Scenario uncertainties assessment within whole building LCA

SUSTAINABLE BUILT ENVIRONMENT D-A-CH CONFERENCE 2019

生态环境科学

Guimaraes, G.D.^1 ; Saade, M.R.M.^1^2 ; Zara, O.O.C.^1 ; Silva, V.G.^1

School of Civil Engineering, Architecture and Urban Design, Department of Architecture and Construction, University of Campinas, Brazil^1

Université de, Sherbrooke, Canada^2

关键词: Cumulative energy demands;    Dominant contributions;    End of life managements;    Environmental decision supports;    Global sensitivity analysis;    Global warming potential;    Life Cycle Assessment (LCA);    Uncertainty assessment;   

Others  :  https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1088/1755-1315/323/1/012059/pdf
DOI  :  10.1088/1755-1315/323/1/012059

学科分类：环境科学（综合）

来源: IOP

【 摘 要 】

Uncertainties evaluation is increasingly gaining traction within life cycle assessment (LCA), due to its key role as environmental decision support tool. When applied at whole-building scale, the large variety of materials, subjective choices and long lifespans introduce parameter, scenario and model uncertainties throughout the life cycle. Since normative choices are unavoidable within whole-building LCA (wbLCA), in this article we carried out a so-called 'scenario' uncertainty assessment for one illustrative case study. First, three uncertainty sources were selected, to include the two drivers most frequently cited in literature (reference service life and end of life management alternatives) and material wastage, a relevant issue to factor in variable construction optimization levels in contexts like Brazil. Cumulative energy demand (CED) and CML 2001 v.2.05 methods were used for calculating deterministic values of non-renewable embodied energy and global warming potential in SimaPro 7.3 The uncertainty assessment combined scenario analysis, stochastic modelling (Monte Carlo simulation of triangular probability distributions for the uncertainty drivers investigated) and global sensitivity analysis (GSA). The GSA confirmed the dominant contribution of the operational phase - strongly influenced by components replacement rate - to of life cycle non-renewable embodied energy and global warming potential result variance, whilst construction and end of life stages showed no correlation with life cycle results. Findings from this research also highlight the strategic importance of gathering service life information adherent to the assessed context. Building components replacement rates induced by the Brazilian standard are overestimated relatively to international figures used in LCAs worldwide.