The web of silence: a qualitative case study of early intervention and support for healthcare workers with mental ill-health

BMC Public Health

Sandra E Moll¹ 

[1] School of Rehabilitation Science, McMaster University, Institute for Applied Health Science, 4th Floor, 1400 Main St. W., Hamilton ON L8S 1C7, Canada

关键词: Qualitative methods;    Mental illness;    Early intervention;    Organizational research;    Stigma;    Workplace mental health;    Healthcare workers;   

Others  :  1145379
DOI  :  10.1186/1471-2458-14-138

 received in 2013-07-24, accepted in 2014-02-07,  发布年份 2014

【 摘 要 】

Background

There is a high rate of stress and mental illness among healthcare workers, yet many continue to work despite symptoms that affect their performance. Workers with mental health issues are typically ostracized and do not get the support that they need. If issues are not addressed, however, they could become worse and compromise the health and safety, not only of the worker, but his/her colleagues and patients. Early identification and support can improve work outcomes and facilitate recovery, but more information is needed about how to facilitate this process in the context of healthcare work. The purpose of this study was to explore the key individual and organizational forces that shape early intervention and support for healthcare workers who are struggling with mental health issues, and to identify barriers and opportunities for change.

Methods

A qualitative, case study in a large, urban healthcare organization was conducted in order to explore the perceptions and experiences of employees across the organization. In-depth interviews were conducted with eight healthcare workers who had experienced mental health issues at work as well as eight workplace stakeholders who interacted with workers who were struggling (managers, coworkers, union leaders). An online survey was completed by an additional 67 employees. Analysis of the interviews and surveys was guided by a process of interpretive description to identify key barriers to early intervention and support.

Results

There were many reports of silence and inaction in response to employee mental health issues. Uncertainty in identifying mental health problems, stigma regarding mental ill health, a discourse of professional competence, social tensions, workload pressures, confidentiality expectations and lack of timely access to mental health supports were key forces in preventing employees from getting the help that they needed. Although there were a few exceptions, the overall study findings point to many barriers to supporting employees with mental health issues.

Conclusions

In order to address the complex knowledge, attitudinal, interpersonal and organizational barriers to action, a multi-layered knowledge translation strategy is needed, that considers not only mental health literacy and anti-stigma interventions, but addresses the unique context of the work environment that can act as a barrier to change.

【 授权许可】

   
2014 Moll; licensee BioMed Central Ltd.

【 图 表 】

Figure 1.

【 参考文献 】

• [1]Statistics Canada: 2005 National Survey of the Work and Health of Nurses (CIHI share file). Ottawa: Statistics Canada; 2006.
• [2]Wieclaw J, Agerbo E, Mortensen PB, Bonde JP: Risk of affective and stress related disorders among employees in human service professions. Occup Environ Med 2006, 63(5):314-319.
• [3]Peterson U, Demerouti E, Bergström G, Samuelsson M, Åsberg M, Nygren Å: Burnout and physical and mental health among Swedish healthcare workers. J Adv Nurs 2008, 62(1):1365-2648.
• [4]Kaseburg M, Chahal N, Duan S, Smailes E: Changing the Workplace: Improving Mental Health of Hospital Workers, Summary of Work Conditions Results from the Baseline Survey. Columbia,Vancouver BC: Occupational Health and Safety Agency for Healthcare in British; 2008.
• [5]Canadian Institute for Health Information (CIHI): Canada’s Healthcare Providers: 2005 Chartbook. Ottawa: Canadian Institute for Health Information (CIHI); 2005.
• [6]Gärtner FR, Nieuwenhuijsen K, Ketelaar SM, van Dijk FJ, Sluiter JK: The mental vitality@ work study: effectiveness of a mental module for workers' health surveillance for nurses and allied health care professionals on their help-seeking behavior. J Occup Environ Med 2013, 55(10):1219-1229.
• [7]Shamian J, El-Jardali F: Healthy workplaces for health workers in Canada: knowledge transfer and uptake in policy and practice. Healthc Pap 2007, 7(I):6.
• [8]Silas L: From promise to practice: Getting healthy work environments in health workplaces. Healthc Pap 2007, 7(I):46.
• [9]Moll S, Eakin JM, Franche R-L, Strike C: When health care WORKERS experience mental Ill health institutional practices of silence. Qual Health Res 2013, 23(2):167-179.
• [10]Kessler RC, Frank RG: The impact of psychiatric disorders on work loss days. Psychol Med 1997, 27(4):861-873.
• [11]McGorry P: Prevention, innovation and implementation science in mental health: the next wave of reform. Br J Psychiatry 2013, 202(s54):s3-s4.
• [12]Pomaki G, Franche R-L, Murray E, Khushrushahi N, Lampinen TM: Workplace-based work disability prevention interventions for workers with common mental health conditions: a review of the literature. J Occup Rehabil 2012, 22(2):182-195.
• [13]Marwaha S, Durrani A, Singh S: Employment outcomes in people with bipolar disorder: a systematic review. Acta Psychiatr Scand 2013, 128(3):179-193.
• [14]Brouwers EP, Terluin B, Tiemens BG, Verhaak PF: Predicting return to work in employees sick-listed due to minor mental disorders. J Occup Rehabil 2009, 19(4):323-332.
• [15]Statistics Canada: Canadian Community Health Survey: Mental Health and Well-Being 2002. Ottawa, ON: Statistics Canada; 2003.
• [16]Jagdeo A, Cox BJ, Stein MB, Sareen J: Negative attitudes toward help seeking for mental illness in 2 population-based surveys from the United States and Canada. Can J Psychiatry 2009, 54(11):757-766.
• [17]Jorm AF: Mental health literacy public knowledge and beliefs about mental disorders. Br J Psychiatry 2000, 177(5):396-401.
• [18]Schomerus G, Angermeyer MC: Special articles stigma and its impact on help-seeking for mental disorders: what do we know? Epidemiol Psichiatr Soc 2008, 17(1):31.
• [19]Franche R-L, Baril R, Shaw W, Nicholas M, Loisel P: Workplace-based return-to-work interventions: optimizing the role of stakeholders in implementation and research. J Occup Rehabil 2005, 15(4):525-542.
• [20]Shaw WS, Robertson MM, Pransky G, McLellan RK: Employee perspectives on the role of supervisors to prevent workplace disability after injuries. J Occup Rehabil 2003, 13(3):129-142.
• [21]Foss L, Gravseth HM, Kristensen P, Claussen B, Mehlum IS, Skyberg K: Risk factors for long-term absence due to psychiatric sickness: a register-based 5-year follow-up from the Oslo health study. J Occup Environ Med 2010, 52(7):698-705.
• [22]Joyce T, Hazelton M, McMillan M: Nurses with mental illness: their workplace experiences. Int J Ment Health Nurs 2007, 16(6):373-380.
• [23]Ross CA, Goldner EM: Stigma, negative attitudes and discrimination towards mental illness within the nursing profession: a review of the literature. J Psychiatr Ment Health Nurs 2009, 16(6):558-567.
• [24]Stergiou-Kita M, Moll S, Walsh A, Gewurtz R: Health professionals, advocacy and return to work: taking up the challenge. Work 2010, 37(2):217-223.
• [25]Shain M: Tracking the perfect legal storm: converging systems create mounting pressure to create the psychologically safe workplace. Mental Health Commission of Canada 2010. [http://www.workplacestrategiesformentalhealth.com/pdf/Perfect_Legal_EN.pdf webcite]
• [26]Canadian Standards Association: Psychological health and safety in the workplace - Prevention, promotion, and guidance to staged implementation. Canada: Canadian Standards Association; 2013. [http://shop.csa.ca/en/canada/occupational-health-and-safety-management/cancsa-z1003-13bnq-9700-8032013/invt/z10032013 webcite]
• [27]Kelloway EK, Day AL: Building healthy workplaces: What we know so far. Can J Behav Sci 2005, 37(4):223.
• [28]Smith P, Bielecky A, Frank J: Intervention research on working conditions and mental health: persistent challenges, new directions and opportunities to integrate research agendas. Healthc Pap 2011, 11(Sp):67-72.
• [29]Graham ID, Logan J, Harrison MB, Straus SE, Tetroe J, Caswell W, Robinson N: Lost in knowledge translation: time for a map? J Contin Educ Health Prof 2006, 26(1):13-24.
• [30]Hartley J: Case study research. In Qualitative Methods in Organizational Research: A Practical Guide. Edited by Cassell C, Symon G. London: Sage; 2004.
• [31]Yin RK: Case Study Research Design and Methods. 4th edition. Thousand Oaks CA: Sage; 2009.
• [32]Moll S: Navigating political minefields: partnerships in organizational case study research. Work 2012, 43:5-12.
• [33]Baxter P, Jack S: Qualitative case study methodology: Study design and implementation for novice researchers. Qual Report 2008, 13(4):544-559.
• [34]Coyne IT: Sampling in qualitative research. Purposeful and theoretical sampling; merging or clear boundaries? J Adv Nurs 1997, 26(3):623-630.
• [35]Tong A, Sainsbury P, Craig J: Consolidated criteria for reporting qualitative research (COREQ): a 32-item checklist for interviews and focus groups. Int J Qual Health Care 19(6):349-357.
• [36]Thorne S: Interpretive Description. California: Left Coast Press; 2008.
• [37]Spencer L, Ritchie J, Lewis J, Dillon L: Quality in Qualitative Evaluation: A Framework for Assessing Research Evidence. National Centre for Social Research; 2003. [http://www.civilservice.gov.uk/wp-content/uploads/2011/09/a_quality_framework_tcm6-38740.pdf webcite]
• [38]Jorm AF, Korten AE, Jacomb PA, Christensen H, Rodgers B, Pollitt P: “Mental health literacy”: a survey of the public’s ability to recognize mental disorders and their beliefs about the effectiveness of treatment. Med J Aust 1997, 166:182-186.
• [39]Szeto AC, Dobson KS: Reducing the stigma of mental disorders at work: a review of current workplace anti-stigma intervention programs. Appl Prev Psychol 2010, 14(1):41-56.
• [40]Tsutsumi A: Development of an evidence-based guideline for supervisor training in promoting mental health: literature review. J Occup Health 2010, 0:1011050158.
• [41]Kitchener BA, Jorm AF: Mental health first aid training in a workplace setting: a randomized controlled trial [ISRCTN13249129]. BMC Psychiatry 2004, 4(1):23. BioMed Central Full Text
• [42]Michaud N, Arndt J: Mental Health First Aid training: An Examination of Two Cases - Health Care Professionals and Corporate Workplace Employees. Poster presentation, Mental Health Commission of Canada; 2012.
• [43]Stuart H: Mental illness and employment discrimination. Curr Opin Psychiatr 2006, 19(5):522-526.
• [44]Stuart H, Arboleda-Florez J, Sartorius N: Paradigms Lost: Fighting Stigma and the Lessons Learned. New York: Oxford; 2012.
• [45]Corrigan PW, River LP, Lundin RK, Penn DL, Uphoff-Wasowski K, Campion J, Mathisen J, Gagnon C, Bergman M, Goldstein H: Three strategies for changing attributions about severe mental illness. Schizophr Bull 2001, 27(2):187.
• [46]Couture S, Penn D: Interpersonal contact and the stigma of mental illness: a review of the literature. J Ment Health 2003, 12(3):291-305.
• [47]Wallach HS: Changes in attitudes towards mental illness following exposure. Community Ment Health J 2004, 40(3):235-248.
• [48]Stuart H, Koller M, Christie R, Pietrus M: Reducing mental health stigma: a case study. Healthc Q 2011, 14(Special Issue 2):40-49.
• [49]Lupton D: Power relations and the medical encounter. Soc Sci Med 2003, 45(3):373-381.
• [50]Holbrook T: The experiential connection. Perspectives 2000, 5(2):10-11.
• [51]Hyman I: Self-Disclosure and Its Impact on Individuals Who Receive Mental Health Services. HHS Pub. No. (SMA)-08-4337 Rockville, Maryland: Center for Mental Health Services, Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration; 2008.
• [52]Robinson M, Tilford S, Branney P, Kinsella K: Championing mental health at work: emerging practice from innovative projects in the UK. Health Promot Int 2013.
• [53]Gilbert M, Bilsker D: Psychological Health and Safety: An Action Guide for Employers. Canada: Mental Health Commission of Canada and the Centre for Applied Research in Mental Health & Addiction; 2012. [http://www.mentalhealthcommission.ca/English/node/505 webcite]
• [54]Podsakoff PM, MacKenzie SB, Paine JB, Bachrach DG: Organizational citizenship behaviors: a critical review of the theoretical and empirical literature and suggestions for future research. J Manag 2000, 26(3):513-563.
• [55]Organ DW: Organizational Citizenship Behavior: The Good Soldier Syndrome. Lexington, MA: Lexington Books; 1988.
• [56]Golden B: Transforming healthcare organizations. Healthc Q 2006, 10(Sp):10-19.
• [57]Gabe J, Bury M, Elson MA: Key Concepts in Medical Sociology. London: Sage; 2004.
• [58]Dewa CS, Burke A, Hardaker D, Caveen M, Baynton MA: Mental health training programs for managers: What do managers find valuable? Can J Community Ment Health 2006, 25(2):221-239.
• [59]Corbière M, Shen J, Rouleau M, Dewa CS: A systematic review of preventive interventions regarding mental health issues in organizations. Work 2009, 33(1):81-116.