Career shift phenomenon among doctors in tacloban city, philippines: lessons for retention of health workers in developing countries

Asia Pacific Family Medicine

Meredith P Labarda¹ 

[1] School of Health Sciences, University of the Philippines-Manila in Palo, Leyte, the Philippines

关键词: job satisfaction/dissatisfaction;    health workers;    retention;    immigration/emigration/migration;    nurses;    doctors;    Career-shift;   

Others  :  790670
DOI  :  10.1186/1447-056X-10-13

 received in 2011-04-20, accepted in 2011-10-06,  发布年份 2011

【 摘 要 】

Background

At the height of the global demand for nurses in the 1990s, a phenomenon of grave concern arose. A significant number of medical doctors in the Philippines shifted careers in order to seek work as nurses overseas. The obvious implications of such a trend require inquiry as to the reasons for it; hence, this cross-sectional study. The data in the study compared factors such as personal circumstances, job satisfaction/dissatisfaction, perceived benefits versus costs of the alternative job, and the role of social networks/linkages among doctors classified as career shifters and non-shifters.

Methodology

A combined qualitative and quantitative method was utilized in the study. Data gathered came from sixty medical doctors practicing in three major hospitals in Tacloban City, Philippines, and from a special nursing school also located in the same city. Respondents were chosen through a non-probability sampling, specifically through a chain referral sampling owing to the controversial nature of the research. A set of pre-set criteria was used to qualify doctors as shifters and non-shifters. Cross-tabulation was carried out to highlight the differences between the two groups. Finally, the Wilcoxon-Mann-Whitney test was utilized to assess if these differences were significant.

Results

Among the different factors investigated, results of the study indicated that the level of job satisfaction or dissatisfaction and certain socio-demographic factors such as age, length of medical practice, and having children to support, were significantly different among shifters and non-shifters at p ≤ 0.05. This suggested that such factors had a bearing on the intention to shift to a nursing career among physicians.

Conclusion

Taken in the context of the medical profession, it was the level of job satisfaction/dissatisfaction that was the immediate antecedent in the intention to shift careers among medical doctors. Personal factors, specifically age, support of children, and the length of medical practice gained explanatory power when they were linked to job satisfaction or dissatisfaction. On the other hand, factors such as perceived benefits and costs of the alternative job and the impact of social networks did not differ between shifters and non-shifters. It would then indicate that efforts to address the issue of physician retention need to go beyond economic incentives and deal with other sources of satisfaction or dissatisfaction among practicing physicians. Since this was an exploratory study in a particular locale in central Philippines, similar studies in other parts of the country need to be done to gain better understanding of this phenomenon at a national level.

【 授权许可】

   
2011 Labarda; licensee BioMed Central Ltd.

【 参考文献 】

• [1]Bach S: International mobility of health professionals: Brain drain or brain exchange. In International Mobility of Talent. UNU:WIDER; 2006:82.
• [2]Ronquillo K, Elegado-Lorenzo F, Nodora R: Human resources for health migration in the Philippines: A case study and policy directions. ASEAN Learning Network for Human Resources for Health: 2-5 August 2005; Bangkok, Thailand
• [3]Sison M: Health system suffers brain drain. [http://ipsnews.net/migration/stories/braindrain.html] webcite
• [4]Lorenzo F, Galvez-Tan J, Icamina K, Javier L: Nurse migration from a source country perspective: Philippine country case study. Health Services Research 2007, 42:1406-1418.
• [5]World Health Organization: WHO Health Statistics 2010. Geneva;
• [6]Sandefur G: Black/white differences in job shift behavior: A dynamic analysis. Sociology Quarter 1981, 22:565-79.
• [7]Rosenfeld R: Job mobility and career processes. Annual Reviews in Sociology 1992, 18:39-61.
• [8]Breen R: Job changing and job loss in the Irish youth labour-market: A test of general model. European Sociological Review 1992, 8,2:113-125.
• [9]Felmlee D: Women's job mobility processes within and between employers. American Sociological Review 1982, 47:142-151.
• [10]Inkeles A, Rossi P: National comparisons of occupational prestige. The American Journal of Sociology 1956, 61,4:329-339.
• [11]Robbins SP, Judge TA: Organizational Behavior. 12th edition. New Jersey: Pearson and Prentice Hall; 2007:169-171.
• [12]McMurray JE, Williams E, Schwartz MD, Douglas J, Van Kirk J, Robert Konrad T, Gerrity M, Bigby JA, Linzer M: Physician job satisfaction: Developing a model using qualitative data. Journal of General Internal Medicine 1997, 12(11):711-714.
• [13]Groot W, Verberne M: Aging, job mobility, and compensation. Oxford Economics Papers 1997, 49:380-402.
• [14]Wu L: Job placement and job shift across employment sectors in China: The effect of education, family background and gender. PhD dissertation, University of Maryland; 2006.
• [15]Stamps P, Piedmont E, Slavitt D, Haase A: Measurement of work satisfaction among health professionals. Medical Care 1978, 16:4, 337-352.
• [16]Blades DS, Ferguson G, Richardson HC, Redfern N: A study of junior doctors to investigate the factors that influence career decisions. British Journal of General Practice 2000, 50:483-485.
• [17]Herzberg F: Work and the Nature of Man. Cleveland: World Publishing Co; 1966.
• [18]Katz F: Occupational contact networks. Social Forces 1958, 37,1:52-55.
• [19]Ioannides Y, Loury L: Job information networks, neighborhood effects, and inequality. Journal of Economic Literature 2004, 42,4:1056-1093.