Invisible no more: a scoping review of the health care aide workforce literature

BMC Nursing

Greta G. Cummings¹  Shawna Reid¹  Heather L. Carleton¹  Trish L. Spiwek¹  Hanhmi Huynh¹  Sarah L. Cooper¹  Sarah J. Hewko¹ 

[1]CLEAR Outcomes Research Program, Faculty of Nursing, University of Alberta, Level 3, Edmonton Clinic Health Academy, 11405 87 Avenue, Edmonton T6G 1C9, AB, Canada

关键词: Health services accessibility;    Home care services;    Nursing homes;    Frail elderly;    Nurses’ aides;    Home health aides;    Review;    Health manpower;   

Others  :  1220733
DOI  :  10.1186/s12912-015-0090-x

 received in 2014-12-02, accepted in 2015-07-14,  发布年份 2015

【 摘 要 】

Background

Healthcare aides (HCAs) are the primary caregivers for vulnerable older persons. They have many titles and are largely unregulated, which contributes to their relative invisibility. The objective of this scoping review was to evaluate the breadth and depth of the HCA workforce literature.

Methods

We conducted a search of seven online bibliographic databases. Studies were included if published since 1995 in English, peer-reviewed journals. Results were iteratively synthesized within and across the following five categories: education, supply, use, demand and injury and illness.

Results

Of 5,045 citations screened, 82 studies met inclusion criteria. Few examined HCA education; particularly trainee characteristics, program location, length and content. Results in supply indicated that the average HCA was female, 36–45 years and had an education level of high school or less. Home health HCAs were, on average, older and were more likely to be immigrants than those working in other settings. The review of studies exploring HCA use revealed that their role was unclear – variation in duties, level of autonomy and work setting make describing “the” role of an HCA near impossible. Projected increased demand for HCAs and high rates of turnover, both at the profession and facility-level, elicit predictions of future HCA shortages. Home health HCAs experienced comparatively lower job stability, earned less, worked the fewest hours and were less likely to have fringe benefits than HCAs employed in hospitals and nursing homes. The review of studies related to HCA illness and injury revealed that they were at comparatively higher risk of injury than registered nurses and licensed practical nurses.

Conclusions

This is the largest, most comprehensive scoping review of HCA workforce literature to date. Our results indicate that the HCA workforce is both invisible and ubiquitous; as long as this is the case, governments and healthcare organizations will be limited in their ability to develop and implement feasible, effective HCA workforce plans. The continued undervaluation of HCAs adversely impacts care providers, the institutions they work for and those who depend on their care. Future workforce planning and research necessitates national HCA registries, or at minimum, directories.

【 授权许可】

   
2015 Hewko et al.

【 图 表 】

Fig. 1.

Fig. 2.

Fig. 3.

【 参考文献 】

• [1]Occupational Profile - Health Care Aide. Government of Alberta.. http://occinfo.alis.alberta.ca/occinfopreview/info/browse-occupations/occupation-profile.html?id=71003293 webcite
• [2]United States Census Bureau. U.S. Department of Commerce.. http://quickfacts.census.gov/qfd/states/00000.html webcite
• [3]Statistics Canada. Canada’s population estimates: Age and sex, 2013.. http://www.statcan.gc.ca/daily-quotidien/131125/dq131125a-eng.htm webcite
• [4]KPMG International. An uncertain age: reimagining long term care in the 21st century.. https://www.kpmg.com/Global/en/IssuesAndInsights/ArticlesPublications/an-uncertain-age/Documents/an-uncertain-age.pdf webcite
• [5]Prince M, Prina M, Guerceht M. World Alzheimer Report 2013: Journey of Caring.. http://www.alz.co.uk/research/WorldAlzheimerReport2013.pdf webcite
• [6]Bowling A, Mariotto A, Evans O: Are older people willing to give up their place in the queue for cardiac surgery to a younger person? Age Ageing 2002, 31(3):187-192.
• [7]Alzheimer Society of Canada. Rising Tide: The impact of dementia on Canadian society.. http://www.alzheimer.ca/~/media/Files/national/Advocacy/ASC_Rising_Tide_Full_Report_e.ashx webcite
• [8]Paraprofessional Healthcare Institute. Who are direct-care workers?. http://phinational.org/direct-care-workers-glance webcite
• [9]Zeller A, Hahn S, Needham I, Kok G, Dassen T, Halfens R: Aggressive behavior of nursing home residents toward caregivers: a systematic literature review. Geriatr Nurs 2009, 30(3):174-187.
• [10]Munn Z, Tufanaru C, Aromataris E: Recognition of the health assistant as a delegated clinical role and their inclusion in models of care: a systematic review and meta-synthesis of qualitative evidence. Int J Evid Based Healthc 2013, 11(1):3-19.
• [11]Birch S, Kephart G, Tomblin-Murphy G, O'Brien-Pallas L, Alder R, MacKenzie A: Human resources planning and the production of health: a needs-based analytical framework. Can Public Pol 2007, 33(S1):S1-S16.
• [12]Arksey H, O'Malley L: Scoping studies: towards a methodological framework. Int J Soc Res Methodol 2005, 8:19-32.
• [13]Levac D, Colquhoun H, O'Brien KK: Scoping studies: advancing the methodology. Impl Sci 2010, 5:69. BioMed Central Full Text
• [14]Budden JS: A national survey of medication aides: education, supervision, and work role by work setting. Geriatr Nurs 2012, 33(6):454-464.
• [15]Howe AL: Migrant care workers or migrants working in long-term care? A review of Australian experience. J Aging Soc Pol 2009, 21(4):374-392.
• [16]Lowell BL, Martin S, Stone R: Ageing and care giving in the United States: policy contexts and the immigrant workforce. J Popul Ageing 2010, 3(1–2):59-82.
• [17]Montgomery RJV, Holley L, Deichert J, Kosloski K: A profile of home care workers from the 2000 census: how it changes what we know. Gerontologist 2005, 45(5):593-600.
• [18]Nancarrow SA, Shuttleworth P, Tongue A, Brown L: Support workers in intermediate care. Health Soc Care Comm 2005, 13(4):338-344.
• [19]Oliveira BGR, Porto IS, Ferreira MA, Castro JBA: Profile of students registered in nursing auxillary and technician courses of the nursing worker professionalization project (PROFAE) in Rio de Janeiro -- Brazil. Rev Lat-Am Enfermagem 2007, 15(1):127-133.
• [20]Power M, Lavelle MJ: Qualifications of non-nursing residential care staff in the Republic of Ireland. Qual Ageing 2011, 12(3):152-161.
• [21]Sengupta M, Harris-Kojetin LD, Ejaz FK: A national overview of the training received by certified nursing assistants working in U.S. nursing homes. Gerontol Geriatr Educ 2010, 31(3):201-219.
• [22]Smith K, Baughman R: Caring for America’s aging population: a profile of the direct-care workforce. Mon Labor Rev 2007, 130(9):20-26.
• [23]Spilsbury K, Stuttard L, Adamson J, Atkin K, Borglin G, McCaughan D, et al.: Mapping the introduction of assistant practitioner roles in acute NHS (hospital) trusts in England. J Nurs Manage 2009, 17(5):615-626.
• [24]Squillace MR, Remsburg RE, Harris-Kojetin LD, Bercovitz A, Rosenoff E, Han B: The National Nursing Assistant Survey: improving the evidence base for policy initiatives to strengthen the Certified Nursing Assistant workforce. Gerontologist 2009, 49(2):185-197.
• [25]Thomas SA, Barter M, McLaughlin FE: State and territorial boards of nursing approaches to the use of unlicensed assistive personnel. J Nurs Admin 2000, 2(1):13-21.
• [26]Tyler DA, Jung H-Y, Feng Z, Mor V: Prevalence of nursing assistant training and certification programs within nursing homes, 1997–2007. Gerontologist 2010, 50(4):550-555.
• [27]Nugent LS: Can’t they get anything better? Home support workers call for change. Home Health Care Serv Q 2007, 26(2):21-39.
• [28]Jorgensen D, Parsons M, Reid MG, Weidenbohm K, Parsons J, Jacobs S: The providers’ profile of the disability support workforce in New Zealand. Health Soc Care Comm 2009, 17(4):396-405.
• [29]Keeney S, Hasson F, McKenna H: Health care assistants: the views of managers of health care agencies on training and employment. J Nurs Manage 2005, 13(1):83-92.
• [30]Seblega BK, Zhang NJ, Unruh LY, Breen G-M, Seung Chun P, Wan TT: Changes in nursing home staffing levels, 1997 to 2007. Med Care Res Rev 2010, 67(2):232-246.
• [31]Castle NG, Engberg J: Organizational characteristics associated with staff turnover in nursing homes. Gerontologist 2006, 46(1):62-73.
• [32]Hsieh P-C, Su H-F: Retention and attrition of certified care assistants in the long-term care industry from the Taipei area: an interview survey. Int J Nurs Stud 2007, 44:93-104.
• [33]Khatutsky G, Wiener JM, Anderson WL: Immigrant and non-immigrant certified nursing assistants in nursing homes: how do they differ? J Aging Soc Pol 2010, 22(3):267-287.
• [34]Menne HL, Ejaz FK, Noelker LS, Jones JA: Direct care workers’ recommendations for training and continuing education. Gerontol Geriatr Educ 2007, 28(2):91-108.
• [35]Sengupta M, Ejaz FK, Harris-Kojetin LD: Training of home health aides and nurse aides: findings from national data. Gerontol Geriatr Educ 2012, 33(4):383-401.
• [36]Svensson AL, Stroyer J, Ebbehoj NE, Mortensen OS: Factors predicting dropout in student nursing assistants. Occup Med 2008, 58(8):527-533.
• [37]Svensson A, Marott JL, Suadicani P, Mortensen OS, Ebbehoj NE: Sickness absence in student nursing assistants following a preventive intervention programme. Occup Med 2011, 61(1):57-61.
• [38]Welton JM: Hospital nursing workforce costs, wages, occupational mix, and resource utilization. J Nurs Admin 2011, 41(7):309-314.
• [39]Yamada Y: Profile of home care aides, nursing home aides, and hospital aides: historical changes and data recommendations. Gerontologist 2002, 42(2):199-206.
• [40]Lindquist L, Cameron K, Messerges-Bernstein J, Friesema E, Zickuhr L, Baker D, et al.: Hiring and screening processes of agencies supplying paid caregivers to older adults. J Am Geriatr Soc 2012, 60:1253-1259.
• [41]Sims-Gould J, Byrne K, Craven C, Martin-Matthews A, Keefe J: Why I became a home support worker: recruitment in the home health sector. Home Health Care Serv Q 2010, 29(4):171-194.
• [42]Baldwin J, Roberts JD, Fitzpatrick JI, While A, Cowan DT: The role of the support worker in nursing homes: a consideration of key issues. J Nurs Manage 2003, 11(6):410-420.
• [43]Hyer K, Molinari V, Kaplan M, Jones S: Credentialing dementia training: the Florida experience. Int Psychogeriatr 2010, 22(6):864-873.
• [44]Keefe JM, Knight L, Martin-Matthews A, Légaré J: Key issues in human resource planning for home support workers in Canada. Work 2011, 40(1):21-28.
• [45]Waldie J: Healthcare assistant role development: a literature review. J Adv Perioper Care 2010, 4(2):61-72.
• [46]Fletcher D, Rush D: The role, responsibilities and educational needs of the non-nurse carer. J Com Nurs 2001, 6:452-458.
• [47]Webb CS: Education for healthcare assistants working in acute NHS hospitals. Nurs Stand 2011, 25(41):41-46.
• [48]Bloom J, Duckett S, Robertson A: Development of an interactive model for planning the care workforce for Alberta: case study. Hum Resour Health 2012, 10:22-32. BioMed Central Full Text
• [49]Choi J, Johantgen M: The importance of supervision in retention of CNAs. Res Nurs Health 2012, 35:187-199.
• [50]D'Arcy LP, Sasai Y, Stearns SC: Do assistive devices, training, and workload affect injury incidence? Prevention efforts by nursing homes and back injuries among nursing assistants. J Adv Nurs 2012, 68(4):836-845.
• [51]Lee D, Coustasse A, Sikula AS: Transformational leadership and workplace injury and absenteeism: analysis of a National Nursing Assistant Survey. Health Care Manage Rev 2011, 36(4):380-387.
• [52]Price-Glynn K, Rakovski C: Who rides the glass escalator? Gender, race and nationality in the National Nursing Assistant Study. Work Employ Soc 2012, 26(5):699.
• [53]Probst JC, Baek JD, Laditka SB: Characteristics and recruitment paths of Certified Nursing Assistants in rural and urban nursing homes. J Rural Health 2009, 25(3):267-275.
• [54]Sloane PD, Williams CS, Zimmerman S: Immigrant status and intention to leave of nursing assistants in U.S. nursing homes. J Am Geriatr Soc 2010, 58:731-737.
• [55]Stearns SC, D'Arcy LP: Staying the course: facility and profession retention among nursing assistants in nursing homes. J Gerontol B Psychol Sci Soc Sc 2008, 63B(3):S113-S121.
• [56]Wiener JM, Squillace MR, Anderson WL, Khatutsky G: Why do they stay? Job tenure among Certified Nursing Assistants in nursing homes. Gerontologist 2009, 49(2):198-210.
• [57]Donoghue C: Nursing home staff turnover and retention: an analysis of national level data. J Appl Gerontol 2010, 29(1):89-106.
• [58]Temple A, Dobbs D, Andel R: Exploring correlates of turnover among nursing assistants in the National Nursing Home Survey. Health Care Manage Rev 2009, 34(2):182-190.
• [59]Temple A, Dobbs D, Andel R: The association between organizational characteristics and benefits offered to nursing assistants: results from the National Nursing Home Survey. Health Care Manage Rev 2010, 35(4):324-332.
• [60]Alamgir H, Cvitkovich Y, Yu S, Yassi A: Work-related injury among direct care occupations in British Columbia, Canada. Occup Environm Med 2007, 64:769-775.
• [61]Alamgir H, Ngan K, Drebit S, Li KH, Keen D: Predictors and economic burden of serious workplace falls in health care. Occup Med 2011, 61(4):234-240.
• [62]Alamgir H, Yu S, Chavoshi N, Ngan K: Occupational injury among full-time, part-time and casual health care workers. Occup Med 2008, 58:348-354.
• [63]Gorman E, Yu S, Alamgir H: When healthcare workers get sick: exploring sickness absenteeism in British Columbia, Canada. Work 2010, 35(2):117-123.
• [64]Ngan K, Drebit S, Siow S, Yu S, Keen D, Alamgir H: Risks and causes of musculoskeletal injuries among health care workers. Occup Med 2010, 60:389-394.
• [65]Giver H, Faber A, Hannerz H, Strøyer J, Rugulies R: Psychological well-being as a predictor of dropout among recently qualified Danish eldercare workers. Scand J Public Health 2010, 38(3):239-245.
• [66]Jensen LD, Ryom PK, Christensen MV, Andersen JH: Differences in risk factors for voluntary early retirement and disability pension: a 15-year follow-up in a cohort of nurses’ aides. BMJ Open 2012, 2:e000991.
• [67]Kachi Y, Inoue K, Toyokawa S: Associations between contractual status, part-time work, and intent to leave among professional caregivers for older people: results of a national cross-sectional survey in Japan. Int J Nurs Stud 2010, 47:1028-1036.
• [68]Nakanishi M, Imai H: Job role quality and intention to leave current facility and to leave profession of direct care workers in Japanese residential facilities for elderly. Arch Gerontol Geriatr 2012, 54:102-108.
• [69]Yamada Y, Sekiya M: Licensing and training requirements for direct care workers in Japan: what can the United States and Japan learn from each other? J Aging Soc Pol 2003, 15(4):113-129.
• [70]Eriksen W: Work factors and smoking cessation in nurses’ aides: a prospective cohort study. BMC Public Health 2005, 5:142. BioMed Central Full Text
• [71]Trinkoff AM, Johantgen M, Lerner N, Storr CL, Han K, McElroy K: State regulatory oversight of Certified Nursing Assistants and resident outcomes. J Nurs Regul 2013, 3(4):53-59.
• [72]Baughman RA, Smith KE: Labor mobility of the direct care workforce: Implications for the provision of long-term care. Health Econ 2012, 21:1402-1415.
• [73]Lipscomb J, Sokas R, McPhaul K, Scharf B, Barker P, Trinkoff A, et al.: Occupational blood exposure among unlicensed home care workers and home care registered nurses: are they protected? Am J Ind Med 2009, 52(7):563-570.
• [74]Lockard CB, Wolf M: Occupational employment projections to 2020. Mon Labor Rev 2012, 135(1):84-108.
• [75]Pillemer K, Meador R, Henderson C Jr, Robison J, Hegeman C, Graham E, et al.: A facility specialist model for improving retention of nursing home staff: results from a randomized, controlled study. Gerontologist 2008, 48(Special Issue I):80-89.
• [76]Potter SJ, Churilla A, Smith K: An examination of full-time employment in the direct-care workforce. J Appl Gerontol 2006, 25(5):356-374.
• [77]Ribas V, Dill JS, Cohen PN: Mobility for care workers: job changes and wages for nurse aides. Soc Sci Med 2012, 75:2183-2190.
• [78]Benjamin BA: Level of literacy in the nurses aide population: baseline data for nursing staff development. J Nurs Staff Dev 1997, 13(3):149-154.
• [79]Brannon D, Barry T, Kemper P, Schreiner A, Vasey J: Job perceptions and intent to leave among direct care workers: evidence from the Better Jobs Better Care demonstrations. Gerontologist 2007, 47(6):820-829.
• [80]Castle NG, Engberg J, Anderson R, Men A: Job satisfaction of nurse aides in nursing homes: intent to leave and turnover. Gerontologist 2007, 47(2):193-204.
• [81]Crown WH, Ahlburg DA, MacAdam M: The demographic and employment characteristics of home care aides: a comparison with nursing home aides, hospital aides, and other workers. Gerontologist 1995, 35(2):162-170.
• [82]Dill JS, Cagle J: Caregiving in a patient’s place of residence: turnover of direct care workers in home care and hospice agencies. J Aging Health 2010, 22(6):713-733.
• [83]Dill JS, Craft Morgan J, Konrad T: Strengthening the long-term care workforce: the influence of the WIN A STEP UP workplace intervention on the turnover of direct care workers. J Appl Gerontol 2010, 29(2):196-214.
• [84]Harmuth S: The direct care workforce crisis in long-term care. N C Med J 2002, 63(2):87-94.
• [85]Kash BA, Castle NG, Naufal GS, Hawes C: Effect of staff turnover on staffing: a closer look at registered nurses, licensed vocational nurses, and certified nursing assistants. Gerontologist 2006, 46(5):609-619.
• [86]Anderson RA, Corazzini KN, McDaniel RR Jr: Complexity science and the dynamics of climate and communication: reducing nursing home turnover. Gerontologist 2004, 44(3):378-388.
• [87]Kash BA, Castle NG, Phillips CD: Nursing home spending, staffing, and turnover. Health Care Manage Rev 2007, 32(3):253-262.
• [88]Castle N: State differences and facility differences in nursing home staff turnover. J Appl Gerontol 2008, 27(5):609-630.
• [89]Castle NG, Engberg J: Staff turnover and quality of care in nursing homes. Med Care 2005, 43(6):616-626.
• [90]Castle NG, Engberg J, Mendeloff J, Burns R: A national view of workplace injuries in nursing homes. Health Care Manage Rev 2009, 34(1):92-103.
• [91]Donoghue C, Castle NG: Leadership styles of nursing home administrators and their association with staff turnover. Gerontologist 2009, 49(2):166-174.
• [92]Brannon D, Zinn JS, Mor V, Davis J: An exploration of job, organizational, and environmental factors associated with high and low nursing assistant turnover. Gerontologist 2002, 42(2):159-168.
• [93]Konetzka RT, Stearns SC, Konrad TR, Magaziner J, Zimmerman S: Personal care aide turnover in residential care settings: an assessment of ownership, economic, and environmental factors. J Appl Gerontol 2005, 24(2):87-107.
• [94]McCaughey D, McGhan G, Kim J, Brannon D, Leroy H, Jablonski R: Workforce implications of injury among home health workers: evidence from the National Home Health Aide Survey. Gerontologist 2012, 52(4):493-505.
• [95]Savage M, Devine F, Cunningham N, Taylor M, Li Y, Hjellbrekke J, et al.: A new model of social class? Findings from the BBC’s Great British Class Survey experiment. Sociol 2013, 47(2):219-250.
• [96]Leana CR, Mittal V, Stiehl E: Organizational behavior and the working poor. Organ Sci 2012, 23(2):888-906.
• [97]Direct Care Alliance Inc. Leonila Vega: The making of an advocate.. http://blog.directcarealliance.org/2012/11/leonila-vega-the-making-of-an-advocate/ webcite
• [98]Direct Care Alliance Inc. Home care workers win minimum wage and overtime protections.. http://www.directcarealliance.org/document/docWindow.cfm?fuseaction=document.viewDocument&documentid=89&documentFormatId=95 webcite
• [99]Browne CV, Braun KL: Globalization, women’s migration, and the long-term-care workforce. Gerontologist 2008, 48(1):16-24.
• [100]Pyle JL, Ward KB: Recasting our understanding of gender and work during global restructuring. Int Sociol 2003, 18(3):461-489.
• [101]Committee on the Future Health Care Workforce for Older Americans. Retooling for an aging workforce: building the healthcare workforce.. http://www.iom.edu/Reports/2008/Retooling-for-an-Aging-America-Building-the-Health-Care-Workforce.aspx webcite
• [102]Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development. Sizing up the challeng ahead: future demographic trends and long-term care costs. In Help wanted? Providing and paying for long-term care.. http://www.oecd.org/els/health-systems/47836116.pdf webcite