cultures other than their own that adhere to different pdigms.

Discussion

In Islam, and most religions, abortion is forbidden. Islam is considerably liberal concerning abortion, which is dependent on (i) the threat of harm to mothers, (ii) the status of the pregnancy before or after ensoulment (on the 120^th day of gestation), and (iii) the presence of foetal anomalies that are incompatible with life. Considerable variation in religious edicts exists, but most Islamic scholars agree that the termination of a pregnancy for foetal anomalies is allowed before ensoulment, after which abortion becomes totally forbidden, even in the presence of foetal abnormalities; the exception being a risk to the mother’s life or confirmed intrauterine death.

Summary

The authors urge Muslim law makers to also consider abortion post ensoulment if it is certain that the malformed foetus will decease soon after birth or will be severely malformed and physically and mentally incapacitated after birth to avoid substantial hardship that may continue for years for mothers and family members. The authors recommend that an institutional committee governed and monitored by a national committee make decisions pertaining to abortion to ensure that ethics are preserved and mistakes are prevented. Anomalous foetuses must be detected at the earliest possible time to enable an appropriate medical intervention prior to the 120^th day.

【 授权许可】

   
2014 Al-Matary and Ali; licensee BioMed Central Ltd.

【 参考文献 】

• [1]Richard Allen G: World Muslim population doubling, report projects - CNN News. 201.
• [2]Shaw A: ‘They say Islam has a solution for everything, so why are there no guidelines for this?’ Ethical dilemmas associated with the births and deaths of infants with fatal abnormalities from a small sample of Pakistani Muslim couples in Britain. Bioethics 2012, 26(9):485-492.
• [3]Gatrad AR, Sheikh A: Medical ethics and Islam: principles and practice. Arch Dis Child 2001, 84:72-75.
• [4]Der Wal JT G-v, Manniën J, Ghaly MM, Verhoeven PS, Hutton EK, Reinders HS: The role of religion in decision-making on antenatal screening of congenital anomalies: a qualitative study amongst Muslim Turkish origin immigrants. Midwifery 2013, 29:S0266-6138(13)00106-X.
• [5]Agay-Shay K, Friger M, Linn S, Peled A, Amitai Y, Peretz C: Periodicity and time trends in the prevalence of total births and conceptions with congenital malformations among Jews and Muslims in Israel, 1999-2006: a time series study of 823,966 births. Birth Defects Res A Clin Mol Teratol 2012, 94(6):438-448.
• [6]Al-Alaiyan S, Alfaleh KM: Aborting a malformed fetus: A debatable issue in Saudi Arabia. J Clin Neonatol 2012, 1(1):6-11.
• [7]Al Aqeel AI: Islamic ethical framework for research into and prevention of genetic diseases. Nat Genet 2007, 39(11):1293-1298.
• [8]Aramesh K: A closer look at the abortion debate in Iran. Am J Bioeth 2009, 9(8):57-58.
• [9]Bryant LD, Ahmed S, Ahmed M, Jafri H, Raashid Y: ‘All is done by Allah’. Understandings of Down syndrome and prenatal testing in Pakistan. Soc Sci Med 2011, 72(8):1393-1399.
• [10]Bundey S, Alam H, Kaur A, Mir S, Lancashire RJ: Race, consanguinity and social features in Birmingham babies: a basis for prospective study. J Epidemiol Community Health 1990, 44:130-135.
• [11]Chaabouni H, Chaabouni M, Maazoul F, M’Rad R, Jemaa LB, Smaoui N, Terras K, Kammoun H, Belghith N, Ridene H, Oueslati B, Zouari F: Prenatal diagnosis of chromosome disorders in Tunisian population. Ann Genet 2001, 44(2):99-104.
• [12]Da Costa DE, Ghazal H, Al KS: Do not resuscitate orders and ethical decisions in a neonatal intensive care unit in a Muslim community. Arch Dis Child Fetal Neonatal Ed 2002, 86(2):F115-119.
• [13]Farag TI, Al-Awadi SA, Yassin S, El-Kassaby TA, Jaefary S, Usha R, Uma R, Mady SA, Fakhr M, Mannae M, et al.: Anencephaly: a vanishing problem in Bedouins? J Med Genet 1989, 26(8):538-539.
• [14]Ngim CF, Lai NM, Ibrahim H, Ratnasingam V: Attitudes towards prenatal diagnosis and abortion in a multi-ethnic country: a survey among parents of children with thalassaemia major in Malaysia. J Community Genet 2013, 4(2):215-221.
• [15]Hedayat KM, Shooshtarizadeh P, Raza M: Therapeutic abortion in Islam: contemporary views of Muslim Shiite scholars and effect of recent Iranian legislation. J Med Ethics 2006, 32(11):652-657.
• [16]Husain F: Ethical dimensions of non-aggressive fetal management: a Muslim perspective. Semin Fetal Neonatal Med 2008, 13(5):323-324.
• [17]Jafri H, Ahmed S, Ahmed M, Hewison J, Raashid Y, Sheridan E: Islam and termination of pregnancy for genetic conditions in Pakistan: implications for Pakistani health care providers. Prenat Diagn 2012, 32(12):1218-1220.
• [18]Sasongko TH, Salmi AR, Zilfalil BA, Albar MA, Mohd Hussin ZA: Permissibility of prenatal diagnosis and abortion for fetuses with severe genetic disorder: type 1 spinal muscular atrophy. Ann Saudi Med 2010, 30(6):427-431.
• [19]Serour GI: Islamic perspectives in human reproduction. Reprod Biomed Online 2008, 17(Suppl 3):34-38.
• [20]Sharony R, Kidron D, Amiel A, Fejgin M, Borochowitz ZU: Familial lethal skeletal dysplasia withcloverleaf skull and multiple anomalies of brain, eye, face and heart: a new autosomal recessive multiple congenital anomalies syndrome. Clin Genet 2002, 61:369-374.
• [21]Sher C, Romano-Zelekha O, Green MS, Shohat T: Utilization of prenatal genetic testing by Israeli Moslem women: a national survey. Clin Genet 2004, 65(4):278-283.
• [22]Teebi AS: Autosomal recessive disorders among Arabs: an overview from Kuwait. J Med Genet 1994, 31(3):224-233.
• [23]Zlotogora J, Haklai Z, Rotem N, Georgi M, Rubin L: The impact of prenatal diagnosis and termination of pregnancy on the relative incidence of malformations at birth among Jews and Muslim Arabs in Israel. Isr Med Assoc J 2010, 12(9):539-542.
• [24]Zlotogora J: The molecular basis of autosomal recessive diseases among the Arabs and Druze in Israel. Hum Genet 2010, 128(5):473-479.
• [25]Zlotogora J, Haklai Z, Leventhal A: Utilization of prenatal diagnosis and termination of pregnancies for the prevention of Down syndrome in Israel. Isr Med Assoc J 2007, 9(8):600-602.
• [26]Zlotogora J, Hujerat Y, Barges S, Shalev SA, Chakravarti A: The fate of 12 recessive mutations in a single village. Ann Hum Genet 2007, 71(Pt 2):202-208.
• [27]Zlotogora J: Is there an increased birth defect risk to children born to offspring of first cousin parents? Am J Med Genet A 2005, 1(3):137A-342.
• [28]Zlotogora J, Haklai Z, Rotem N, Georgi M, Berlovitz I, Leventhal A, Amitai Y: Relative prevalence of malformations at birth among different religious communities in Israel. Am J Med Genet A 2003, 15(1):59-62.
• [29]Zlotogora J, Leventhal A, Amitai Y: The impact of congenital malformations and Mendelian diseases on infant mortality in Israel. Isr Med Assoc J 2003, 5(6):416-418.
• [30]Blancard CM: Islam:Sunnis and Shiites. Congressional Research Services Report for Congress January 28, 2009. 2013. http://www.fas.org/irp/crs/RS21745.pdf webcite
• [31]Lewis JA: Jewish perspectives on pregnancy and child bearing. Matern Child Nurs 2003, 28:306-12.
• [32]Markwell HJ, Brown BF: Bioethics for clinicians: 27. Catholic bioethics. Can Med Assoc J 2001, 165:189-92.
• [33]Pauls M, Hutchinson RC: Bioethics for clinicians: 28. Protestant bioethics. Can Med Assoc J 2002, 166:339-343.
• [34]BBC: Religion & Ethics - When is the foetus ‘alive’: The stages of fetal development. 2011.
• [35]Alamri YA: Islam and abortion. J. Islamic Med Assoc North Am 2011, 43(1):39-40.
• [36]Moore KL: A Scientist’s interpretation of references to embryology in the Qur’an. J. Islamic Med Assoc North Am 1986, 18(1):15-17.
• [37]Al-Maqdesse AAMM, Shams A-D, Al-Maqdesse AAMM: Cairo (Egypt): Aalam Al-Kotob. 1985, 281.
• [38]Al-Mardawi AAAS: Alensaf fi ma’refat alrajeh men alkhelaf. Vol.1. Beirut. Lebanon: Dar El Fikr; 1956:386.
• [39]Al-Fozan SF: Opinions in medicine and the rights of the patients. Proceedings of the Standing Committee for Scientific Research and Issuing Edicts, Preaching and Guidance in Saudi Arabia 2003, 280-283.
• [40]Zahrah MA: Alengab alsenaei ahkamh alganoniah wa hododah al shareiah. Kuwait: University of Kuwait; 1993:351.
• [41]Al-Rajeh MR: Competent women in worship and the provisions of the family. Riyadh (Saudi Arabia): Al-Imam Muhammad Ibn Saud Islamic University Islamic, Faculty of Sharia; 2005:1198.
• [42]Khaled AAAE: Alhemaiah algenaeiah lelganeen fi del altagniat almostahdathah. Alexandria (Egypt): Dar El Fikr Al-Game’y; 2005:246.
• [43]Albar MA: Deformed fetus and genetic diseases. Damascus (Syria): Dar Al-Qalam; 1991:476.
• [44]Saeed AH: The provisions of the pregnant women in Islam. Riyadh (Saudi Arabia): Al-Imam Muhammad Ibn Saud Islamic University Islamic, Higher Institute of Justice; 1985:75.
• [45]Fatwa 1998. Grand Mufti of Al-Azhar: International Women’s Rights Action Watch. The Women’s Watch. Vol.12, Nos.1/2, December 1998. Cited In: Hessini. L. Abortion and Islam: Policies and practice in the Middle East and North Africa. Reprod Health Matters 2007, 15(29):75-84.
• [46]Fatwa 2004. Grand Mufti of Al-Azhar: Abortion issue in Egyptian spotlight. Arab News. 16 March 2004. Cited In: Hessini. L. Abortion and Islam: Policies and practice in the Middle East and North Africa. Reprod Health Matters 2007, 15(29):75-84.
• [47]Al-Hagawi S: Advisory opinion and approval of abortions for abnormal foetuses: Mufti of Jordan. Bahrain. Arabic: Newspaper, Al Wasat; 2007.
• [48]Council of the World Muslim League: Proceedings of Conference of The Fiqh (Islamic Jurisprudence). 1990.
• [49]Preaching and Guidance in Saudi Arabia: Proceedings of the Standing Committee for Scientific Research and Issuing Edicts. 2011.
• [50]Shapiro GK: Abortion law in Muslim-majority countries: an overview of the Islamic discourse with policy implications. Health Policy Plan 2013, 8:1-12.
• [51]Al-Maqdisi Q, Al-Mughni : Beirut (Lebanon): Dar Eha’a Al-Torath Al-Arabi. 1985, 324.
• [52]Bahoot MYI: Kashef algenaa’ an maten alegna’a. Vol.4. Beirut (Lebanon): Dar AlFekr; 1982:464.
• [53]Al-Dessouki MAA: Sharh al-Kabeer. Vol. 1. Cairo (Egypt): Dar Ehya’a Al-kotob Al-Arabia; 2004:427.
• [54]Al-A’bbadi AAMA: Al-jawhrah al-nairah. Vol.1. Cairo (Egypt): Al-mataba’ah al-Khairiah; 1901:110.
• [55]Al Shaikh HA: Impact of new technologies on controversial issues in Islam. Riyadh (Saudi Arabia): Al-Imam Muhammad Ibn Saud Islamic University Islamic, Faculty of Sharia; 2005:624-629.
• [56]Al-Srkhsai SAMAA: Al-Mabsoot. Vol.30. Beirut (Lebanon): Dar alma’refah; 1989:51.
• [57]Al- shawkani MA: Nil alawtar shareh motaga alakhbar. Vol.4. Cairo (Egypt): Dar al-Hadeeth; 1993:57.
• [58]Al- Meftah MS: Algeniat alkhasah bealtawaem almoltasegah. Damascus (Syria): Dar Al-Salam; 2008:167-238.
• [59]Al-Madhaji MG: Arbitrations in reproduction [PhD dissertation]. Riyadh (Saudi Arabia): Al-Imam Muhammad Ibn Saud Islamic University Islamic, Faculty of Sharia; 2009.
• [60]Kyle PM, Coghlan P, Matthews J, De Ryke R, Reid R: Accuracy of prenatal diagnosis in a tertiary fetal medicine unit. N Z Med J 2009, 122(1288):50-61.
• [61]United Nations Population Fund: The Gap Exists Between Hopes and Realities. New York: UNFPA. Cited In: Hessini. L. Abortion and Islam: Policies and practice in the Middle East and North Africa. Reprod Health Matters 2007, 15(29):75-84.
• [62]World Health Organization: Unsafe Abortion: Global and Regional Estimates of the Incidence of Unsafe Abortion and Associated Mortality in 2000. Geneva: WHO; 2004.
• [63]Population Council: Experience with clinical training in postabortion care in Egypt. In Improving Medical and Interpersonal skills. Edited by Al-Hegazi S, Huntington D. Cairo: Population Council; 1997.
• [64]Global Health Council: Promises to Keep: The Toll of Unintended Pregnancy on Women in the Developing World. Washington, DC: Global Health Council; 2002. Cited In: Hessini. L. Abortion and Islam: Policies and practice in the Middle East and North Africa. Reprod Health Matters 2007, 15(29):75-84.
• [65]WHO: Report, 2011. 2014. http://www.who.int/reproductivehealth/topics/unsafeabortion/hrpwork/en/index.html webcite. Accessed 06 January 2014
• [66]Jewkes R, Rees H, Dickson K, Brown H, Levin J: The impact of age on the epidemiology of incomplete abortions in South Africa after legislative change. British J Obstet Gynaecol 2005, 112(3):355-359.
• [67]Department for International Development (DFID): How to Reduce Maternal Deaths: Rights and Responsibilities. 2005. http://www2.ohchr.org/english/issues/development/docs/rights_maternal_health.pdf webcite. Accessed 6 January 2014
• [68]Al Sayyad IA: Legal Directives for Medical Practice Procedures. 2007. http://www.islamicmedicine.org/SayadBook2.htm webcite. Cited In: Al Aqeel, 2007
• [69]Ajlouni KMS: in Cloning between Science and Religion [available in Arabic]. Amman, Jordan: Ajial Press; 2007.
• [70]Al Othiamian MS: in Fundamentals Of Islamic Jurisprudence “Isul Al Fagih”. Damam, KSA: Abn Al Jawzi Press; 2007.
• [71]Al Aqeel AI: Common genetics and metabolic diseases in Saudi Arabia. Middle East J Fam Med 2004, 6:6. http://www.mejfm.com/Newarchives2013/Common%20Genetics%20and%20Meta.pdf webcite. Accessed 6 January 2014
• [72]Resolution on “Conscientious Objection”: Adopted by FIGO General Assembly. 2006.