Validity and timeliness of syndromic influenza surveillance during the autumn/winter wave of A (H1N1) influenza 2009: results of emergency medical dispatch, ambulance and emergency department data from three European regions

BMC Public Health

Helmut Brand²  Thomas Krafft²  Gernot Vergeiner⁴  Jean Bernard Gillet³  Luis Garcia-Castrillo Riesgo¹  Alexandra Ziemann²  Nicole Rosenkötter² 

[1] Department of Medical Sciences and Surgery, University of Cantabria, Santander, Spain;Department of International Health, CAPHRI School for Public Health and Primary Care, Faculty for Health, Medicine and Life Sciences, Maastricht University, Duboisdomein 30, Maastricht 6229 GT, The Netherlands;Department of Emergency Medicine, University Hospital Leuven, Leuven, Belgium;Dispatch Centre Tyrol, Innsbruck, Austria

关键词: Timeliness;    Specificity;    Sensitivity;    Emergency medical service;    Influenza;    Syndromic surveillance;    Public health surveillance;   

Others  :  1161717
DOI  :  10.1186/1471-2458-13-905

 received in 2012-12-30, accepted in 2013-09-24,  发布年份 2013

【 摘 要 】

Background

Emergency medical service (EMS) data, particularly from the emergency department (ED), is a common source of information for syndromic surveillance. However, the entire EMS chain, consists of both out-of-hospital and in-hospital services. Differences in validity and timeliness across these data sources so far have not been studied. Neither have the differences in validity and timeliness of this data from different European countries. In this paper we examine the validity and timeliness of the entire chain of EMS data sources from three European regions for common syndromic influenza surveillance during the A(H1N1) influenza pandemic in 2009.

Methods

We gathered local, regional, or national information on influenza-like illness (ILI) or respiratory syndrome from an Austrian Emergency Medical Dispatch Service (EMD-AT), an Austrian and Belgian ambulance services (EP-AT, EP-BE) and from a Belgian and Spanish emergency department (ED-BE, ED-ES). We examined the timeliness of the EMS data in identifying the beginning of the autumn/winter wave of pandemic A(H1N1) influenza as compared to the reference data. Additionally, we determined the sensitivity and specificity of an aberration detection algorithm (Poisson CUSUM) in EMS data sources for detecting the autumn/winter wave of the A(H1N1) influenza pandemic.

Results

The ED-ES data demonstrated the most favourable validity, followed by the ED-BE data. The beginning of the autumn/winter wave of pandemic A(H1N1) influenza was identified eight days in advance in ED-BE data. The EP data performed stronger in data sets for large catchment areas (EP-BE) and identified the beginning of the autumn/winter wave almost at the same time as the reference data (time lag +2 days). EMD data exhibited timely identification of the autumn/winter wave of A(H1N1) but demonstrated weak validity measures.

Conclusions

In this study ED data exhibited the most favourable performance in terms of validity and timeliness for syndromic influenza surveillance, along with EP data for large catchment areas. For the other data sources performance assessment delivered no clear results. The study shows that routinely collected data from EMS providers can augment and enhance public health surveillance of influenza by providing information during health crises in which such information must be both timely and readily obtainable.

【 授权许可】

   
2013 Rosenkötter et al.; licensee BioMed Central Ltd.

【 图 表 】

Figure 1.

Figure 2.

Figure 3.

【 参考文献 】

• [1]Fleming DM, van der Velden J, Paget WJ: The evolution of influenza surveillance in Europe and prospects for the next 10 years. Vaccine 2003, 21(16):1749-1753.
• [2]Paget J, Marquet R, Meijer A, van der Velden K: Influenza activity in Europe during eight seasons (1999–2007): an evaluation of the indicators used to measure activity and an assessment of the timing, length and course of peak activity (spread) across Europe. BMC Infect Dis 2007, 7:141. BioMed Central Full Text
• [3]Weekly influenza surveillance overview. http://ecdc.europa.eu/en/publications/surveillance_reports/influenza/Pages/weekly_influenza_surveillance_overview.aspx webcite
• [4]Paquet C, Coulombier D, Kaiser R, Ciotti M: Epidemic intelligence: a new framework for strengthening disease surveillance in Europe. Euro Surveill 2006, 11(12):212-214.
• [5]Triple S: Assessment of syndromic surveillance in Europe. Lancet 2011, 378(9806):1833-1834.
• [6]Griffin BA, Jain AK, Davies-Cole J, Glymph C, Lum G, Washington SC, Stoto MA: Early detection of influenza outbreaks using the DC Department of Health’s syndromic surveillance system. BMC Public Health 2009, 9:483. BioMed Central Full Text
• [7]Zheng W, Aitken R, Muscatello DJ, Churches T: Potential for early warning of viral influenza activity in the community by monitoring clinical diagnoses of influenza in hospital emergency departments. BMC Public Health 2007, 7:250. BioMed Central Full Text
• [8]Mostashari F, Fine A, Das D, Adams J, Layton M: Use of ambulance dispatch data as an early warning system for communitywide influenzalike illness. New York City. J Urban Health 2003, 80(2 Suppl 1):i43-49.
• [9]Bork KH, Klein BM, Molbak K, Trautner S, Pedersen UB, Heegaard E: Surveillance of ambulance dispatch data as a tool for early warning. Euro Surveill 2006, 11(12):229-233.
• [10]Smith S, Smith GE, Olowokure B, Ibbotson S, Foord D, Maguire H, Pebody R, Charlett A, Hippisley-Cox J, Elliot AJ: Early spread of the 2009 influenza A(H1N1) pandemic in the United Kingdom--use of local syndromic data, May-August 2009. Euro Surveill 2011, 16(3):pii: 19771.
• [11]Kavanagh K, Robertson C, Murdoch H, Crooks G, McMenamin J: Syndromic surveillance of influenza-like illness in Scotland during the influenza A H1N1v pandemic and beyond. Journal of the Royal Statistics Society: Series A (Statistics in Society) 2012, 175(4):939-958.
• [12]Kara EO, Elliot AJ, Bagnall H, Foord DG, Pnaiser R, Osman H, Smith GE, Olowokure B: Absenteeism in schools during the 2009 influenza A(H1N1) pandemic: a useful tool for early detection of influenza activity in the community? Epidemiol Infect 2011, 140(7):1328-1336.
• [13]Schmidt WP, Pebody R, Mangtani P: School absence data for influenza surveillance: a pilot study in the United Kingdom. Euro Surveill 2010, 15(3):pii: 19467.
• [14]Das D, Metzger K, Heffernan R, Balter S, Weiss D, Mostashari F: Monitoring over-the-counter medication sales for early detection of disease outbreaks–New York City. MMWR Morb Mortal Wkly Rep 2005, 54(Suppl):41-46.
• [15]Linge JP, Steinberger R, Weber TP, Yangarber R, van der Goot E, Al Khudhairy DH, Stilianakis NI: Internet surveillance systems for early alerting of health threats. Euro Surveill 2009, 14(13):pii: 19162.
• [16]Valdivia A, Lopez-Alcalde J, Vicente M, Pichiule M, Ruiz M, Ordobas M: Monitoring influenza activity in Europe with Google Flu Trends: comparison with the findings of sentinel physician networks - results for 2009–10. Euro Surveill 2010, 15(29):pii: 19621.
• [17]Medical Information System (MedISys). http://medusa.jrc.it/medisys/homeedition/en/home.html webcite
• [18]Fouillet A, Sala-Soler M, Conti S, Kanieff M, Rago G, Perrin J, Dupuy C, Krafft T, Ziemann A, Viso AC: Inventory of syndromic surveillance systems in Europe by the triple-S project. Emerging Health Threats Journal 2011, 4:10946.
• [19]Ziemann A, Krafft T, Rosenkötter N, Garcia-Castrillo Riesgo L, Vergeiner G, Fischer M, Lippert F, Krämer A, Pinheiro P, Brand H, et al.: Syndromic surveillance: enhancing public health responsiveness to global change - a european perspective. IHDP Update 2011, 1:12-18.
• [20]Krafft T, Garcia Castrillo-Riesgo L, Edwards S, Fischer M, Overton J, Robertson-Steel I, Konig A: European Emergency Data Project (EED Project): EMS data-based health surveillance system. Eur J Public Health 2003, 13(3 Suppl):85-90.
• [21]Buehler JW, Hopkins RS, Overhage JM, Sosin DM, Tong V: Framework for evaluating public health surveillance systems for early detection of outbreaks: recommendations from the CDC Working Group. MMWR Recomm Rep 2004, 53(RR-5):1-11.
• [22]Amato-Gauci A, Zucs P, Snacken R, Ciancio B, Lopez V, Broberg E, Penttinen P, Nicoll A: Surveillance trends of the 2009 influenza A(H1N1) pandemic in Europe. Euro Surveill 2011, 16(26):pii: 19903.
• [23]European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control: The 2009 A(H1N1) pandemic in Europe. In A review of the experience. Stockholm: ECDC; 2010.
• [24]SIDARTHa - European emergency data-based syndromic surveillance system. http://www.sidartha.eu webcite
• [25]Hofmarcher MM, Rack H-M: Austria: health system review. Health Syst Transit 2006, 8(3):1-275.
• [26]Van Casteren V, Mertens K, Antoine J, Wanyama S, Thomas I, Bossuyt N: Clinical surveillance of the influenza a (H1N1) 2009 pandemic through the network of sentinel general practitioners. Archives of Public Health 2010, 68(2):62-67. BioMed Central Full Text
• [27]Schmidt D, Liu YL, Lachner P: Influenza in österreich, saison 2009/2010. In Nationale Referenzzentrale für Influenza-Epidemiologie. Wien: Agentur für Gesundheit und Ernährungssicherheit; 2011.
• [28]Influenza case definitions. http://ecdc.europa.eu/en/activities/surveillance/EISN/surveillance/Pages/influenza_case_definitions.aspx webcite
• [29]Greenko J, Mostashari F, Fine A, Layton M: Clinical evaluation of the Emergency Medical Services (EMS) ambulance dispatch-based syndromic surveillance system. New York City. J Urban Health 2003, 80(2 Suppl 1):i50-56.
• [30]May LS, Griffin BA, Bauers NM, Jain A, Mitchum M, Sikka N, Carim M, Stoto MA: Emergency department chief complaint and diagnosis data to detect influenza-like illness with an electronic medical record. West J Emerg Med 2010, 11(1):1-9.
• [31]Rosenkötter N, Kauhl B, Garcilla-Castrillo Riesgo L, Diaz FJL, Kraan J, Ziemann A, Schorbahn M, Krafft T, Brand H: Retrospective data analysis and simulation study as basis for an automated syndromic surveillance system - results from the SIDARTHa project. SIDARTHa. Bad Honnef 2010. http://www.sidartha.eu/publications.html webcite
• [32]Burkom H: Alerting algorithms for biosurveillance. In Disease surveillance: a public health informatics approach. Edited by Lombardo JS, Buckeridge DL. Hoboeken New Jersey: John Wiley & Sons Inc; 2007:159-163.
• [33]Lucas JM, Crosier RB: Fast initial response for CUSUM quality-control schemes: give your CUSUM a head start. Technometrics 1982, 24(3):199-205.
• [34]Lucas JM: Counted data CUSUM’s. Technometrics 1985, 27(2):129-144.
• [35]Dailey L, Watkins RE, Plant AJ: Timeliness of data sources used for influenza surveillance. J Am Med Inform Assoc 2007, 14(5):626-631.
• [36]SPSS: SPSS Trends, 10.0. Chicago: SPSS Inc.; 1999.
• [37]Cowling BJ, Wong IO, Ho LM, Riley S, Leung GM: Methods for monitoring influenza surveillance data. Int J Epidemiol 2006, 35(5):1314-1321.
• [38]Plagianos MG, Wu WY, McCullough C, Paladini M, Lurio J, Buck MD, Calman N, Soulakis N: Syndromic surveillance during pandemic (H1N1) 2009 outbreak, New York, New York. USA. Emerg Infect Dis 2011, 17(9):1724-1726.
• [39]Schrell S, Ziemann A, Garcia-Castrillo Riesgo L, Rosenkotter N, Llorca J, Popa D, Krafft T, on Behalf of the SPC: Local implementation of a syndromic influenza surveillance system using emergency department data in Santander, Spain. J Public Health (Oxf) 2013, 5(3):397-403.
• [40]Garcia-Armesto S, Abadia-Taira MB, Durán A, Hernández-Quevedo C, Bernal-Delgado E: Spain: health systems review. Health Syst Transit 2010, 12(4):1-295.
• [41]Gerkens S, Merkur S: Belgium: health system review. Health Syst Transit 2010, 12(5):1-266.
• [42]Coory MD, Kelly H, Tippett V: Assessment of ambulance dispatch data for surveillance of influenza-like illness in Melbourne. Australia. Public Health 2009, 123(2):163-168.
• [43]Hutwagner LC, Maloney EK, Bean NH, Slutsker L, Martin SM: Using laboratory-based surveillance data for prevention: an algorithm for detecting Salmonella outbreaks. Emerg Infect Dis 1997, 3(3):395-400.
• [44]Buckeridge DL: Outbreak detection through automated surveillance: a review of the determinants of detection. J Biomed Inform 2007, 40(4):370-379.
• [45]Craigmile PF, Kim N, Fernandez SA, Bonsu BK: Modeling and detection of respiratory-related outbreak signatures. BMC Med Inform Decis Mak 2007, 7:28. BioMed Central Full Text
• [46]Lemay R, Mawudeku A, Shi Y, Ruben M, Achonu C: Syndromic surveillance for influenzalike illness. Biosecur Bioterror 2008, 6(2):161-170.
• [47]Sosin DM: Draft framework for evaluating syndromic surveillance systems. J Urban Health 2003, 80(2 Suppl 1):i8-13.