Most bowel cancer symptoms do not indicate colorectal cancer and polyps: a systematic review

BMC Gastroenterology

Les Irwig²  Peter H Katelaris³  Siew F Chan¹  Petra Macaskill⁴  Barbara-Ann Adelstein⁵ 

[1] biostatistician, STEP, School of Public Health, University of Sydney, Australia;professor of epidemiology, STEP, School of Public Health, University of Sydney, Australia;gastroenterologist, Concord Repatriation General Hospital, University of Sydney, Australia;associate professor, STEP, School of Public Health, University of Sydney, Australia;Screening and Test Evaluation (STEP) Program, School of Public Health, University of Sydney, NSW 2006, Australia

关键词: change in bowel habit;    rectal bleeding;    bowel symptoms;    colorectal polyps;    colorectal cancer;   

Others  :  1114488
DOI  :  10.1186/1471-230X-11-65

 received in 2010-09-30, accepted in 2011-05-30,  发布年份 2011

【 摘 要 】

Background

Bowel symptoms are often considered an indication to perform colonoscopy to identify or rule out colorectal cancer or precancerous polyps. Investigation of bowel symptoms for this purpose is recommended by numerous clinical guidelines. However, the evidence for this practice is unclear. The objective of this study is to systematically review the evidence about the association between bowel symptoms and colorectal cancer or polyps.

Methods

We searched the literature extensively up to December 2008, using MEDLINE and EMBASE and following references. For inclusion in the review, papers from cross sectional, case control and cohort studies had to provide a 2×2 table of symptoms by diagnosis (colorectal cancer or polyps) or sufficient data from which that table could be constructed. The search procedure, quality appraisal, and data extraction was done twice, with disagreements resolved with another reviewer. Summary ROC analysis was used to assess the diagnostic performance of symptoms to detect colorectal cancer and polyps.

Results

Colorectal cancer was associated with rectal bleeding (AUC 0.66; LR+ 1.9; LR- 0.7) and weight loss (AUC 0.67, LR+ 2.5, LR- 0.9). Neither of these symptoms was associated with the presence of polyps. There was no significant association of colorectal cancer or polyps with change in bowel habit, constipation, diarrhoea or abdominal pain. Neither the clinical setting (primary or specialist care) nor study type was associated with accuracy.

Most studies had methodological flaws. There was no consistency in the way symptoms were elicited or interpreted in the studies.

Conclusions

Current evidence suggests that the common practice of performing colonoscopies to identify cancers in people with bowel symptoms is warranted only for rectal bleeding and the general symptom of weight loss. Bodies preparing guidelines for clinicians and consumers to improve early detection of colorectal cancer need to take into account the limited value of symptoms.

【 授权许可】

   
2011 Adelstein et al; licensee BioMed Central Ltd.

【 图 表 】

Figure 1.

Figure 2.

Figure 3.

Figure 4.

Figure 5.

Figure 6.

Figure 7.

Figure 8.

【 参考文献 】

• [1]Cooper N, Westlake S: Cancer incidence and mortality: trends in the United Kingdom and constituent countries, 1993 to 2004. Health Statistics Quarterly 2008, Summer(38):33-46.
• [2]Majumdar SR, Fletcher RH, Evans AT: How does colorectal cancer present? Symptoms, duration, and clues to location. Am J Gastroenterol 1999, 94(10):3039-3045.
• [3]Mulcahy HE, O'Donoghue DP: Duration of colorectal cancer symptoms and survival: the effect of confounding clinical and pathological variables. Eur J Cancer 1997, 33(9):1461-1467.
• [4]Dent OF, Goulston KJ, Zubrzycki J, Chapuis PH: Bowel symptoms in an apparently well population. Dis Colon Rectum 1986, 29(4):243-247.
• [5]Goulston K, Chapuis P, Dent O, Bokey L: Significance of bowel symptoms. Med J Aust 1987, 146(12):631-633.
• [6]European Panel on the Appropriateness of Gastrointestinal Endoscopy II (EPAGE) Volume 2009. Lausanne, Switzerland; 2008.
• [7]Dodds S, Dodds A, Vakis S, Flashman K, Senapati A, Cripps N, Thompson M: The value of various factors associated with rectal bleeding in the diagnosis of colorectal cancer. Gut 1999, 44(suppl 1):A99.
• [8]Norrelund N, Norrelund H: Colorectal cancer and polyps in patients aged 40 years and over who consult a GP with rectal bleeding. Fam Pract 1996, 13(2):160-165.
• [9]Moses LE, Shapiro D, Littenberg B: Combining independent studies of a diagnostic test into a summary ROC curve: data-analytic approaches and some additional considerations. Stat Med 1993, 12(14):1293-1316.
• [10]Rutter CM, Gatsonis CA: Regression methods for meta-analysis of diagnostic test data. Acad Radiol 1995, 2(Suppl 1):S48-56.
• [11]Rutter CM, Gatsonis CA: A hierarchical regression approach to meta-analysis of diagnostic test accuracy evaluations. Stat Med 2001, 20(19):2865-2884.
• [12]Macaskill P: Empirical Bayes estimates generated in a hierarchical summary ROC analysis agreed closely with those of a full Bayesian analysis. J Clin Epidemiol 2004, 57(9):925-932.
• [13]Adler A, Roll S, Marowski B, Drossel R, Rehs H-U, Willich SN, Riese J, Wiedenmann B, Rosch T: Appropriateness of colonoscopy in the era of colorectal cancer screening: a prospective, multicenter study in a private-practice setting (Berlin Colonoscopy Project 1, BECOP 1). Dis Colon Rectum 2007, 50(10):1628-1638.
• [14]Ahmed S, Leslie A, Thaha MA, Carey FA, Steele RJ: Lower gastrointestinal symptoms are not predictive of colorectal neoplasia in a faecal occult blood screen-positive population. Br J Surg 2005, 92(4):478-481.
• [15]Bafandeh Y, Khoshbaten M, Eftekhar Sadat A-T, Farhang S: Clinical predictors of colorectal polyps and carcinoma in a low prevalence region: results of a colonoscopy based study. World J Gastroenterol 2008, 14(10):1534-1538.
• [16]Bat L, Pines A, Shemesh E, Levo Y, Zeeli D, Scapa E, Rosenblum Y: Colonoscopy in patients aged 80 years or older and its contribution to the evaluation of rectal bleeding. Postgrad Med J 1992, 68(799):355-358.
• [17]Berkowitz I, Kaplan M: Indications for colonoscopy. An analysis based on indications and diagnostic yield. S Afr Med J 1993, 83(4):245-248.
• [18]Bhatti MA, Kashif MA, Imran M: Colonoscopic evaluation of middle aged patients with altered bowel habits. Journal of the College of Physicians and Surgeons - Pakistan 2004, 14(8):481-484.
• [19]Bjerregaard NC, Tottrup A, Sorensen HT, Laurberg S: Diagnostic value of self-reported symptoms in Danish outpatients referred with symptoms consistent with colorectal cancer. Colorectal Dis 2007, 9(5):443-451.
• [20]Brenna E, Skreden K, Waldum HL, Marvik R, Dybdahl JH, Kleveland PM, Sandvik AK, Halvorsen T, Myrvold HE, Petersen H: The benefit of colonoscopy. Scand J Gastroenterol 1990, 25(1):81-88.
• [21]Brewster NT, Grieve DC, Saunders JH: Double-contrast barium enema and flexible sigmoidoscopy for routine colonic investigation. Br J Surg 1994, 81(3):445-447.
• [22]Chak A, Post AB, Cooper GS: Clinical variables associated with colorectal cancer on colonoscopy: a prediction model. Am J Gastroenterol 1996, 91(12):2483-2488.
• [23]Charalambopoulos A, Syrigos KN, Ho JL, Murday VA, Leicester RJ: Colonoscopy in symptomatic patients with positive family history of colorectal cancer. Anticancer Res 2000, 20(3B):1991-1994.
• [24]Cheong KL, Roohi S, Jarmin R, Sagap I, Tong SH, Qureshi A: The yield for colorectal cancer and adenoma by indication at colonoscopy. Med J Malaysia 2000, 55(4):464-466.
• [25]Curless R, French J, Williams GV, James OF: Comparison of gastrointestinal symptoms in colorectal carcinoma patients and community controls with respect to age. Gut 1994, 35(9):1267-1270.
• [26]de Bosset V, Froehlich F, Rey JP, Thorens J, Schneider C, Wietlisbach V, Vader JP, Burnand B, Muhlhaupt B, Fried M, Gonvers JJ: Do explicit appropriateness criteria enhance the diagnostic yield of colonoscopy? Endoscopy 2002, 34(5):360-368.
• [27]Douek M, Wickramasinghe M, Clifton MA: Does isolated rectal bleeding suggest colorectal cancer? Lancet 1999, 354(9176):393.
• [28]du Toit J, Hamilton W, Barraclough K: Risk in primary care of colorectal cancer from new onset rectal bleeding: 10 year prospective study. BMJ 2006, 333(7558):69-70.
• [29]Dukas L, Willett WC, Colditz GA, Fuchs CS, Rosner B, Giovannucci EL: Prospective study of bowel movement, laxative use, and risk of colorectal cancer among women. Am J Epidemiol 2000, 151(10):958-964.
• [30]Duncan JE, Sweeney WB, Trudel JL, Madoff RD, Mellgren AF, Duncan JE, Sweeney WB, Trudel JL, Madoff RD, Mellgren AF: Colonoscopy in the elderly: low risk, low yield in asymptomatic patients. Dis Colon Rectum 2006, 49(5):646-651.
• [31]Ellis BG, Thompson MR: Factors identifying higher risk rectal bleeding in general practice. Br J Gen Pract 2005, 55(521):949-955.
• [32]Farrands PA, Hardcastle JD: Colorectal screening by a self-completion questionnaire. Gut 1984, 25(5):445-447.
• [33]Ferraris R, Senore C, Fracchia M, Sciallero S, Bonelli L, Atkin WS, Segnan N, Score Working Group I: Predictive value of rectal bleeding for distal colonic neoplastic lesions in a screened population. Eur J Cancer 2004, 40(2):245-252.
• [34]Fijten GH, Starmans R, Muris JW, Schouten HJ, Blijham GH, Knottnerus JA: Predictive value of signs and symptoms for colorectal cancer in patients with rectal bleeding in general practice. Fam Pract 1995, 12(3):279-286.
• [35]Fontagnier EM, Manegold BC: [Colonoscopy in patients over 80 years of age. Indications, methods and results]. Dtsch Med Wochenschr 2000, 125(44):1319-1322.
• [36]Haenszel W, Berg JW, Segi M, Kurihara M, Locke FB: Large-bowel cancer in Hawaiian Japanese. J Natl Cancer Inst 1973, 51(6):1765-1779.
• [37]Hamilton W, Round A, Sharp D, Peters TJ: Clinical features of colorectal cancer before diagnosis: a population-based case-control study. Br J Cancer 2005, 93(4):399-405.
• [38]Higginson J: Etiological factors in gastrointestinal cancer in man. J Natl Cancer Inst 1966, 37(4):527-545.
• [39]Jacobs EJ, White E: Constipation, laxative use, and colon cancer among middle-aged adults. Epidemiology 1998, 9(4):385-391.
• [40]Jain M, Cook GM, Davis FG, Grace MG, Howe GR, Miller AB: A case-control study of diet and colorectal cancer. Int J Cancer 1980, 26(6):757-768.
• [41]Jensen J, Kewenter J, Swedenborg J: The correlation of symptoms, occult blood tests, and neoplasms in patients referred for double-contrast barium enema. Scand J Gastroenterol 1993, 28(10):911-914.
• [42]Kassa E: Colonoscopy in the investigation of colonic diseases. East Afr Med J 1996, 73(11):741-745.
• [43]Kojima M, Wakai K, Tokudome S, Tamakoshi K, Toyoshima H, Watanabe Y, Hayakawa N, Suzuki K, Hashimoto S, Ito Y, Tamakoshi A: Bowel movement frequency and risk of colorectal cancer in a large cohort study of Japanese men and women. Br J Cancer 2004, 90(7):1397-1401.
• [44]Kune GA, Kune S, Field B, Watson LF: The role of chronic constipation, diarrhea, and laxative use in the etiology of large-bowel cancer. Data from the Melbourne Colorectal Cancer Study. Dis Colon Rectum 1988, 31(7):507-512.
• [45]Lee JF-Y, Ng SS-M, Yiu RY-C, Leung K-L, Lau JW-Y: Colonoscopy in adult patients: A review of tis indications and its yield in detecting colorectal neoplasia. Annals of the College of Surgeons (Hong Kong) 2002, 6:48-52.
• [46]Leis VM, Hughes ML, Williams CB, Nuemaster TD, Ludwig DJ, Fontenelle LJ: Risk factors predictive of positive finding at colonoscopy. Curr Surg 2001, 58:227-229.
• [47]Leung WK, Ho KY, Kim W-h, Lau JYW, Ong E, Hilmi I, Kullavanijaya P, Wang C-y, Li C-j, Fujita R, Abdullah M, Tandon R, Sung JJY: Colorectal neoplasia in Asia: a multicenter colonoscopy survey in symptomatic patients. Gastrointest Endosc 2006, 64(5):751-759.
• [48]Mant A, Bokey EL, Chapuis PH, Killingback M, Hughes W, Koorey SG, Cook I, Goulston KJ, Dent OF: Rectal bleeding. Do other symptoms aid in diagnosis? Dis Colon Rectum 1989, 32(3):191-196.
• [49]Metcalf JV, Smith J, Jones R, Record CO: Incidence and causes of rectal bleeding in general practice as detected by colonoscopy. Br J Gen Pract 1996, 46(404):161-164.
• [50]Morini S, Hassan C, Meucci G, Toldi A, Zullo A, Minoli G: Diagnostic yield of open access colonoscopy according to appropriateness. Gastrointest Endosc 2001, 54(2):175-179.
• [51]Nakama H, Zhang B, Fattah A, Kamijo N, Fukazawa K: Relationships between a sign of rectal bleeding and the results of an immunochemical occult blood test, and colorectal cancer. Eur J Cancer Prev 2000, 9(5):325-328.
• [52]Nakamura GJ, Schneiderman LJ, Klauber MR: Colorectal cancer and bowel habits. Cancer 1984, 54(7):1475-1477.
• [53]Nascimbeni R, Donato F, Ghirardi M, Mariani P, Villanacci V, Salerni B: Constipation, anthranoid laxatives, melanosis coli, and colon cancer: a risk assessment using aberrant crypt foci. Cancer Epidemiol Biomarkers Prev 2002, 11(8):753-757.
• [54]Neugut AI, Garbowski GC, Waye JD, Forde KA, Treat MR, Tsai JL, Lee WC: Diagnostic yield of colorectal neoplasia with colonoscopy for abdominal pain, change in bowel habits, and rectal bleeding. Am J Gastroenterol 1993, 88(8):1179-1183.
• [55]Panzuto F, Chiriatti A, Bevilacqua S, Giovannetti P, Russo G, Impinna S, Pistilli F, Capurso G, Annibale B, Delle Fave G: Symptom-based approach to colorectal cancer: survey of primary care physicians in Italy. Dig Liver Dis 2003, 35(12):869-875.
• [56]Park Y, Freedman AN, Gail MH, Pee D, Hollenbeck A, Schatzkin A, Pfeiffer RM: Validation of a colorectal cancer risk prediction model among white patients age 50 years and older. J Clin Oncol 2009, 27(5):694-698.
• [57]Pernu J: An epidemiological study of the digestive organs and respiratory system. Annales Medicinae Internae Fenniae Supplementum 1960, 49(supp 33):1-117.
• [58]Roberts MC, Millikan RC, Galanko JA, Martin C, Sandler RS: Constipation, laxative use, and colon cancer in a North Carolina population. Am J Gastroenterol 2003, 98(4):857-864.
• [59]Robertson R, Campbell C, Weller DP, Elton R, Mant D, Primrose J, Nugent K, Macleod U, Sharma R: Predicting colorectal cancer risk in patients with rectal bleeding. Br J Gen Pract 2006, 56(531):763-767.
• [60]Sardinha TC, Nogueras JJ, Ehrenpreis ED, Zeitman D, Estevez V, Weiss EG, Wexner SD: Colonoscopy in octogenarians: a review of 428 cases. Int J Colorectal Dis 1999, 14(3):172-176.
• [61]Schoepfer A, Marbet UA: Colonoscopic findings of symptomatic patients aged 50 to 80 years suggest that work-up of tumour suspicious symptoms hardly reduces cancer-induced mortality. Swiss Med Wkly 2005, 135(45-46):679-683.
• [62]Selvachandran SN, Hodder RJ, Ballal MS, Jones P, Cade D: Prediction of colorectal cancer by a patient consultation questionnaire and scoring system: a prospective study. Lancet 2002, 360(9329):278-283.
• [63]Steine S, Stordahl A, Laerum F, Laerum E: Referrals for double-contrast barium examination. Factors influencing the probability of finding polyps or cancer. Scand J Gastroenterol 1994, 29(3):260-264.
• [64]Tan YM, Rosmawati M, Ranjeev P, Goh KL: Predictive factors by multivariate analysis for colorectal cancer in Malaysian patients undergoing colonoscopy. J Gastroenterol Hepatol 2002, 17(3):281-284.
• [65]Tate JJ, Royle GT: Open access colonoscopy for suspected colonic neoplasia. Gut 1988, 29(10):1322-1325.
• [66]Thompson MR, Perera R, Senapati A, Dodds S: Predictive value of common symptom combinations in diagnosing colorectal cancer. Br J Surg 2007, 94(10):1260-1265.
• [67]Vobecky J, Caro J, Devroede G: A case-control study of risk factors for large bowel carcinoma. Cancer 1983, 51(10):1958-1963.
• [68]Watanabe T, Nakaya N, Kurashima K, Kuriyama S, Tsubono Y, Tsuji I: Constipation, laxative use and risk of colorectal cancer: The Miyagi Cohort Study. Eur J Cancer 2004, 40(14):2109-2115.
• [69]Wauters H, Van Casteren V, Buntinx F: Rectal bleeding and colorectal cancer in general practice: diagnostic study. BMJ 2000, 321(7267):998-999.
• [70]Wynder EL, Kajitani T, Ishikawa S, Dodo H, Takano A: Environmental factors of cancer of the colon and rectum. II. Japanese epidemiological data. Cancer 1969, 23(5):1210-1220.
• [71]Wynder EL, Shigematsu T: Environmental factors of cancer of the colon and rectum. Cancer 1967, 20(9):1520-1561.
• [72]Zbar AP, Pignatelli M, Sherman D, Toomey P, Kmiot WA: An analysis of site-specific attributable pathologies for colorectal symptoms: diagnostic yield of colonoscopy. Colorectal Dis 1988., 1
• [73]Zerey M, Paton BL, Khan PD, Lincourt AE, Kercher KW, Greene FL, Heniford BT: Colonoscopy in the very elderly: a review of 157 cases. Surg Endosc 2007, 21(10):1806-1809.
• [74]Deeks JJ, Altman DG: Diagnostic tests 4: likelihood ratios. BMJ 2004, 329(7458):168-169.
• [75]Soares-Weiser K, Burch J, St John J, Smith S, Westwood M, Kleijnen J: Diagnostic accuracy and cost-effectiveness of faecal occult blood tests used in screening for colorectal cancer: A systematic review. York: Centre for Reviews and Dissemination; 2007.
• [76]Ford AC, Veldhuyzen van Zanten SJ, Rodgers CC, Talley NJ, Vakil NB, Moayyedi P, Veldhuyzen van Zanten SJO: Diagnostic utility of alarm features for colorectal cancer: systematic review and meta-analysis. Gut 2008, 57(11):1545-1553.
• [77]Jellema P, van der Windt DAWM, Bruinvels DJ, Mallen CD, van Weyenberg SJB, Mulder CJ, de Vet HCW: Value of symptoms and additional diagnostic tests for colorectal cancer in primary care: systematic review and meta-analysis. BMJ 2010, 340:c1269.
• [78]Olde Bekkink M, McCowan C, Falk GA, Teljeur C, Van de Laar FA, Fahey T: Diagnostic accuracy systematic review of rectal bleeding in combination with other symptoms, signs and tests in relation to colorectal cancer. Br J Cancer 2010, 102(1):48-58.
• [79]Shapley M, Mansell G, Jordan JL, Jordan KP: Positive predictive values of >= 5% in primary care for cancer: systematic review. Br J Gen Pract 2010, 60(578):e366-377.
• [80]Buck A, Gart J: Comparison of a screening test and a reference test in epidemiologic studies. I. Indices of agreement and their relation to prevalence. American Journal of Epidemiology 1966, 83(3):586-592.
• [81]Bossuyt PM, Reitsma JB, Bruns DE, Gatsonis CA, Glasziou PP, Irwig LM, Lijmer JG, Moher D, Rennie D, de Vet HCW: Towards complete and accurate reporting of studies of diagnostic accuracy: the STARD initiative. BMJ 2003, 326(7379):41-44.
• [82]Adelstein B-A, Irwig L, Macaskill P, Katelaris PH, Jones DB, Bokey L: A self administered reliable questionnaire to assess lower bowel symptoms. BMC Gastroenterol 2008, 8:8. BioMed Central Full Text